this is the code for the render ad
Wedding Woes

Why would you tell them?

Dear Prudence,

I work in a big city with a relatively high cost of living. I work at a nonprofit that I feel very strongly about and am happy to have gotten away from the small town where I was often harassed for being gender-nonconforming. However, the grind of living paycheck to paycheck (even when saving often and spending frugally) is wearing me down. I was recently approved to be an egg donor from a very reputable agency and could make $10,000. But I worry about my siblings. No one in my family has ever done anything like this, and I can only imagine the judgment and prying questions I’d face if it ever came to light. My partner knows my plans and is supportive. If we ever have children in the future, I’d obviously share my status as a donor when they’re old enough to understand. But do I need to tell my own siblings? I know they’d be horrified if they found out years later via one of those genetic sequencing companies. But the idea of just keeping it to myself seems vastly easier at this point in my life—especially when I already face so much judgment from them for being gender-nonconforming. What should I do?

—Egg Donor Loner


Re: Why would you tell them?

  • downtondivadowntondiva member
    Knottie Warrior 1000 Comments 500 Love Its Name Dropper
    edited May 2020
    If you're not ready to tell your siblings about this, then don't. They don't need to know everything about you or be privy to every single medical test, procedure, etc. that comes up. They don't sound like a very supportive bunch, so the only thing you'd probably gain from talking to them about this right now is a lot of stress.

    If you think you might want or need to disclose this later on, you can revisit the issue from time to time and decide whether or not you're ready to talk to them about it or if there's any good reason to let them know. That may or may not involve doing your own research with one of these genetic sequencing companies before they do.
    image
  • Again, I think this is a relatively private matter and you don't tell your siblings what you plan to do in this scenario. 
  • drunkenwitchdrunkenwitch member
    Ninth Anniversary 1000 Comments 500 Love Its First Answer
    edited May 2020
    This has me so confused.  How could they possibly find out?  Why would you need to tell them?  Why do you even care about they think?  My brother knows next to nothing about me, because I don't tell him anything but the most basic, visible details about my life.

  • This is odd.  LW is missing the forest for the trees.  The issue is their family members are Judgey McJudgersons who need to mind their own business.  And to LW, I'd keep everything my own business; family doesn't need to know anything that can be ammunition for them.  I do think it's appropriate to tell your partner (at some point if a new relationship happens) and LW's partner already knows and approves, so I think that's it.


  • LW, do you think every AMAB person tells their extended family every time they donate sperm? It's a little more involved, but no more of their business.

    I see no reason to tell them, ever. If it did happen to surface from genetic testing, which is still pretty unlikely, you'd tell them it's none of their business and change the subject. 
  • I'm also not understanding why the LW is wondering if they should tell their family.  Hard No, LW.  You already know the family is going to be their usual jerk selves about it.  There is absolutely no reason they need to know.  Maybe it pops up on someone's DNA Ancestry test.  Someday.  If in the super unlikely event that happens years from now, they can decide what to say at that point.
    Wedding Countdown Ticker
  • No on is entitled to your medical information except for
    providers who need to treat you. Your siblings don’t need to be involved in any of this. Neither do your future children. 
  • I honestly don't see a need to tell them. 
  • Right.  I don’t see a need to tell anyone.  I was so confused because in my mind I READ egg donor but though surrogate for some reason but you cleared it up that she wouldn't be carrying for 9 months and no one would have to know

Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards