Wedding Etiquette Forum

Help! How to invite a guest against a parental wish

Help!

My fiancee has a friend from high school who he's stayed close with over the years. His mom and stepdad are not fond of this friend due to some partying that took place at her house when he was in high school. High school was 8 years ago for him....and people change!

I've come to know this friend over the last couple years and she's great! She has now become OUR friend. Yeah, when my fiancee was in high school, she was older, and he would party at her house. But since that time she's been married, had a child, and has completely changed! She's as loyal of a friend as you could ask for.

Shortly after we got engaged my fiancee got a phone call from his mom...his stepfather apparently had voiced his opinion on this friend being invited to OUR wedding that WE are paying for! Apparently, he is threatening to not attend our wedding if this friend is there. My fiancee's mom understands that this is OUR day and thinks we should be able to invite whoever we want. She is willing to let the past remain in the past for one day, and has had no luck convincing his stepfather to do the same. This friend lives in Tennessee (the wedding is in Wisconsin), and we don't even know if she would be able to make the trip for the wedding, but we think we should be able to extend the invitation to her.

It's been a couple months since this conversation first happened, and we haven't heard an update from his mom on the subject. How do we re-address this issue, making our wishes to invite her clear without creating tension?!?!

Has anyone else come across this or a similar issue? And how was it resolved?

P.S. I have not taken this friend off our guest list. Maybe I'm being selfish? I'm open to any and all thoughts on this issue!

Re: Help! How to invite a guest against a parental wish

  • Since you and your FI are paying for this wedding you are free to invite whoever you want.  I think his stepfather is being a bit ridiculous to still hold a grudge over something that occurred when your FI was in high school.  FFS kids in high school do stupid and immature, selfish things because high schoolers are immature and selfish by nature.

    I would just invite her and not say anything to his Dad about it.  If his Dad asks then your FI should tell him that she is invited and that if that one person prevents him from coming to his wedding then he will be missed (basically call his bluff).

    Agreed. Invite but don't bring up that she was invited to his stepfather unless he specifically asks.
    "There is always some madness in love. But there is also always some reason in madness." -Friedrich Nietzsche, "On Reading and Writing"
  • Invite her - you don't need to clear it with anyone since you're paying. If Stepdad chooses not to attend his stepson's wedding because of that...he'll be the one who looks like a jerk. A total jerk. 
  • Agree with PPs. Stepfather is being very immature. I would invite her and try not to stress about it too much until you receive a response. They have no right to dictate who attends your wedding or guilt you out of inviting the important people in your life.
    image
  • syoun1nj said:
    Invite her - you don't need to clear it with anyone since you're paying. If Stepdad chooses not to attend his stepson's wedding because of that...he'll be the one who looks like a jerk. A total jerk. 
    Totally agree. That's honestly ridiculous that the step dad is behaving like that. It's your wedding that you are paying for. You're free to invite whomever you'd like. 
  • kalchbr2 said:

    Help!


    My fiancee has a friend from high school who he's stayed close with over the years. His mom and stepdad are not fond of this friend due to some partying that took place at her house when he was in high school. High school was 8 years ago for him....and people change!

    I've come to know this friend over the last couple years and she's great! She has now become OUR friend. Yeah, when my fiancee was in high school, she was older, and he would party at her house. But since that time she's been married, had a child, and has completely changed! She's as loyal of a friend as you could ask for.

    Shortly after we got engaged my fiancee got a phone call from his mom...his stepfather apparently had voiced his opinion on this friend being invited to OUR wedding that WE are paying for! Apparently, he is threatening to not attend our wedding if this friend is there. My fiancee's mom understands that this is OUR day and thinks we should be able to invite whoever we want. She is willing to let the past remain in the past for one day, and has had no luck convincing his stepfather to do the same. This friend lives in Tennessee (the wedding is in Wisconsin), and we don't even know if she would be able to make the trip for the wedding, but we think we should be able to extend the invitation to her.

    It's been a couple months since this conversation first happened, and we haven't heard an update from his mom on the subject. How do we re-address this issue, making our wishes to invite her clear without creating tension?!?!

    Has anyone else come across this or a similar issue? And how was it resolved?

    P.S. I have not taken this friend off our guest list. Maybe I'm being selfish? I'm open to any and all thoughts on this issue!
    Agree with everyone else

    Wedding Countdown Ticker
    image
  • What? That's crazy. You're adults and you're paying for your own wedding. You don't need his parents permission to invite your friends. If FSF threatens not to attend, tell him you'll miss him. Don't let a childish adult manipulate you.
                       
  • If I was your FI I'd say, "SF, we understand that you may not like this person but she is a dear friend and absolutely is on the guest list. If that affects your decision to attend it is most unfortunate. "

  • I would just invite her and not even bring it up to them.  They don't get to decide who you invite, or who you are friends with.

    Wedding Countdown Ticker
  • Are we sure there isn't something else going on with the stepfathers hatred for this girl? Seems like quite a reaction to a girl who was a partier in high school and is now grown, married and has a kid. 
  • His stepdad DOES know he's an adult, right?
    What did you think would happen if you walked up to a group of internet strangers and told them to get shoehorned by their lady doc?~StageManager14
    image
  • His stepdad needs to butt out.  It's not up to him who gets invited to an event he's not paying for.
  • jnissajnissa member
    100 Love Its 100 Comments First Anniversary Name Dropper
    edited March 2014
    "Are we sure there isn't something else going on with the stepfathers hatred for this girl? Seems like quite a reaction to a girl who was a partier in high school and is now grown, married and has a kid."

    That exactly. It's hard to read this story without thinking he was looking for an excuse to create wedding drama. 
This discussion has been closed.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards