this is the code for the render ad
New Hampshire

How do you "share" families? Kinda long sorry

Ok not completely wedding planning related, but I'm sure you have all dealt with, or will deal with this once you're married.

My FI and I have been dating for a little over 4 years.  He is born and bred in MA where we have lived for the past 4 years.  I'm from NH only lived in MA for about 6 years because I took a job down here out of college and have not left yet.  I have a really small family (no aunts or uncles, 1 brother 2 parents), FI has a big family (lots of aunts and uncles, cousins, 3 siblings all with children right in this area).  Since we met I made it clear to FI that I will be moving back to NH permanently by the time I buy a house, hopefully sooner.  I have been trying to get a job in NH over the past 3 years or so.

For the last 4 years I have spent just about all of my time with my FI's family at birthday parties, baby showers, bbq's and any holidays that are not Christmas, Thanksgiving or Easter.  Those 3 holidays are when we drive up to NH and see my family.  We never sat down and mapped out who gets what holiday or some plan to make things equal, I just went along seeing his family, but made it clear that I would like to see my family more often, perhaps we could skip a b-day party once and a while or take the next weekend go to NH, esp where my family is starting to get upset that they never see us.

Long story short lately it has become a problem with FI's family.  His sister and I have been in a bit of a silly fight over other things and she finally had the guts (kinda as she FB emailed me instead of saying it to my face!) to tell me that she's upset that she doesn't get to see FI and I on a "real holiday" meaning x-mas, easter or thanksgiving.  Mind you my FSIL only goes to those 3 holidays because she hosts them, typically doesn't go to other b-day parties unless it's for her kids.  She just got married for the 3rd time and was giving me marriage advise of how I need to learn to "share" to have a successful marriage.

I don't care what you go too or don't go too, but I'm very frustrated that she has the nerve to say these kind of things.  FI of course has not stood up for me and explained to her the time that I give to his family and not mine and no matter how much I tell him it hurts he says "I'll do it, I'll tell her."  I understand how akward it is for him to be in the middle, but he has to understand that we have to make it fair to both of us.

We do have plans to hopefully buy a house soon (although all of our money is tied up in the wedding).  Of course his family has a problem with us going to NH even though they know the plan is to be as equi-distant to both families as possible.  We are looking at the Nashua area because we could still end up in MA (much to my dismay) or NH, but either way be about equal to both families.

I guess I'm just curious how do you balance both families?  FInally FI is starting to see that yes I make a lot of sacrafices (sp) and that it is indeed not fair to not see my family, however he is not taking the steps to change things.  I've offered to make a holiday list at the beginning of the year so that no one can complain when they see who gets what, but he doesn't think it's a good idea.  My poor family can't afford to not see us on holidays because my only brother doesn't always come home, his family has grandchildren and cousins and all kinds of other people to keep his parents company.

Thankfully we have no plans of having children, but if we did then what?  My family would never be able to see their grandchild?

Thanks ladies!

Re: How do you "share" families? Kinda long sorry

  • edited December 2011
    Though both our families live mainly in NH, his live 2 hours away from mine.

    Its a little easier for us because our family's dont really have holidays on the same day.

    ie: Christmas is celebrated on the Saturday before by my moms side, christmas eve on my dads side, and christmas day with FI family.
    Thanksgiving we swap- dinner with my family, dessert with his family on year, than swap it the next year.
    Easter my family doesnt usually do anything because my parents usually work, so we  usually go to his parents house.

    It works out really well for us, but our familes aren't really fighting over who sees who when. How far is the distance between the two familes? Could you pull of two in one day?
  • FireDancer04FireDancer04 member
    Fifth Anniversary 1000 Comments
    edited December 2011
    I grew up in Maine and my large family still lives in Maine. It's 3 hours to my home town. We share holidays. IE, if we spend Thanksgiving down here, then we spend Christmas in Maine. The following year Thanksgiving in Maine and Christmas down here. Easter has been just the two of us for a couple years now. We try to go up a few times a year just to spend the weekend and if I feel I need "mommy time", I'll go up by myself to spend sometime with my mom.

    It's hard to split time between families but you both need to compromise on what you want. If he sees no problem with not spending holidays with his family than you should have him talk to his sister and explain things to him.
  • edited December 2011
    We tend to do something similar to FireDancer.  We eat Thanksgiving dinner and spend X-eve with one family and Christmas day with the other.  But because they're so close together, we do visit with both families on the holidays and only eat with one. 

    However, in general we spend more time with my family and I think his family is starting to notice.  The reason this happens is becasue FI prefers to spend time with my family (his isn't exactly the warm fuzzy type).  We try our best to be fair, but nothing you do can make everyone happy.  I do think having some sort of plan helps.  Good luck!
    image
    Anniversary Buying A Home
  • edited December 2011
    In Response to <a href="http://forums.theknot.com/Sites/theknot/Pages/Main.aspx/local-wedding-boards_new-hampshire_share-families-kinda-long-sorry?plckFindPostKey=Cat:Local%20Wedding%20BoardsForum:101Discussion:3b0d2447-217b-4688-a596-5577a49ed6faPost:57e51746-6d9f-4f9e-bbd2-d656318e8b99">Re: How do you "share" families? Kinda long sorry</a>:
    [QUOTE]It's hard to split time between families but you both need to compromise on what you want. If he sees no problem with not spending holidays with his family than you should have him talk to his sister and explain things to him.
    Posted by FireDancer04[/QUOTE]

    <div>This exactly. We spent the past 3 years with FI's family for Easter, so this year I told my mom we were coming. I think his grandparents were a little upset, but he told them that we had not spent Easter with my family in years. </div><div>My grandparents lived on opposite ends of MA growing up (mom's parents in western MA, dad's in Boston). My parents switched holidays; if we spent Thanksgiving with dad's parents, we were with my mom's parents for Christmas. The next year it would swap. Thankfully, my FILs are only 2 hours from my parents, so we have Thanksgiving lunch with one set of parents, and dinner with the other. Christmas eve with one, day with the other.</div><div>
    </div><div>Once we have kids, I think we'll do less traveling. If people want to come see grandkids open presents, they can drive to us!</div>
  • edited December 2011
    We live in NH our families live in MA with a 15 minute distance between them.  So we go to MA every holiday and mostly every other weekend.  We spend 1/2 the day at one and 1/2 the day at the other. 
  • edited December 2011
    you're never going to make everyone happy... my brother and his wife live in NH.. her family is from MA and my family is from IL, and so they *constantly* spend the smallest of events with her family, but he only sees my family once a year (either christmas or thanksgiving... they switch)... and there is so much drama because of it... but that's what they want to do and they're sticking to it... i would just be clear with both of your families and lay out ahead of time the major things... anything smaller that comes up you can play by ear... people just need to understand that you're starting your own new family and need to do what's best for you guys!
  • edited December 2011
    It has been a sticky issue for my FI and I too.  We play it year to year.  This past holiday season it went like this.  We went down to his parents in southern MA on Christmas eve then drove the 1 1/2 to my house (closer to home as he lives in Nashua) to celebrate with my family.  Thnaksgiving, we spent the morning and lunch at my place and then drove to his parents for dinner and stayed the weekend.  My family isnt as big on Easter so we spend the weekend with his parents.  I have a big family and it is only him, his parents, and his sister.  So when he isnt around, it is a big void.  We did decide that when we get married and have a house, we will host Thanksgiving and possibly Easter with both families.  They agreed.
    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • edited December 2011
    What if you tried hosting a holiday once a year, like easter or thanksgiving, that way both families could be together. If you're much of a cook, make it potluck and hav everyone bring something.

    Also I would decide what Holiday is most important to both families. If it's christmas, then switch off every year.

    We deal with this issue with my brother and his wife. The only holiday we get if Christmas morning. It still kinda stinks, but at least its something
  • edited December 2011
    I know exactly how you feel but luckily my family and his are more understanding... I have pretty much lived at his house since we started dating almost 8 years ago and I know sometimes my family feels like they arent good enough for us to hang out with... so here is what we do, take what you may..:::

    X-mas eve with my step mom and dad in NH
    Easter with Fiance family (because it is important to thenm)
    Day before thanksgiving my dad and step mom celebrate early for us
    Thanksgiving day with his family, and then to ME for my mom the weekend after.
    Christmas day with his family in am and then dad or moms later that day
    Birthdays do what we can...


    Mainly you just need to see what holiday is important for what family.. If his family LOVES christmas make that there day, EVERY YEAR... keep it consistent so no fights over whos year, etc.... Then pick one for your family like thanksgiving then split the rest into whoever is doing what. its hard hun but just make plans and stick to em no budging you have two familieies now. We are looking at nashua too, good middle ground! GOOD LUCK!!
    ....Happy ever after.... http://romanowedding.weebly.com/
This discussion has been closed.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards