Wedding Woes

Clearly, this person does not like the FI.

Dear Prudence,

Our whole family is very worried about my nephew. He is a terrific 30-year-old who has wanted a home and family since he was at least 10. He finally found the love of his life. The two of them have a lot of fun and adore each other. But she was clear from the beginning that marriage was not her goal, and neither were children. Much to the amazement of the intended bride (I think) and delight of my nephew, she accepted an engagement ring. She also compromised on the location of a house they bought together (groan). When family, friends, and fiancée try to discuss wedding dates and plans with her, she leaves the scene. Now my nephew and her BFF are making the wedding plans. Also, whenever she is around children, she is kind to them but obviously has no intrinsic interest in them. They don’t fascinate her or appeal to her. Apparently, they have talked about children, but she will only go as far as to adopt—no pregnancy for her. This whole thing looks like heartbreak in the making for our beloved nephew. Do you see any way the family can assist without alienating my nephew or making the situation worse? So far, we are all on the sidelines.

—Reluctant Bride

Re: Clearly, this person does not like the FI.

  • Being on the sidelines is exactly where you all should be. This is an adult you're talking about and he's well aware of the decisions he has made with his FI. Stay out of his business.
  • Also, children in general don't fascinate me. I am super excited to be an aunt, I love H's neice and nephew and I play with them, listen to their crazy stories and I'm involved in their lives, but do I prefer adult conversations, you bet. That doesn't mean I wouldn't love and be involved with my own children. 
  • And the fact that she's willing to adopt but just doesn't want to be pregnant is not so uncommon. The idea just grosses some women out or they don't see it as necessary to bear children when there are children needing loving homes already. This does not make her (or anyone) a bad person.
  • She sounds like the kind of person who would win the lottery and her first reaction would be frowning on the major taxes she now has to pay.

    Wow, seriously.  Your family-oriented nephew has found the woman of his dreams.  They are getting married and buying a house, albeit with a compromise.  Awesome!  Your nephew and his soon-to-be bride have already achieved the first step of a successful relationship...compromise.

    Next compromise.  He wants kids.  I suspect she doesn't especially.  But is compromising by agreeing to adoption.

    I'm seeing nothing but happy things for the nephew.  Maybe some items are not exactly how he envisioned them, but whose life is?  Obviously he is thrilled with how things are going and is joyfully planning the wedding.

    Me personally, my "white picket fence" is "black wrought iron".  Different, but just as lovely.  So is her nephew's life. 

    Wedding Countdown Ticker
  • If LW hadn't included that Nephew and FI attend family parties, I'd think this was written by MIL's family. They like to think they know H super duper well (He's seen 1out of 10 aunts and uncles more than one time in the last ten years) and that I'm bringing him down and making his decisions for him since WE (FFS) don't want kids.

    I'm with PPs. Butt the fuck out.

    Image result for someecard betting someone half your shit youll love them forever
  • I'm going to go as far as to say that maybe the bride knows that she won't be able to have children (infertility, cancer, was born a man) and doesn't feel the need to share the details of this with folks other than the groom. 
  • I'm wondering if nephew shares his FI's feelings and everyone is assuming it's just her decision ....
    I'm sure she was clear from day 1 her opinions with him.
This discussion has been closed.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards