this is the code for the render ad
Snarky Brides

+1s Vent

I just need to get something off my chest, I'm sorry in advance for ranting.

My fiance and I are getting married next month and giant Catholic families being what they are, between the two of us we have 52 first cousins, along with dozens of aunts, uncles, grandparents, siblings, etc. etc. We cut some by only inviting adults, nixing people we're not close to, all the usual methods, but we also decided not to give +1s to the truly single (with one exception - a friend of FI's who won't know anyone else at the wedding who we didn't want to feel uncomfortable.) 

This hasn't been controversial except with my brother and two of my cousins, who have now for the entire length of my engagement (eighteen months) whined to me about this decision every single time they see me. The men in my family have a problem with being told "no" in general and my mother and my aunt have been on my ass about this, telling me I should make an exception, it's just three more people, etc. etc, deaf to any explanations that my family is not more important than FI's and I can't make exceptions for my cousins/brother if we're not doing the same for the other side. 

A few weeks ago my aunt brought the issue up to me YET AGAIN (the day after her oldest son, the chief complainer, told me flat out he had no idea who he would bring if he had a plus one, he just wanted "the option" because my wedding won't be "fun" without it, and "none of [my] friends are pretty enough for him anyway") and asked if I might change my mind if we get a lot of no's. I told her we'd see once the RSVPs came in, which somehow turned into her telling my mom a few days later that I'd changed my mind and was now giving them +1s. Of course I told my mom this never happened, but just now got off the phone with her telling me my aunt was filling out her oldest son's RSVP card (he's 30 and his mom who doesn't live with him is answering his mail for him - noticing a pattern?) and asked my mom should she "just put four people" for her two sons and their +1s?

I'm at work so I'm trying to spare my coworkers overhearing yet another heated call with my mother about this, but it very quickly turned into "Well, I don't understand why you're so stuck on this issue" "why is this such a big deal?" "why does your aunt think you said it was okay?" "don't you know I barely invited any of my friends because we were trying to keep the numbers down" "why does your bridesmaid get to bring her roommate because her boyfriend didn't want to come but they can't have plus ones?" (the answer to that last one is because her roommate is also a good friend of ours who we would have cut otherwise for numbers, but my bm told me way ahead of time her boyfriend wouldn't make it, so we were happy to include our friend.)

I finally broke down and said she didn't understand and my aunt thinks I said it was okay because for eighteen months nobody has listened to a word I've said about it, and it doesn't matter what comes out of my mouth because everyone has only ever heard what they wanted to hear. The fact of the matter is even if I might have been inclined to find a way to make it work eventually, a year and a half of constant entitled whining, pressure from all sides, and bullshit comments like "I need a date but I don't know who I'd bring because your friends aren't pretty enough for me" have completely made up my mind not to be accommodating. I honestly couldn't care less if my cousins/brother have someone to take back to their hotel rooms afterward, which is what this boils down to, and at this point I couldn't care less if they even come. I'm so frustrated feeling like my only ally in this is FI, and not even my mom can stand with me on this.

Re: +1s Vent

  • If I were you I would feign deafness whenever anyone brings this topic up.

    Them:  You must make an exception and give them a plus one!

    You: ...

    Them:  Did you hear me?!  I sad make an exception

    You: ...

    Them:  SYLVEONPLATH!!!!!!

    You: This bean dip is amazing.  Do you want some?
    When she calls me I think all of my phones are going to get really mysteriously staticky. 
    Yeah - it's crazy that you all of a sudden live in a cell phone dead zone ;-)
  • arrrghmateyarrrghmatey member
    500 Love Its 500 Comments First Anniversary First Answer
    edited September 2015
    Stick to your guns on this. Learn to be a master at definitive answers and bean-dipping. 

    Them: They want to bring +1s and we think you should let them.

    You: Sorry, but FI and I are now allowing them +1s. The guest list is final and the matter is closed.

    Them: But what about--

    You: Oh, did you see the news last night??

    And if you do get invitations back with added +1s, be prepared to call them up and set them straight, but don't give in to their demands. "Sorry, bro. But the invitation is just for you, not a +1. If you bring a guest, they will not be accommodated (i.e. no seat, no meal)."
                                     Wedding Countdown Ticker

                                                   image
  • edited September 2015
    hellohkb said:
    The sole fact that your cousin said none of your friends are "pretty enough" for him would be enough reason for me to say "f no" to him bringing a date. How rude of him! I agree with PPs. Keep ignoring their whining. It's one of those "they'll get over it, I did" sort of situations. Which I can definitely relate to right about now..
    You would be AMAZED at what the men in my family can get away with. That comment was explained away as "just a joke!!!!" but my mom straight up asked me why I'm "being such a bitch" about this.

    (I feel the need to say here that my mom in general is awesome, we're very close, I love her, etc. but man you can see the lifelong effects of my nana raising her daughters to wait hand and foot on their brothers, even decades later, with how babied these brats are.)
  • I'm sorry you're experiencing this.

    I'd be tempted to blurt, "This is my wedding, not a singles mixer!" but I'm generally too non-confrontational. Seriously, sounds like these people will know plenty of people at the wedding. They need to stop asking and get over themselves. Easier said than done, but...

    ________________________________


  • Ugh sorry you're dealing with this OP. Two of my cousins were single for the majority of my wedding planning, and my aunt asked when booking a hotel room for them (even though they're in their f'in late 20s) if they'd be getting a plus one -- like if she needed to book one rooms or two for them. I was honest with her: "if they're in relationships, they'll get a plus one." She kind of looked frowny about it but shrugged and booked the one room for her adult sons.

    Flash forward to today, one of my cousins has a new girlfriend who he started dating this summer. Invitations went to the calligrapher before the relationship existed, but I told my cousin in person that she was of course welcome to come. I said something along the lines of "please feel to invite Suzy... we definitely want to make sure our guests are invited with their significant other if they're in a relationship." So after inviting his new girlfriend to the wedding, cousin went off to tell his older brother, my still currently single cousin, that peachy will give you a plus one if you get a girlfriend before the wedding! So UGH now the damage is done and I wouldn't be surprised if my older cousin lets me know that he has someone to bring too. These morons are spoiled rotten and these little extra costs that FI and I will have to pay for go right over their heads.

    In the meantime, my aunt has been pouting to me that she should have booked 2 rooms now that one of her sons has a girlfriend, but the hotel is all full. Amazing that her reaction is to pout and whine instead of suggesting to the coupled-up son to book a room at a nearby hotel if it's that much of a problem.
    Daisypath Anniversary tickers


  • that sucks. I think you should plan for a few more because it sounds like they give ZERO cares about what you are saying and will probably show up with a +1 regardless of what you say or how rude it is.
  • julieanne912julieanne912 member
    1000 Comments 500 Love Its Fourth Anniversary First Answer
    edited September 2015
    Ugh that sucks.  I've noticed a lot of people think they're entitled to have a plus one, even if they weren't invited with one. We didn't invite single people with plus ones due to space issues at the venue... not because we were being cheap, or didn't want our single friends to have fun... there literally was no room legally in the venue for more than 198. 

    FI's college roommate is a cousin of some other friends of ours (a married couple who are invited).  He added his "plus one" to be the couple's dad (his uncle). WHATTT??  And to top it off, I found out originally via a Facebook post that the couple's sister (also not invited since we barely know her) send to the roommate saying "My dad wants to be your plus one to J's wedding".  W T F.  We ended up just letting it go because we received a large number of declines, but still, what makes people think that's OK without even asking first?  Some other friends ASKED about having plus ones with specific people, but nothing like what you are experiencing.  Hopefully they'll eventually let it go :( 
    Married 9.12.15
    image
  • Thank you everyone, it's been really helpful to hear all of your advice, and honestly just to talk to people who don't think I'm doing this just to be an asshole.

    RSVPs are due Monday so I'll see where we are then and decide how hard of a line we're going to take, though honestly I think FI is so tired of hearing about this whining and watching my family put pressure on me (as well as feeling like his family is constantly getting dismissed) that he'd be more than happy to give someone the boot if they show up uninvited.

    A couple of people have mentioned the entitlement and thoughtlessness, and that's exactly that it is - people think "oh it's just a few more people, how much can it be, a hundred bucks?" and forget that a handful more people means more food, more booze, more chairs, maybe more tables, linens, flatware which all add up pretty quickly. Everyone has the attitude of "well I'm just one person, what difference could it make if I do this?" and fail to realize what the consequences would be if everyone thinks that way.

    And @peachy13 - man do your cousins sound like mine. I've had our room block for more than a year (it expires next week) and have been reminding my cousins every time I see them for that whole time to book their rooms. Who ends up doing it? My mom, of course, because how can anyone expect a 25 year old and a 30 year old who live on their own and have full-time jobs to do something as challenging as book a hotel room? Especially when there's ladies around to do it for them.
This discussion has been closed.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards