Wedding Woes

Don't bite the hand you may want to feed you one day...

Dear Prudence,
A couple of years ago, my sister-in-law, a stay-at-home mom, made some nasty comments to me about my choice to continue working after having kids. She never apologized, and while I am pleasant to her out of necessity, it isn’t the same. I don’t trust her. Now her husband is out of work, and she wants me to recommend her for a position at my company. I do not like or respect this woman and do not want to work with her. My husband admits he wouldn’t help either. I know there is a special place in hell for women who don’t help other women, but do I have to help her here?

—Bad Recommendation

Re: Don't bite the hand you may want to feed you one day...

  • Maybe you can help her by pointing her in a better direction. I certainly would never put myself on the line professionally for someone I wasn't enthusiastic about.
  • "I really don't think the culture here is a good fit for you."
  • I would definitely not recommend her. When you recommend someone you're putting your career on the line too and if you don't trust that person it's not a good fit. I can't believe she'd even have the nerve to ask.

    Also I think it's bullshit that there is a special place in hell for women who don't help other women. If you earn my respect I'll help you regardless of gender, race, orientation, religion etc... and reversely I'm not helping people just because we share one of those things in common.
    QFT.

  • VarunaTTVarunaTT member
    Knottie Warrior 10000 Comments 500 Love Its First Answer
    edited March 2016
    I will make a special effort to help other women and other marginalized populations (LGBTQ+, PoC) and I have no issue with saying it or working that. I've found such a lack of representation in the stuffs I do and it's a concern of mine.  Diversity is important. 

    HOWEVER, if you're not someone I would want to work with, just being a marginalized population member isn't enough to overcome that concern.  I want efficient, capable, and impressive people busting down biases, not someone I have to make excuses for.  You're not helping get more diverse representation if you suck at your job/role (which gets into a whole 'nother discussion about higher expectations and institutionalized biases, but that's not particular relevant to the OP).
  • I wouldn't recommend her.  Another issue is that if she is so against mom's working, she likely won't stay at the job for long.  She may be needing something to fill in until her husband gets another job, but then she may quit and you are stuck with the negative impact of recommending someone who flaked out on the job.

    image 

  • Ditto @holyguacamole79 .

    And I'd consider saying, "I need to let you know that the company considers positions here as part of a career path.   Based on some of your previous comments I don't think I can recommend you for a position that may be used as a way to fill a gap." 
This discussion has been closed.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards