Wedding Etiquette Forum

Uninviting a bridesmaid.. DRAMA!

edited October 2014 in Wedding Etiquette Forum
I effed up, Knotties.  Lurkers - this is why you don't ask friends to be bridesmaids too early :(

The wedding isn't for another year.  I got caught up in the excitement of getting engaged, and asked my friends to be bridesmaids WAY too early (and way before I started lurking on these boards).  For the most part, this has been an okay decision.  I chose 4 friends to be bridesmaids and 3 of them I have been friends with for 8+ years.  These are steady, long time friends who have survived sporadic and long periods of not talking to each other without any negative impact.  Even with a year away, I have confidence these friendships will stand the test of time!

However... I asked a relatively recent friend to be a bridesmaid as well.  We'd been work friends for about a year and half and became very close, very quickly.  It made perfect sense to ask her to be a bridesmaid, given how close we were.  At the time I considered it almost insulting to NOT to ask her, because of how close we were.  I couldn't possibly see us not being friends.

There's been a lot of changes since then, however.  She has changed tremendously as a person, and part of me wants to justify my poor decision to ask her with the fact she simply isn't the same person I asked.  While there are many reasons our friendship has died out, I don't feel the details of why it died are necessary to air out on here.  The gist of it is - we began growing apart, she broke my trust (nothing wedding related), we tried to rebuild said friendship, it didn't work.  To avoid uncomfortableness at work, we agreed to just start over and work on rebuilding our friendship instead of trying to repair it to what it once was.

Sounds promising, right?  But it's not.  I really have only done this as to not impact our work place.  I am moving to be with Fiance while he finishes school.  I am 100% certain this friendship will dwindle out after the move.  What I need help with is a tactful and straight forward way of stopping any awkwardness when FI and I fly back into the states next year to get married.  I am almost certain she doesn't expect to be in the bridal party, or even invited to the wedding at this point.  I'm trying to avoid being a total bitch by not saying anything to her at all, and politely get rid of any confusion for her.

Let me be perfectly clear here:  our friendship dying had NOTHING to do with the wedding, her being a bridesmaid or anything related.  I'm also well aware this decision is a "friendship ending move."  Since there is not much of a friendship there anymore, this is not really a problem.  I'm not looking for cristicism on our friendship - what's done is done.  We both made mistakes, and it's in the past now.

My plan is to say something along the lines of "We were very close when I asked you to be a bridesmaid.  I'm sorry to say we have drastically parted ways since then, and I wanted to relieve you of the burden of being a bridesmaid."  I won't rescind her invitation, however I sincerely doubt she'll want to go. 
Thoughts?

Sorry for the long post, I feel the need to yammer on incessantly when I dun f*ed up :(

EDIT:  I've got a lot of great criticism on this, and have decided to say something more like "We were very close when I asked you to be a bridesmaid.  Our friendship just isn't what it used to be, and I don't think it makes sense to have you be a bridesmaid anymore." 

This shouldn't come as any great shock to her, so the direct approach is probably best.
Wedding Countdown Ticker


image

Re: Uninviting a bridesmaid.. DRAMA!

  • I see nothing wrong with how you've laid everything out.  Good luck.
    Happiness is an inside job
  • I think how you worded it is ok. I too got excited and asked two people to be my bridesmaids as soon as I got engaged, but then I found this forum so I will be holding off on asking anyone else. Best of Luck
  • I understand. But I wouldn't word it as you doing her a favor. Own it. I would word it from your perspective - that you no longer want her to be a bridesmaid.
    I hesitate to word it that way, because I want to avoid coming off as confrontational.  But I see where you're coming from, as if I'm telling her I'm assuming her feelings for her.

    BTW- That drool!  Hahh!
    Wedding Countdown Ticker


    image
  • Is there a reason you have to do anything right now? Your wedding is a year away; anything could happen in that time. It might be wise to wait, and see if things change. If you are 100% sure that you will never be friends again, then own it.

    How long ago did you ask her to be bridesmaid?
    image
    image

    image


  • Is there a reason you have to do anything right now? Your wedding is a year away; anything could happen in that time. It might be wise to wait, and see if things change. If you are 100% sure that you will never be friends again, then own it.

    How long ago did you ask her to be bridesmaid?
    I'm not planning to do this right away, I'm going to wait for a bit after I move.  I still want to maintain a positive environment at work. 

    When we talked about things about a month ago, she brought up the bridesmaid thing, saying she wasn't sure I even wanted her to be in the wedding any more.  My response was to tell her I'm not focused on the wedding party at all, and that I'm more concerned with setting our friendship straight before even taking the bridesmaid thing into consideration. 

    I'm pretty embarrassed to say how long ago I asked.  It was way, WAY too early.  Seeing as I still have a year to the wedding and enough time has passed for a really strong friendship to dwindle to nothing.  There wasn't an explosive fight and this wasn't a decision I made in the heat of the moment, it's just kind of a sad realization over time - that I will at some point have to do this.
    Wedding Countdown Ticker


    image
  • I think you have things worded out pretty well here. Since you have lots of time I would wait and see if she initiates some sort of conversation first... but I am notorious for avoiding any kind of confrontation so that might not be the best advice. Just something to consider if you are totally dreading bringing up the topic at some point.


    image
  • She may very well drop out when you move, so I agree with you that it's best to wait at least till then.


    Agree with ShesSoCold that it might be best to just say "I don't really think it makes sense anymore to have you as a bridesmaid" (or something less blunt? I don't know) rather than your original wording, although I know your heart is in the right place and I "get" what you mean by it.


    Good luck. And I'm sorry for the loss of your friendship, for what it's worth. That shit sucks.

    image
    This baby knows exactly how I feel
  • I would just wait. Will you even need to say anything at all? If you move away and don't stay in contact, it's pretty obvious the friendship is over and that she isn't a bridesmaid.
    What did you think would happen if you walked up to a group of internet strangers and told them to get shoehorned by their lady doc?~StageManager14
    image
  • jacques27jacques27 member
    Knottie Warrior 1000 Comments 500 Love Its 5 Answers
    edited October 2014
    Just wanted to say I wholeheartedly agree about changing the wording.  I'm sorry, but there really is little that's worse in this situation from the receiving end than someone assuming they know what you are feeling and making it sound like they are doing you a favor.  It makes you come across as smug and like you're trying to martyr yourself. 

    Own it and use "I statements", not "we" or "you".  You admit you're not close to her anymore, so that also means you're not close enough to speak on her behalf.

    "I appreciate the friendship we had..."
    "I'm sorry that..."
    "I feel it would be best if..."
  • I also agree that you shouldn't say it like you're doing her a favor. And personally, I'd prefer the bluntness if I were getting bridal party dumped. If you just move and stop talking, there is still a possibility that you may want her. I vote to just tell it like it is, and make sure she gets that she's out. 

    "I know we were close at one time, but we are not now. I do not feel that you should be a bridesmaid in my wedding."
    "I'm sorry that our friendship has faded, but I do not think you should be in the bridal party anymore."
    "I'm sorry for the things I've done wrong in our friendship, but unfortunately, we have both made mistakes. As a result, I no longer want you in the bridal party."


  • I effed up, Knotties.  Lurkers - this is why you don't ask friends to be bridesmaids too early :(

    The wedding isn't for another year.  I got caught up in the excitement of getting engaged, and asked my friends to be bridesmaids WAY too early (and way before I started lurking on these boards).  For the most part, this has been an okay decision.  I chose 4 friends to be bridesmaids and 3 of them I have been friends with for 8+ years.  These are steady, long time friends who have survived sporadic and long periods of not talking to each other without any negative impact.  Even with a year away, I have confidence these friendships will stand the test of time!

    However... I asked a relatively recent friend to be a bridesmaid as well.  We'd been work friends for about a year and half and became very close, very quickly.  It made perfect sense to ask her to be a bridesmaid, given how close we were.  At the time I considered it almost insulting to NOT to ask her, because of how close we were.  I couldn't possibly see us not being friends.

    There's been a lot of changes since then, however.  She has changed tremendously as a person, and part of me wants to justify my poor decision to ask her with the fact she simply isn't the same person I asked.  While there are many reasons our friendship has died out, I don't feel the details of why it died are necessary to air out on here.  The gist of it is - we began growing apart, she broke my trust (nothing wedding related), we tried to rebuild said friendship, it didn't work.  To avoid uncomfortableness at work, we agreed to just start over and work on rebuilding our friendship instead of trying to repair it to what it once was.

    Sounds promising, right?  But it's not.  I really have only done this as to not impact our work place.  I am moving to be with Fiance while he finishes school.  I am 100% certain this friendship will dwindle out after the move.  What I need help with is a tactful and straight forward way of stopping any awkwardness when FI and I fly back into the states next year to get married.  I am almost certain she doesn't expect to be in the bridal party, or even invited to the wedding at this point.  I'm trying to avoid being a total bitch by not saying anything to her at all, and politely get rid of any confusion for her.

    Let me be perfectly clear here:  our friendship dying had NOTHING to do with the wedding, her being a bridesmaid or anything related.  I'm also well aware this decision is a "friendship ending move."  Since there is not much of a friendship there anymore, this is not really a problem.  I'm not looking for cristicism on our friendship - what's done is done.  We both made mistakes, and it's in the past now.

    My plan is to say something along the lines of "We were very close when I asked you to be a bridesmaid.  I'm sorry to say we have drastically parted ways since then, and I wanted to relieve you of the burden of being a bridesmaid."  I won't rescind her invitation, however I sincerely doubt she'll want to go. 
    Thoughts?

    Sorry for the long post, I feel the need to yammer on incessantly when I dun f*ed up :(

    Jic

  • I effed up, Knotties.  Lurkers - this is why you don't ask friends to be bridesmaids too early :(

    The wedding isn't for another year.  I got caught up in the excitement of getting engaged, and asked my friends to be bridesmaids WAY too early (and way before I started lurking on these boards).  For the most part, this has been an okay decision.  I chose 4 friends to be bridesmaids and 3 of them I have been friends with for 8+ years.  These are steady, long time friends who have survived sporadic and long periods of not talking to each other without any negative impact.  Even with a year away, I have confidence these friendships will stand the test of time!

    However... I asked a relatively recent friend to be a bridesmaid as well.  We'd been work friends for about a year and half and became very close, very quickly.  It made perfect sense to ask her to be a bridesmaid, given how close we were.  At the time I considered it almost insulting to NOT to ask her, because of how close we were.  I couldn't possibly see us not being friends.

    There's been a lot of changes since then, however.  She has changed tremendously as a person, and part of me wants to justify my poor decision to ask her with the fact she simply isn't the same person I asked.  While there are many reasons our friendship has died out, I don't feel the details of why it died are necessary to air out on here.  The gist of it is - we began growing apart, she broke my trust (nothing wedding related), we tried to rebuild said friendship, it didn't work.  To avoid uncomfortableness at work, we agreed to just start over and work on rebuilding our friendship instead of trying to repair it to what it once was.

    Sounds promising, right?  But it's not.  I really have only done this as to not impact our work place.  I am moving to be with Fiance while he finishes school.  I am 100% certain this friendship will dwindle out after the move.  What I need help with is a tactful and straight forward way of stopping any awkwardness when FI and I fly back into the states next year to get married.  I am almost certain she doesn't expect to be in the bridal party, or even invited to the wedding at this point.  I'm trying to avoid being a total bitch by not saying anything to her at all, and politely get rid of any confusion for her.

    Let me be perfectly clear here:  our friendship dying had NOTHING to do with the wedding, her being a bridesmaid or anything related.  I'm also well aware this decision is a "friendship ending move."  Since there is not much of a friendship there anymore, this is not really a problem.  I'm not looking for cristicism on our friendship - what's done is done.  We both made mistakes, and it's in the past now.

    My plan is to say something along the lines of "We were very close when I asked you to be a bridesmaid.  I'm sorry to say we have drastically parted ways since then, and I wanted to relieve you of the burden of being a bridesmaid."  I won't rescind her invitation, however I sincerely doubt she'll want to go. 
    Thoughts?

    Sorry for the long post, I feel the need to yammer on incessantly when I dun f*ed up :(
    Jic
    Lol, really?
    Wedding Countdown Ticker


    image
  • edited October 2014
    jacques27 said:
    Just wanted to say I wholeheartedly agree about changing the wording.  I'm sorry, but there really is little that's worse in this situation from the receiving end than someone assuming they know what you are feeling and making it sound like they are doing you a favor.  It makes you come across as smug and like you're trying to martyr yourself. 

    Own it and use "I statements", not "we" or "you".  You admit you're not close to her anymore, so that also means you're not close enough to speak on her behalf.

    "I appreciate the friendship we had..."
    "I'm sorry that..."
    "I feel it would be best if..."
    Yes, I agree.  I responded to another post similar to this saying "I see where you're coming from, as if I'm telling her I'm assuming her feelings for her."

    I truly feel being a bridesmaid is a burden, which is why I went that direction - but understand and agree with each of you who think I should change the wording to be directly from me. 

    I will own it, it's my decision.

    ETA: I feel being a bridesmaid is a burden because you have to buy a dress.  I understand there is not much too it.  Please don't jump on me about having outrageous expectations of my bridal party.  I'm not asking them to do anything other than get a black dress and show up.
    Wedding Countdown Ticker


    image
  • My comment had nothing to do with thinking you had outrageous expectations.  It came from "Gee...what if there is a minute chance this coworker still wanted to be a bridesmaid and was thinking that maybe it would be the perfect opportunity to mend fences."  Or something like that.  Maybe she feels that buying a dress isn't a burden at all.  You are the one who feels like a burden, and that's placing YOUR feelings on her and assuming they are true for her.  Just don't do that.  Making it sound like you're doing her a favor is just kind of gross - that's all. 
  • @sarahbear31 Is THAT why people quote really long posts? I have been trying to figure this out!

    OP- Good luck! It sounds like it won't be a big shock to her, especially since you are waiting a while to bring it up.

  • jacques27 said:
    My comment had nothing to do with thinking you had outrageous expectations.  It came from "Gee...what if there is a minute chance this coworker still wanted to be a bridesmaid and was thinking that maybe it would be the perfect opportunity to mend fences."  Or something like that.  Maybe she feels that buying a dress isn't a burden at all.  You are the one who feels like a burden, and that's placing YOUR feelings on her and assuming they are true for her.  Just don't do that.  Making it sound like you're doing her a favor is just kind of gross - that's all. 
    My edit was directed at my definition of a burden, and nothing to do with what you said.  I was preemptively trying to combat any kind of "well what sort of things are you asking your BM's to do that's such a burden" and not directed at you.

    I think we're beating a same drum here, but it's starting to become a dead horse :)
    Wedding Countdown Ticker


    image
  • OP- I agree with PP that you need to own it. "I'm grateful for the friendship we had but we've drifted apart etc" If you say "I don't want to burden you with being a bridesmaid" and she comes back with "it's not a burden! It's fine!" Then you're in a truly awkward place of spending your wedding day in the company of someone you don't like.
  • @sarahbear31 Is THAT why people quote really long posts? I have been trying to figure this out!

    OP- Good luck! It sounds like it won't be a big shock to her, especially since you are waiting a while to bring it up.

    Yes, she thought I would delete my post.  I owned the mistake and didn't deny it was a poor choice, which is why I thought her quoting it was kind of silly.

    And thanks, it's an awkward position to be in.  But I brought it upon myself!  Hopefully lurkers will learn from my mistake. 

    Even with the uneasy conversation looming in the future, I definitely feel a sense of relief after having made the decision to have this talk.
    Wedding Countdown Ticker


    image
  • OP- I agree with PP that you need to own it. "I'm grateful for the friendship we had but we've drifted apart etc" If you say "I don't want to burden you with being a bridesmaid" and she comes back with "it's not a burden! It's fine!" Then you're in a truly awkward place of spending your wedding day in the company of someone you don't like.
    That's a really good point!
    Wedding Countdown Ticker


    image
  • @sarahbear31 Is THAT why people quote really long posts? I have been trying to figure this out!

    OP- Good luck! It sounds like it won't be a big shock to her, especially since you are waiting a while to bring it up.

    Yes, she thought I would delete my post.  I owned the mistake and didn't deny it was a poor choice, which is why I thought her quoting it was kind of silly.

    And thanks, it's an awkward position to be in.  But I brought it upon myself!  Hopefully lurkers will learn from my mistake. 

    Even with the uneasy conversation looming in the future, I definitely feel a sense of relief after having made the decision to have this talk.
    First bolded, it's not silly, it happens all the time. One can never know how brides will react when getting advice they may not like hearing. Don't take offense, it's not personal and good on you for taking the advice and owning your mistake.

    Second bolded, they won't. Just lurk on Wedding Party board and you will see how time and time again, brides think it's okay to ask in excitement and then kick out their wedding party for seemingly silly reasons and expect no repercussions. But again, good on you for realizing what you did and owning your decision. 

     Just be sure you really want to end this friendship, and that she is in no position to recommend you for a job later. Good luck!
  • I'm sorry to hear this :( I think the PP's gave excellent advice. Just a personal story here. I have a very close work friend. We became inseparable at one point, used to go out every single night of the week, and sometimes people would confuse us and call us by each others names! It was a fun friendship that bloomed really quickly. 

    Fast forward a few months, some things went down, and eventually our friendship just died. We did not speak for weeks, and it got to the point where we would walk by each other and not speak a word. It was the weirdest thing. I'll admit I was not in a good place at the time, so I think I was the one who must have been giving off some bad vibes, etc. We eventually made up, became close again, all for it to happen again. This time I don't know what happened. She sent me a nasty text message, we did not speak for months. It took another coworker to one day mediate and have us talking again.

    Right now we are great friends. We are not at that BFF level, but we are still pretty close, and are still there for each others big events. So I think maybe just wait a bit like others said. A lot can happen. You guys may rekindle the friendship, and you'll want her to be in your wedding. Or, maybe it will die out completely. Since you have a year till your wedding, time will tell. 

    If you do decide not to have her in the wedding, that wording sounds good. I wish you the best of luck! It really sucks when friendships fade away.
                                 Anniversary
    imageimageimage


     

  • pinkcow13 said:
    I'm sorry to hear this :( I think the PP's gave excellent advice. Just a personal story here. I have a very close work friend. We became inseparable at one point, used to go out every single night of the week, and sometimes people would confuse us and call us by each others names! It was a fun friendship that bloomed really quickly. 

    Fast forward a few months, some things went down, and eventually our friendship just died. We did not speak for weeks, and it got to the point where we would walk by each other and not speak a word. It was the weirdest thing. I'll admit I was not in a good place at the time, so I think I was the one who must have been giving off some bad vibes, etc. We eventually made up, became close again, all for it to happen again. This time I don't know what happened. She sent me a nasty text message, we did not speak for months. It took another coworker to one day mediate and have us talking again.

    Right now we are great friends. We are not at that BFF level, but we are still pretty close, and are still there for each others big events. So I think maybe just wait a bit like others said. A lot can happen. You guys may rekindle the friendship, and you'll want her to be in your wedding. Or, maybe it will die out completely. Since you have a year till your wedding, time will tell. 

    If you do decide not to have her in the wedding, that wording sounds good. I wish you the best of luck! It really sucks when friendships fade away.
    This is almost exactly what happened with us.  We just avoid eye contact with each other at work because it's awkward.  That's great that you guys were able to move forward and be friends again!  We have tried to as well, but haven't been successful.

    It's true, it may change in the future.  I will wait until a more reasonable time to say anything to her.  
    I'm sad to say at this point I'm mourning our friendship and don't have high hopes for it bouncing back, but I've been wrong about us in the past, so who knows!
    Wedding Countdown Ticker


    image
This discussion has been closed.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards