Wedding Etiquette Forum

Thanks for coming (but not really)

I want to begin by saying there's a 99.9% chance I'm going to send this thank you card, but I wanted to see if anyone else felt WEIRD about it as well. 

To make a long story short(er), my husband's cousin and her long-term partner had a HUGE falling out with my husband's family. The falling out was originally between her and her brother (who was a groomsman) but quickly spread to the rest of the family, as these things do. Cousin and her husband cut off all communication with the family for several months, but when they realized they had not received a wedding invitation (at the request of my husband's family, we did not invite them) they quickly called everyone to try to make amends. The decision about whether to invite them was ultimately left up to my husband, and he chose to do so, which I supported. Including an extra two people with only a few weeks to go until the big day was not the easiest thing in the world but it was also not a crisis or anything. 

To this day I am still not entirely sure what happened because no one wanted to stress out the bride, but from what I can gather, no one warned Cousin's father that she was going to be there. When they met face-to-face the day before the wedding, there was a screaming match that led to him leaving and not attending the wedding. This added additional stress for my husband's family, obviously. 

I had a semi-destination wedding. We have already sent Cousin and her husband a thank you card for the wedding gifts they sent prior to the wedding, but I am sending thank you cards to all the guests who traveled as well (and of course thanking the guests for any gifts we received at the reception). Again, PROBABLY going to send Cousin a thank you for coming. My husband decided he wanted them there and they did put in the effort. I'm not sure how much of the drama that accompanied their presence was really their fault, because I don't know what happened. But part of me feels like it's weird to send a "thanks for coming" given what all went down and the lingering bad feelings.

Not really looking for anyone to tell me not to send it. I know I ought to. I basically just wanted to vent about the fact that I think it's an awkward thing to send.

Re: Thanks for coming (but not really)

  • You do not need to send a thank you card for someone's attendance.  You already sent a thank you card for the gifts they gave you and H, so that is all that is required of you.  I wouldn't send a follow up card.
  • I wouldn't send one not only for the reasons PPs stated, but also because I would feel almost facetious in saying "thanks for coming!" when their very attendance caused so much drama among my in-laws. I would just let that one go.
  • Although it almost seems counter-intuitive, thank you notes should only be sent for gifts and not attendance.  It can come off as gift grabby.  So you're off the hook for sending one. 


    image
  • Even in cases where people traveled quite a long distance to attend? Cuz we already sent out most of the thank yous for coming. >.< 

    I didn't know!! 

    image
  • elleC14 said:
    Even in cases where people traveled quite a long distance to attend? Cuz we already sent out most of the thank yous for coming. >.< 

    I didn't know!! 

    image
    I wouldn't side-eye you, especially if I had already given a gift and been thanked separately for that. I'd appreciate your overzealousness in your thanks. But it can be perceived by people who didn't give a gift as a passive-aggressive "Thanks... for coming, I guess. Since I'm not sending you a thank you note for the gift you didn't get me."
  • I feel bad but I guess all I can do at this point is hope that everyone knows us well enough (it was a smaller wedding) to know we're not like that. 

    And if they don't, oh well... honest mistake...! 
  • Maggie0829Maggie0829 member
    Eighth Anniversary 10000 Comments 500 Love Its 25 Answers
    edited February 2015
    elleC14 said:
    Even in cases where people traveled quite a long distance to attend? Cuz we already sent out most of the thank yous for coming. >.< 

    I didn't know!! 

    image
    Yes, even if people traveled a long distance to attend your wedding.  I am assuming you talked to and thanked each person at your actual wedding.  Well that is enough.  You only send thank you notes for gifts.  To get two separate thank you notes would just be odd.  Just don't send any more of the "thanks for coming" notes.

  • elleC14 said:
    Even in cases where people traveled quite a long distance to attend? Cuz we already sent out most of the thank yous for coming. >.< 

    I didn't know!! 

    image
    Yes, even if people traveled a long distance to attend your wedding.  I am assuming you talked to and thanked each person at your actual wedding.  Well that is enough.  You only send thank you notes for gifts.  To get two separate thank you notes would just be odd.  Just don't send any more of the "thanks for coming" notes.
    To build on this, the reception itself is the official thank you for guests who attend, so sending an additional thank you note is redundant.  This is one of the main reasons we impress upon brides that they must have a reception for guests who attend their ceremony. 


    image
This discussion has been closed.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards