this is the code for the render ad
Chit Chat

Boundaries and oversharing

I've been pondering a discussion I need to have with my husband and was wondering what your thoughts on the topic were.  Some background... my husband is a very open person.  There are very few things that he finds deeply personal and doesn't share with a lot of people, but many things that most people find somewhat personal and private he is an open book about.  That's cool.  I really like that he is that comfortable with himself and the things in his life.  He's also genuinely curious, which leads to some very personal questions being asked sometimes.

However, he sometimes seems to forget that other people are not that comfortable with these things.  He has, on a few occasions, shared private information about me with people without checking with me about it first.  I've discussed this with him and he's gotten better about it.  However, when I was out for some girl time with a mutual friend of ours last night, she mentioned that he had previously asked her and her S.O. some fairly personal questions that kind of took them aback.  They are pretty much open books too, so they weren't offended by it, but they were kind of surprised.  She then said he had asked similar things to another couple we are friends with, and they are more private.  It kind of freaked them out a little... at least enough that they mentioned it to her.  No offense was meant or taken, but it made them a little uncomfortable and they weren't sure how to tell him that.  (They didn't ask her to mention this to me, it just came up in the conversation we were having.)

I think I need to talk to him about this and let him know that he should try to be more sensitive to other people's boundaries and comfort levels about certain topics of discussion.  He doesn't intend to be making people uncomfortable and I don't think he realizes that he did.  But I'm not quite sure how to go about having this conversation.  Thoughts?  Suggestions?
image

Re: Boundaries and oversharing

  • I feel like I need to know what the questions were? I suppose since you say he's open, you think they might have been toe-ing the line. I would just say it lightheartedly... 

    "H, when I was at dinner the other day, the ladies were saying that you asked them X & Y and they thought it was a little odd. I know you're an open book, but they're not as much, so try to keep to more surface topics." 

    Or something.... eeek! That's hard but I wouldn't want them to think my H was a creeper.
  • What kind of questions is he asking?  What kind of stuff is he sharing?
    Wedding Countdown Ticker
    image

    "I'm not a rude bitch.  I'm ten rude bitches in a large coat."

  • God, no offense but I really hope your husband is not like my friend's. This dude talks like a 13 year old boy with no limits, constantly saying inappropraite and embarrassing things in every sentence. Example- me "We ordered a pizza last night" him "Ashley can't have pizza- cheese will give her the shits!" me "We might get a puppy, not sure yet" him "We don't have a dog, but Ashley loves that doggie style". We refuse to hang out with him- I will meet her for lunch privately and that's it.

    I don't know if these are the types of things your husband is saying, or if it's more like talking salary with people, or talking health scares with people? But I would just keep reminding him like you already do that certain topics are off limits with people. If he wants to talk salary with his best friend when they are alone, fine, but never in a group conversation.

     

                                                                     

    image

  • Yeah, I know the point of your post is that you're a private person compared to your H, but I feel like my response would differ depending on what it was. Like if it's just questions about money, or asking their opinions on things they feel they shouldn't weigh in on, that's pretty mild and you could probably address it with a short remark. But asking questions about sexuality etc would warrant a bigger talk.
    Wedding Countdown Ticker

    image
  • jenna8984 said:

    God, no offense but I really hope your husband is not like my friend's. This dude talks like a 13 year old boy with no limits, constantly saying inappropraite and embarrassing things in every sentence. Example- me "We ordered a pizza last night" him "Ashley can't have pizza- cheese will give her the shits!" me "We might get a puppy, not sure yet" him "We don't have a dog, but Ashley loves that doggie style". We refuse to hang out with him- I will meet her for lunch privately and that's it.

    I don't know if these are the types of things your husband is saying, or if it's more like talking salary with people, or talking health scares with people? But I would just keep reminding him like you already do that certain topics are off limits with people. If he wants to talk salary with his best friend when they are alone, fine, but never in a group conversation.

     

    No.  It wasn't anything like that.  Not juvenile over sharing.  More questions about their relationships that not everyone wants to share with other people.
    image
  • melbenso said:

    jenna8984 said:

    God, no offense but I really hope your husband is not like my friend's. This dude talks like a 13 year old boy with no limits, constantly saying inappropraite and embarrassing things in every sentence. Example- me "We ordered a pizza last night" him "Ashley can't have pizza- cheese will give her the shits!" me "We might get a puppy, not sure yet" him "We don't have a dog, but Ashley loves that doggie style". We refuse to hang out with him- I will meet her for lunch privately and that's it.

    I don't know if these are the types of things your husband is saying, or if it's more like talking salary with people, or talking health scares with people? But I would just keep reminding him like you already do that certain topics are off limits with people. If he wants to talk salary with his best friend when they are alone, fine, but never in a group conversation.

     

    No.  It wasn't anything like that.  Not juvenile over sharing.  More questions about their relationships that not everyone wants to share with other people.
    I might bring it up during dinner or something. "Oh, Jane and Michael mentioned something to me the other day that I think you should know about." Frame it as you wanting him to be aware that your friends said that about him, and he can do what he wants with that information. Give him the chance to decide for himself that he needs to pull back on the questions; he's an adult, after all. Unless you feel it's super serious, I wouldn't sit him down just for a talk.
    Wedding Countdown Ticker

    image
  • melbenso said:

    jenna8984 said:

    God, no offense but I really hope your husband is not like my friend's. This dude talks like a 13 year old boy with no limits, constantly saying inappropraite and embarrassing things in every sentence. Example- me "We ordered a pizza last night" him "Ashley can't have pizza- cheese will give her the shits!" me "We might get a puppy, not sure yet" him "We don't have a dog, but Ashley loves that doggie style". We refuse to hang out with him- I will meet her for lunch privately and that's it.

    I don't know if these are the types of things your husband is saying, or if it's more like talking salary with people, or talking health scares with people? But I would just keep reminding him like you already do that certain topics are off limits with people. If he wants to talk salary with his best friend when they are alone, fine, but never in a group conversation.

     

    No.  It wasn't anything like that.  Not juvenile over sharing.  More questions about their relationships that not everyone wants to share with other people.
    Like how often they have sex or something? Cuz now we all need to know lol

                                                                     

    image

  • jenna8984 said:

    melbenso said:

    jenna8984 said:

    God, no offense but I really hope your husband is not like my friend's. This dude talks like a 13 year old boy with no limits, constantly saying inappropraite and embarrassing things in every sentence. Example- me "We ordered a pizza last night" him "Ashley can't have pizza- cheese will give her the shits!" me "We might get a puppy, not sure yet" him "We don't have a dog, but Ashley loves that doggie style". We refuse to hang out with him- I will meet her for lunch privately and that's it.

    I don't know if these are the types of things your husband is saying, or if it's more like talking salary with people, or talking health scares with people? But I would just keep reminding him like you already do that certain topics are off limits with people. If he wants to talk salary with his best friend when they are alone, fine, but never in a group conversation.

     

    No.  It wasn't anything like that.  Not juvenile over sharing.  More questions about their relationships that not everyone wants to share with other people.
    Like how often they have sex or something? Cuz now we all need to know lol
    I want to know too. Was it closer to "How often do you have sex?" or closer to "How did you two meet?"
    Wedding Countdown Ticker

    image
  • Hm. I think it's the kind of thing you have to "catch in the act" to really bring up, mainly because we're talking about subtleties and social cues, so if you aren't there, it's hard to know if it was a "Holy shit, anyone should know not to ask about that" situation, a "Yeesh, he's really not reading their uncomfortable responses well enough to stop talking" situation, or a "He can't read minds, and to a certain extent it's on the person with the boundary to make that boundary known" issue.

    Basically, any one of us has to deal with these kinds of social issues all the time. But what do you think--is your H oblivious to people's responses when he opens a sensitive door? Because while I don't think he should have to go around censoring himself entirely, I do think it's possible for "open book" people to work on tempering themselves when they see certain cues that the other party is uncomfortable. Things like a surprised look, stammering a reply, blushing, attempting to change the subject. 

    But again, I don't really know how you'd bring this up if you didn't have an exact, recent example to share with him. Like, on the way home from a double date, you could mention "Hey, I think Cheryl was uncomfortable when you asked her about how they share their finances. Did you notice she kept trying to change the subject?" And see where it takes you?
    image
    This baby knows exactly how I feel
  • jenna8984 said:

    melbenso said:

    jenna8984 said:

    God, no offense but I really hope your husband is not like my friend's. This dude talks like a 13 year old boy with no limits, constantly saying inappropraite and embarrassing things in every sentence. Example- me "We ordered a pizza last night" him "Ashley can't have pizza- cheese will give her the shits!" me "We might get a puppy, not sure yet" him "We don't have a dog, but Ashley loves that doggie style". We refuse to hang out with him- I will meet her for lunch privately and that's it.

    I don't know if these are the types of things your husband is saying, or if it's more like talking salary with people, or talking health scares with people? But I would just keep reminding him like you already do that certain topics are off limits with people. If he wants to talk salary with his best friend when they are alone, fine, but never in a group conversation.

     

    No.  It wasn't anything like that.  Not juvenile over sharing.  More questions about their relationships that not everyone wants to share with other people.
    Like how often they have sex or something? Cuz now we all need to know lol
    I want to know too. Was it closer to "How often do you have sex?" or closer to "How did you two meet?"


    ____

    Stuck in the box

    More "How often do you have sex?" type stuff.
    image
  • melbenso said:

    jenna8984 said:

    melbenso said:

    jenna8984 said:

    God, no offense but I really hope your husband is not like my friend's. This dude talks like a 13 year old boy with no limits, constantly saying inappropraite and embarrassing things in every sentence. Example- me "We ordered a pizza last night" him "Ashley can't have pizza- cheese will give her the shits!" me "We might get a puppy, not sure yet" him "We don't have a dog, but Ashley loves that doggie style". We refuse to hang out with him- I will meet her for lunch privately and that's it.

    I don't know if these are the types of things your husband is saying, or if it's more like talking salary with people, or talking health scares with people? But I would just keep reminding him like you already do that certain topics are off limits with people. If he wants to talk salary with his best friend when they are alone, fine, but never in a group conversation.

     

    No.  It wasn't anything like that.  Not juvenile over sharing.  More questions about their relationships that not everyone wants to share with other people.
    Like how often they have sex or something? Cuz now we all need to know lol
    I want to know too. Was it closer to "How often do you have sex?" or closer to "How did you two meet?"


    ____

    Stuck in the box

    More "How often do you have sex?" type stuff.
    That's creepy as fuck.  I'd be having a talk with him.
    Wedding Countdown Ticker
    image

    "I'm not a rude bitch.  I'm ten rude bitches in a large coat."

  • melbenso said:

    jenna8984 said:

    melbenso said:

    jenna8984 said:

    God, no offense but I really hope your husband is not like my friend's. This dude talks like a 13 year old boy with no limits, constantly saying inappropraite and embarrassing things in every sentence. Example- me "We ordered a pizza last night" him "Ashley can't have pizza- cheese will give her the shits!" me "We might get a puppy, not sure yet" him "We don't have a dog, but Ashley loves that doggie style". We refuse to hang out with him- I will meet her for lunch privately and that's it.

    I don't know if these are the types of things your husband is saying, or if it's more like talking salary with people, or talking health scares with people? But I would just keep reminding him like you already do that certain topics are off limits with people. If he wants to talk salary with his best friend when they are alone, fine, but never in a group conversation.

     

    No.  It wasn't anything like that.  Not juvenile over sharing.  More questions about their relationships that not everyone wants to share with other people.
    Like how often they have sex or something? Cuz now we all need to know lol
    I want to know too. Was it closer to "How often do you have sex?" or closer to "How did you two meet?"


    ____

    Stuck in the box

    More "How often do you have sex?" type stuff.
    That's creepy as fuck.  I'd be having a talk with him.
    Ew, yeah. I might actually consider that less of a "bring it up quickly during dinner" talk and more of a "Honey, sit down on the couch because we need to have a discussion" talk. That is 100% not cool.
    Wedding Countdown Ticker

    image
  • melbenso said:

    jenna8984 said:

    melbenso said:

    jenna8984 said:

    God, no offense but I really hope your husband is not like my friend's. This dude talks like a 13 year old boy with no limits, constantly saying inappropraite and embarrassing things in every sentence. Example- me "We ordered a pizza last night" him "Ashley can't have pizza- cheese will give her the shits!" me "We might get a puppy, not sure yet" him "We don't have a dog, but Ashley loves that doggie style". We refuse to hang out with him- I will meet her for lunch privately and that's it.

    I don't know if these are the types of things your husband is saying, or if it's more like talking salary with people, or talking health scares with people? But I would just keep reminding him like you already do that certain topics are off limits with people. If he wants to talk salary with his best friend when they are alone, fine, but never in a group conversation.

     

    No.  It wasn't anything like that.  Not juvenile over sharing.  More questions about their relationships that not everyone wants to share with other people.
    Like how often they have sex or something? Cuz now we all need to know lol
    I want to know too. Was it closer to "How often do you have sex?" or closer to "How did you two meet?"


    ____

    Stuck in the box

    More "How often do you have sex?" type stuff.
    That's creepy as fuck.  I'd be having a talk with him.
    Ew, yeah. I might actually consider that less of a "bring it up quickly during dinner" talk and more of a "Honey, sit down on the couch because we need to have a discussion" talk. That is 100% not cool.
    That actually reminds me of some of the stuff we discuss here, like how often we have sex, and all our other TMI threads that show up all the time. Usually I think it's cuz someone is curious or they think they have a problem or want to compare or want more information, etc. And I think the reason it gets discussed here is because this is a private and fairly anonymous place, so it's like a "safe space" to say/ask anything. 

    Maybe he needs some kind of online forum where he can ask and discuss stuff like that. Sometimes it's nice to get an answer on these things from other people (rather than from google) but asking friends IRL who are then made to feel uncomfortable is not the right way to go. 
    image
  • melbenso said:

    jenna8984 said:

    melbenso said:

    jenna8984 said:

    God, no offense but I really hope your husband is not like my friend's. This dude talks like a 13 year old boy with no limits, constantly saying inappropraite and embarrassing things in every sentence. Example- me "We ordered a pizza last night" him "Ashley can't have pizza- cheese will give her the shits!" me "We might get a puppy, not sure yet" him "We don't have a dog, but Ashley loves that doggie style". We refuse to hang out with him- I will meet her for lunch privately and that's it.

    I don't know if these are the types of things your husband is saying, or if it's more like talking salary with people, or talking health scares with people? But I would just keep reminding him like you already do that certain topics are off limits with people. If he wants to talk salary with his best friend when they are alone, fine, but never in a group conversation.

     

    No.  It wasn't anything like that.  Not juvenile over sharing.  More questions about their relationships that not everyone wants to share with other people.
    Like how often they have sex or something? Cuz now we all need to know lol
    I want to know too. Was it closer to "How often do you have sex?" or closer to "How did you two meet?"


    ____

    Stuck in the box

    More "How often do you have sex?" type stuff.
    That's creepy as fuck.  I'd be having a talk with him.
    Ew, yeah. I might actually consider that less of a "bring it up quickly during dinner" talk and more of a "Honey, sit down on the couch because we need to have a discussion" talk. That is 100% not cool.
    That actually reminds me of some of the stuff we discuss here, like how often we have sex, and all our other TMI threads that show up all the time. Usually I think it's cuz someone is curious or they think they have a problem or want to compare or want more information, etc. And I think the reason it gets discussed here is because this is a private and fairly anonymous place, so it's like a "safe space" to say/ask anything. 

    Maybe he needs some kind of online forum where he can ask and discuss stuff like that. Sometimes it's nice to get an answer on these things from other people (rather than from google) but asking friends IRL who are then made to feel uncomfortable is not the right way to go. 
    _ _ _ _

    Lol tk is definitely NOT private!




    image
  • edited April 2015

    JCbride2015 said: melbenso said: flutteringinfl said: jenna8984 said: melbenso said: jenna8984 said:God, no offense but I really hope your husband is not like my friend's. This dude talks like a 13 year old boy with no limits, constantly saying inappropraite and embarrassing things in every sentence. Example- me "We ordered a pizza last night" him "Ashley can't have pizza- cheese will give her the shits!" me "We might get a puppy, not sure yet" him "We don't have a dog, but Ashley loves that doggie style". We refuse to hang out with him- I will meet her for lunch privately and that's it. I don't know if these are the types of things your husband is saying, or if it's more like talking salary with people, or talking health scares with people? But I would just keep reminding him like you already do that certain topics are off limits with people. If he wants to talk salary with his best friend when they are alone, fine, but never in a group conversation.  

    No.  It wasn't anything like that.  Not juvenile over sharing.  More questions about their relationships that not everyone wants to share with other people.


    Like how often they have sex or something? Cuz now we all need to know lol


    I want to know too. Was it closer to "How often do you have sex?" or closer to "How did you two meet?"


    ____

    Stuck in the box

    More "How often do you have sex?" type stuff.




    That's creepy as fuck.  I'd be having a talk with him.
    ETA: BOXES --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------



    Yeah, for a question like that I would definitely bring to his attention that asking those types of things in normal conversation are NOT okay. I don't have a problem sharing that kind of information with my best friends, but I probably wouldn't ask
    anyone, best friends included, if it didn't apply to the conversation...and I like to think of myself as a fairly open person, too. I just don't see how or why that is something worth knowing unless it's applicable to the conversation in some way.

    If he doesn't know that is inappropriate, I think you should address it. But do it carefully. As PPs have said, he is an adult and he can technically say whatever he wants, but it is safe to guess neither he or you want to risk offending people. 

    I would probably say something like "So I was talking to SoandSo yesterday and she mentioned that you brought up XYZ and it really surprised her. Did you notice that? You might want to watch what you say around some people, because it could come off wrong."

    I don't know. It's a tough situation for sure.

  • melbenso said:

    jenna8984 said:

    melbenso said:

    jenna8984 said:

    God, no offense but I really hope your husband is not like my friend's. This dude talks like a 13 year old boy with no limits, constantly saying inappropraite and embarrassing things in every sentence. Example- me "We ordered a pizza last night" him "Ashley can't have pizza- cheese will give her the shits!" me "We might get a puppy, not sure yet" him "We don't have a dog, but Ashley loves that doggie style". We refuse to hang out with him- I will meet her for lunch privately and that's it.

    I don't know if these are the types of things your husband is saying, or if it's more like talking salary with people, or talking health scares with people? But I would just keep reminding him like you already do that certain topics are off limits with people. If he wants to talk salary with his best friend when they are alone, fine, but never in a group conversation.

     

    No.  It wasn't anything like that.  Not juvenile over sharing.  More questions about their relationships that not everyone wants to share with other people.
    Like how often they have sex or something? Cuz now we all need to know lol
    I want to know too. Was it closer to "How often do you have sex?" or closer to "How did you two meet?"


    ____

    Stuck in the box

    More "How often do you have sex?" type stuff.
    That's creepy as fuck.  I'd be having a talk with him.
    Ew, yeah. I might actually consider that less of a "bring it up quickly during dinner" talk and more of a "Honey, sit down on the couch because we need to have a discussion" talk. That is 100% not cool.
    That actually reminds me of some of the stuff we discuss here, like how often we have sex, and all our other TMI threads that show up all the time. Usually I think it's cuz someone is curious or they think they have a problem or want to compare or want more information, etc. And I think the reason it gets discussed here is because this is a private and fairly anonymous place, so it's like a "safe space" to say/ask anything. 

    Maybe he needs some kind of online forum where he can ask and discuss stuff like that. Sometimes it's nice to get an answer on these things from other people (rather than from google) but asking friends IRL who are then made to feel uncomfortable is not the right way to go. 
    _ _ _ _

    Lol tk is definitely NOT private!
    lol this is true! That was probably the wrong word for it. I just mean it's not like facebook where everyone you know is there, and your real name is there, so if you post something personal you're basically announcing it to EVERYONE you know. I feel way safer talking about personal things on TK than I do anywhere else. But I guess that's from the anonymity standpoint. 
    image
  • Yeah no I would talk to him. One of my friend's is an open book, she isn't private at all. V is an extremely private person. One of their first interactions was her asking how many people he has slept with. He told her that was none of her business and she thought he was a dick for the longest time. This was before I met both of them. Now they are more friendly but no really friends. I've learned that some topics are best left alone.
    image
  • edited April 2015
    I had to talk to my husband about this. He misses a lot of social cues. Nothing embarrasses him... NOTHING. Sometimes it is a good thing, and other times it can be a mortifying experience.

    H has talked to his boss about my endometriosis and my horribly painful menstrual cycles. He works in a small company, and knows his boss really well, but um... No. I was so embarrassed. I don't like people knowing about my fertility issues or my back problems. I find it extremely embarrassing. I haven't even told most of his siblings I have endometriosis... And most of my family is in the dark.

    H does this to other people as well. When sis in law is breastfeeding, he always makes a comment. I tell him he is essentially talking about his sister's breasts and that is never okay. I sat him down and told him firmly that it makes people extremely uncomfortable, and he needs to gauge social cues and realize what makes other people uncomfortable. He thought I was overreacting, so I told him to ask my sister and his other sister in law if his comments made them uncomfortable. They said they were indeed made to feel uncomfortable by his comments. H still slips, from time to time, but he is starting to realize just because he is okay with something, others might not be.
  • edited June 2015
This discussion has been closed.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards