My fiance proposed about a month ago with his grandmother's ring, and he had it resized before I even saw it. He took it to Ashcroft & Oak, and I was a little disappointed that he trusted a mall jeweler with such a precious job, but I didn't think much of it until my ring broke this weekend. Basically they made a small cut in the ring and rebonded it, and this is where the band broke. The cut was on the side of the ring and not centered - which now explains why my ring is almost always tilted to the side. I am going to try to get some sort of refund from A&O, then take the ring to a few local, credible jewelers to see what they have to say. I'm not sure if the structural integrity of the ring will be compromised if we just rebond it, so I'm wondering if I should just look into resetting the entire ring or having just the band repaired.