this is the code for the render ad
Wedding Woes

Yeah, IDK how you wouldn't feel hurt.

Dear Prudence,
I’m a full-time single dad who’s been raising my now-teenage daughter for the last 10 years. Her mom lives in another state and has her for half the summer. Upon returning home this summer, she told me she wants to live with her mom. I honestly don’t know how to handle it. I told her I would take her desire seriously and talk about it with her, but inside I’m confused and hurt. My daughter and I have a good relationship, so I don’t think it’s that she’s necessarily unhappy. The only thing she says is that she thinks a teenager “needs her mom.” I don’t know the best way to respond or even proceed. Any advice?

—Daughter Wants Mom, Not Me

Re: Yeah, IDK how you wouldn't feel hurt.

  • Set a time to sit down and talk to Mom and daughter separately. Get on the same page with mom as to rules and expectations about behavior. Talk to daughter about why she wants to change now, and communicate the rules you both agreed upon. 

    Unless there is a reason daughter can't live with mom, it might be good for daughter to be able to make a decision and experience living with her other parent. But that doesn't mean LW can't be sad and hurt. 
  • A similar situation happened to a couple of characters in a book I read called Big Little Lies, by Liane Moriarty.  But that was fiction, and this is real life. The parents also lived in the same town. The book was great, btw.

    I'm going to play devil's advocate here and just throw out that teenage girls, however they may act and treat their parents, do actually need their moms.  She may be reaching an age where relating to dad is becoming awkward and potentially uncomfortable and she wants more of a female figure in her life.  Dad is allowed to be hurt, that's a very healthy reaction, but it doesn't sound like Mom lives close enough to accommodate the daughter's wishes if this is actually the real reason.  Joint custody clearly isn't an option.

    I mean, it was super weird having "the talk" with my dad, and forget about telling him I had my first period.  There are just some things a girl needs her mom for that a dad, no matter how good a parent he is, isn't as well-equipped to handle.


    "And when they use our atoms to make new lives, they won’t just be able to take one, they’ll have to take two, one of you and one of me..."
    --Philip Pullman

  • my first thought was that mom has a less strict/more fun house and she thinks it will be more like living with a friend than a parent. that would be a big decision to move away, although I guess we don't know which parent is the one who initially moved away so it could be she has friends/family where mom is.
  • Without knowing more, I'm thinking this might be a "grass is greener" kinda thing.

    As a kid, my parents didn't do the every other weekend thing, we just called Dad and hung out with him whenever we wanted to and there was no formal arrangement. I wanted to live with dad. No reason other than the typical "mom is mean" kinda crap every kid thinks. I lived there for like a week and it sucked. I had a bedtime and chores and shit.

    But I agree with you, Mrs.Conn that it would be impossible not to feel hurt but I hope LW can understand that it's fairly normal.

    Image result for someecard betting someone half your shit youll love them forever
  • As usual, we don't have enough info from the LW. I want to know the reasons behind the original custody agreement. It seems extreme, which makes me wonder what the mom's deal is and if she's really ready for full time parenthood.
  • It has to be a grass is greener situation. My experience with my own teenge years and my friends was that we clashed with our mums constantly. Much more so than our dads. If daughter can have a close or even just good relationship with her mum during her teens then more power to her. I do feel for LW though, has to sting.
                 
  • VarunaTTVarunaTT member
    Knottie Warrior 10000 Comments 500 Love Its First Answer
    edited August 2016
    I also agree with not enough info.  My biomom took me to "visit" away from my grandparent who had been awarded custody.  While I was "visiting", she convinced me I wanted to live with her.  It's pretty hard as a kid to say "no" to your parents on big issues likes this.  It's really hard for me to look at this LW w/out using that lens.

    ETA:  I also kind think it's BS to say that she just needs her mom more.  Dad is perfectly capable of teaching her the things she needs to know about physically being a female, and even mentally.  Neither sex is blessed with "sharing knowledge."  My BFF in HS mother's conversation but sex and femalehood was, "You know all about that stuff,r ight?" after BFF had been taking Mom's tampons for 2 years.
  • A similar situation happened to a couple of characters in a book I read called Big Little Lies, by Liane Moriarty.  But that was fiction, and this is real life. The parents also lived in the same town. The book was great, btw.

    So good. She just released her new one and I've got about 8 hours left (audiobook) and the suspense is killing me. I love her!
    Daisypath Anniversary tickers
This discussion has been closed.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards