this is the code for the render ad
Wedding Etiquette Forum

Uncle wants to bring new girlfriend to wedding (ignore double post, sorry)

jmichlikjmichlik member
Fourth Anniversary 10 Comments
edited May 2014 in Wedding Etiquette Forum
Hi everyone,

I am mostly a lurker on here, occasional poster, and I was hoping for some opinions on a situation that has arisen with my sister's upcoming wedding this July. Here is the backstory:

My uncle and aunt (she was my mom's oldest sister) were married for over 30 years when my aunt passed away 3 years ago. She had been diagnosed with a rare neurological condition but was on medication and seemed to be doing okay even if she was not her "usual" self anymore. Both my aunt and uncle attended my wedding and seemed to have a good time, then a few days later my uncle came home and found her dead on the floor. It was a huge shock to my whole family, especially my grandmother, who is still very sad about losing her daughter so unexpectedly. My uncle was devastated of course and refused to date for some time, but about a year ago (two years after her death) he did start dating again after being encouraged by my mom. She told him he would always be a part of our family no matter what and she did not want him to have to be alone for the rest of his life. While my mom has been supportive of my uncle dating again, many of my relatives are still too upset about my aunt's death to feel the same. They have told my uncle that they are not going to stop him from seeing other women but they do not want to meet anyone he dates, and it is clear they are really not comfortable with him having girlfriends.

So then we come to my sister's wedding. I have read enough posts on TK to know that SO's are always supposed to be invited to weddings except in rare situations such as people who may be violent or hurt other guests, so to me it seems that uncle's girlfriend should be invited. However, my mom has said that because so many relatives are upset about his dating again my uncle is being invited by himself, not with his girlfriend. I was wondering if I could get some opinions from the folks on here: am I right that his girlfriend should be invited no matter what, or should she not be invited to respect the family's wishes?
Anniversary

Re: Uncle wants to bring new girlfriend to wedding (ignore double post, sorry)

  • Sorry, double post by accident
    Anniversary
  • You're right! She gets invited. The rest of your family can GTFO their belief that he should be dating.

    His wife died and that was tragic but it's been three years. He is more than allowed to date again and your family (as you well know) is being flatly unreasonable.

    Also, if he ends up marrying this GF, she's now In the family and then what?
    Anniversary

    image
    I'm gonna go with 'not my circus, not my monkeys.'
  • phiraphira member
    5000 Comments 500 Love Its Second Anniversary 5 Answers
    Soooo many double/triple/quadruple posts since the update! No worries.

    You are right--his girlfriend should be invited. These relatives who would be upset have no grounds for this demand. Death is very hard to deal with, and everyone processes it differently and takes more or less time to grieve. But your uncle is not doing anything wrong. He's not betraying your aunt by finding someone else. He did not cheat on her. Dating again does not mean he didn't (or doesn't still) love her.
    Anniversary
    now with ~* INCREASED SASSINESS *~
    image
  • Yes, she should be invited. Your family members should be ashamed of themselves for not allowing this man to move on with his life after experiencing such a tragic loss.
    What did you think would happen if you walked up to a group of internet strangers and told them to get shoehorned by their lady doc?~StageManager14
    image
  • Yes your uncle should be able to bring his new girlfriend.    


    I think it's pretty selfish of the family to think otherwise.  It's not like they divorced and there is bad blood.  She died and 3 years ago at that.  He has a right to move on and the family needs to get over the fact he has a new girlfriend.

    My aunt also started dating someone about 2-3 years after my uncle died.  They have been together for 10 years now.  I can't imagine telling her "M" is not welcome at family events. Sure it was strange, maybe even odd to see her with someone other than my uncle, but it's a non-issue now.  M is an awesome guy and my aunt is happy with him.  They compliment each other.   We still tell funny stories about my uncle with M around.   M tells funny stories about his own wife who had also passed away.    It's a new chapter for them (and us), but the old one didn't disappear. 






    What differentiates an average host and a great host is anticipating unexpressed needs and wants of their guests.  Just because the want/need is not expressed, doesn't mean it wouldn't be appreciated. 
  • She should definitely be invited. FI's aunt died after a long battle with cancer, and his uncle began dating again pretty shortly afterwards. There was some side-eyeing going on, but the guy was lonely! He ended up marrying the woman he was seeing, and they've now been married for like 5 years. She's a lovely woman who everyone loves to pieces - and FI's uncle is so very happy. Everyone is entitled to feel how they feel, but it's unfair for anyone to expect your uncle to not move on with his life.
    ~*~*~*~*~

  • It's sad that your Uncle's family is so against him dating.  They should be happy that he is getting back into life and finding happiness.  I hope that you can stand up to your mom and family to make sure they don't give him and his girlfriend a hard time.  You are absolutely right that he should be invited with her.
  • It's sad that your Uncle's family is so against him dating.  They should be happy that he is getting back into life and finding happiness.  I hope that you can stand up to your mom and family to make sure they don't give him and his girlfriend a hard time.  You are absolutely right that he should be invited with her.
    It's the deceased aunt's family that is upset.   And I kind-of get it.   Looking at him must bring back memories that their sister/aunt/whatever is no longer with them.  But they need to get over it and not project their own feelings on mourning on to others.  We all mourn differently and dating someone 3 years after a spouse dies does not make him a jerk.






    What differentiates an average host and a great host is anticipating unexpressed needs and wants of their guests.  Just because the want/need is not expressed, doesn't mean it wouldn't be appreciated. 
  • kitsunegari89kitsunegari89 member
    500 Love Its Third Anniversary 100 Comments Name Dropper
    edited May 2014
    She should absolutely be invited! In addition, the family needs to have a come-to-Jesus talk about their unrealistic demands that your uncle not have a love life after the passing of his wife. Yes, it's tragic and sad. It's okay that everyone is sad about it. However, it's not disloyal to your late aunt to welcome a new woman into his life who is presumably supportive of and important to him.

    If I were dead I would absolutely want my husband to find love again! Maybe not 3 months after, but 3 years is certainly a reasonable interval to begin dating. Nothing can replace her, but why shouldn't he enjoy life and try to be happy?
    My colors are "blood of my enemies" and "rage".

    http://media.tumblr.com/tumblr_m3h1kr8sYk1qzve89.gif
  • My uncle passed away from cancer. It wasn't unexpected because it was stage 4 and metastatic with poor odds of survival when he was diagnosed, but his sisters and mother thought that he would be the one to beat it. When his wife (my aunt by marriage) began dating, his sisters and mother behaved similarly to your relatives. There was a lot of side-eyes, judging and behind her back gossip that she must not have loved him because they thought she moved on too fast. My dad finally had to have a come to Jesus talk with them saying "[aunt] loved our brother very much. She was by his side the entire time he was fighting cancer. [Brother] would have wanted her to move on and find happiness. [Aunt] is young (late 40s) and he would not want her to be alone for the rest of her life. [Brother] would be disgusted by the way that you are treating her". 

    The uncle should be invited with his girlfriend. The aunt's family needs to realize that moving on doesn't diminish the love that he had for their sister/daughter. After something tragic happening, he deserves to be happy, and they need to accept he still has a life.

    Anniversary
  • I agree with all other posters. If the uncle is invited to the wedding - his girlfriend should be too.  
    Wedding Countdown Ticker
  • I experienced a similar situation at my own wedding, but it was my mother who had passed away 3 years earlier after a 33 yr marriage with my father, and my father who wanted to bring his girlfriend. The bottom line for me was that I wanted to see my father happy on the day of my wedding. I wanted him to have someone to dance next to and enjoy the night with. Obviously we'd all prefer it if my mother was there - that goes without saying. I feel bad for your uncle that he has to deal with such a backwards-thinking family.
  • ei34ei34 member
    Knottie Warrior 2500 Comments 500 Love Its 5 Answers
    Your inclination is correct. Your uncle is invited with his girlfriend. Similarly to you, I lost my favorite aunt (mom's sister) suddenly, and we were all devastated. When my uncle started dating again, we accepted it. The woman he was dating when I got married was invited to my wedding, and the woman he was dating when my sister got married was invited to her wedding. We were more focused on missing my aunt during such a big moment than who my uncle's date was. Hopefully your family eases up!
This discussion has been closed.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards