Wedding Etiquette Forum

What would you do?

So I've run into an issue with my sister in concerns of her bridal shower and would like to hear what everyone thinks about this situation. My sister had been married to her husband for almost two years in a court house ceremony that they had in which I attended. Fast forward to now and my sister is having what she's considering her "real"wedding in which I'm the MOH, though it does sometimes baffle me why she's getting married again- I don't voice this to her.

The problem comes into play in concerns of her bridal shower that she wants. I currently live over 3 hours away from where my sister, mother and the rest of the bridal shower live. For the last few months I've had an extremely difficult time finding a venue under $500 dollars(not including food, decorations, etc) because I honestly have no idea where to host a shower down where she lives. My mother and the rest of the bridal party have not helped with finding the location at all and my sister finally told me I could host it at her house(which is well suited for it) if I couldn't find a place.

Yesterday I drove down to visit and confirmed that she was okay for me to host the shower at her house and she said yes, she didn't want to clean or set up which I told her she wouldn't have to do at all and we spent awhile talking and planning ideas for her wedding. I text her last night confirming the date, venue and registry then ordered invitations once she stated that all sounded great. Fast forward to today and when I call her letting her know the invites should be arrive in a week or so and I'll be sending them out then. She became very short on the phone with me and basically hung up the phone.

My mother calls me shortly after and basically chews me out for ordering the invites (which I also informed her I was doing last night and she agreed with) and got to the point I actually had to hang up the phone with her. I called my sister back and she flipped a switch that how dare I have her bridal shower at her house and I knew she didn't want it there, and apparently my mother had been trying to get a hold of me for weeks (no missed calls or texts from mom but okay). She also went on about how I've basically haven't done anything as MOH and she doesn't even know why she's having me in her wedding, as I dropped the ball on her bachelorette party (I'm pregnant and told her right away I'm uncomfortable going to a bachelorette party when I'll be 6 months pregnant- but I told the other bridesmaids about this and asked them if they could host).

I told her we've discussed this and that I don't live down there and I could either host a party at her house like we had agreed, up where I live (like she made me drive down for my own) or have one of the other girls host it for her and I help as needed. The end result is I've been disinvited from the wedding. I've been in five weddings and never once had any issues like this. I honestly feel she's acting like a child and it makes me feel bad that something so stupid could cause a break in our otherwise good relationship. So how would you handle this situation? Words of wisdom welcome

Re: What would you do?

  • Tell her you tried to do something nice for her and she was rude so now you're not.
  • Thank whatever deity you want that you have been disinvited from this shitshow.


  • I have family like this. When the invites don't go out and she realizes she won't have any shower at all, I bet she'll be apologizing and sweet as pie.

    The good news is, since it's not actually her wedding, you don't have to indulge in that kind of drama. (Though even if it WERE her real wedding, demands like this about parties thrown FOR her are absolutely unacceptable.) I'd separate myself from the issue altogether, knowing you were at your sister's real wedding, and you currently have your own (real) things to be excited about, like your new son or daughter.
  • edited September 2015
    If I were you I'd read the PPD (pretty princess day) thread in this forum to see that everything about what she is doing is really not cool, and the part where she expected you to host her shower (which is a gift that no one is entitled to even when they are having a real wedding) is especially rude. If I was in your shoes, I too would be relieved to be out of that fake mess.
  • So I've run into an issue with my sister in concerns of her bridal shower and would like to hear what everyone thinks about this situation. My sister had been married to her husband for almost two years in a court house ceremony that they had in which I attended. Fast forward to now and my sister is having what she's considering her "real"wedding in which I'm the MOH, though it does sometimes baffle me why she's getting married again- I don't voice this to her.

    The problem comes into play in concerns of her bridal shower that she wants. I currently live over 3 hours away from where my sister, mother and the rest of the bridal shower live. For the last few months I've had an extremely difficult time finding a venue under $500 dollars(not including food, decorations, etc) because I honestly have no idea where to host a shower down where she lives. My mother and the rest of the bridal party have not helped with finding the location at all and my sister finally told me I could host it at her house(which is well suited for it) if I couldn't find a place.

    Yesterday I drove down to visit and confirmed that she was okay for me to host the shower at her house and she said yes, she didn't want to clean or set up which I told her she wouldn't have to do at all and we spent awhile talking and planning ideas for her wedding. I text her last night confirming the date, venue and registry then ordered invitations once she stated that all sounded great. Fast forward to today and when I call her letting her know the invites should be arrive in a week or so and I'll be sending them out then. She became very short on the phone with me and basically hung up the phone.

    My mother calls me shortly after and basically chews me out for ordering the invites (which I also informed her I was doing last night and she agreed with) and got to the point I actually had to hang up the phone with her. I called my sister back and she flipped a switch that how dare I have her bridal shower at her house and I knew she didn't want it there, and apparently my mother had been trying to get a hold of me for weeks (no missed calls or texts from mom but okay). She also went on about how I've basically haven't done anything as MOH and she doesn't even know why she's having me in her wedding, as I dropped the ball on her bachelorette party (I'm pregnant and told her right away I'm uncomfortable going to a bachelorette party when I'll be 6 months pregnant- but I told the other bridesmaids about this and asked them if they could host).

    I told her we've discussed this and that I don't live down there and I could either host a party at her house like we had agreed, up where I live (like she made me drive down for my own) or have one of the other girls host it for her and I help as needed. The end result is I've been disinvited from the wedding. I've been in five weddings and never once had any issues like this. I honestly feel she's acting like a child and it makes me feel bad that something so stupid could cause a break in our otherwise good relationship. So how would you handle this situation? Words of wisdom welcome

    Do people know she is married? I would never go to a bridal shower for digestive who has been married for 2 years - a properly hosted PPD, maybe, but definitely not a bridal shower!
    :kiss: ~xoxo~ :kiss:

  • I didn't even make it through the first paragraph.  Your sister is married and has been for 2 years.  So if I were you I wouldn't be throwing her any kind of party because she is already married.

  • PupatellaPupatella member
    Eighth Anniversary 100 Love Its 100 Comments Combo Breaker
    edited September 2015
    I am so sorry that you are dealing with this.

    I think it's a ridiculous thing for her to be upset about, especially since you checked with her (and your Mom) before you ordered the invitations. I don't understand why she is having a shower for a PPD, but that's a different issue altogether.

    I would just say nothing more to her about her PPD, shower, etc. Leave this topic be and let her talk to you about it first. She disinvited you from her "wedding", so there is no reason for you to plan anything. You went out of your way to accommodate her. 

    If you do talk to her, keep it to your normal, non-wedding topics. Talk to her about your pregnancy, etc. My guess is that she will come around after she takes a step back and realizes that she overreacted.

  • Wait?   A woman who has been married for 2 years is DEMANDING a bridal shower?


    Girl, I wouldn't have even been in the planning process on this one.  A wife of 2 fucking years does not get a bridal shower.  Fuck that.


    Sorry she is being a brat, but you were not dis-invited from the wedding.  You were at the wedding 2 years ago.







    What differentiates an average host and a great host is anticipating unexpressed needs and wants of their guests.  Just because the want/need is not expressed, doesn't mean it wouldn't be appreciated. 
  • Can I ask how your relationship is with your mother? The way I read this is that she chewed you out for sending invites, but your sister said your mother tried to get you to stop, which it doesn't sound like she did. 
    What?

    Thank your lucky stars you're no longer invited to the "event" but I'd, personally, be worried about my relationship with my mom after this. Everyone's different though. 

    ________________________________


  • I would be thankful that any obligation to attend this PPD has been lifted from my shoulders and I will not have to associate with someone so BSC.

    I'm sorry that your mother is also being BSC at the moment to chew you out for doing what she told you she agreed with.  Hopefully she'll come around-maybe after more exposure to your sister's BSCness.

  • How has no one told her this is a terrible idea yet?!
    image
  • What should you do? Nothing. 

    This is the worst kind of gift grab. It's one thing to demand a shower when you're a bride, but to demand a shower as a wife of TWO YEARS?! That's nuts. I got married two years ago, I cannot even fathom demanding a shower right now! LOL!
    *********************************************************************************

    image
  • Holy crap! Again, another time I've been blown away by how adults act (and yes I'm talking about your BSC sister, not you, OP).

    1) Your sister is already married. This is not her wedding. Sure, some people are pretty chill about a well hosted PPD but your sister is not entitled to any sort of pre-PPD events.

    2) Pre-wedding events are NEVER required. People offer to host a shower and/or bachelorette party- they are not demanded.

    3) The above parties are NEVER required to be hosted by the MOH. ANYONE can offer to throw these parties.

    4) The wedding party has no obligation to help plan or host anything related to the wedding. WP positions are that of honour, not job titles.

    So to summarize, you have done nothing wrong OP. Your sister is being completely ridiculous. I agree that I would not engage with her any further on the wedding and do not host this shower. Hopefully she'll come back around and at least play nice again, but still I wouldn't host this shower, even if she does apologize. I like the, "I tried to do something nice for you and all you could do was complain. I will not be hosting any sort of shower".

    I would try to talk to your mom and hash things out. Personally, if I were you, I'd be pretty pissed at my mom (that she could not support you at all and threw you under the bus) and probably wouldn't have super nice things to say, but you know your mom best.
This discussion has been closed.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards