this is the code for the render ad
Wedding Woes

H*ll no, we won't go

How do I remind my husband how miserable we were vacationing in the same house as his family, without seeming like I hate his family? For the record, I do not.

We went away with them last year and stayed together in one house, and no one but his sister and her boyfriend enjoyed themselves. His sister constantly dumped care of her stepdaughter on someone else, and they are a family of dramatic tempers. One house, no matter how big, just does not give enough room for them all to separate from each other when they inevitably start picking and arguing. It was also miserable being confined to one bedroom when our two small children would not sleep well and we didn’t want to wake others. After the trip, we discussed it and said that in the future we would travel to the same location, but get our own separate place to stay. My husband’s parents ended up telling us that they also did not enjoy themselves. They said in the future they would prefer to bring their camper with a bed they know works for them and stay nearby.

My sister-in-law just reached out to everyone with a house to rent for this summer. My in-laws immediately agreed to it. My husband said he thinks it will be fine, because this time we would have two bedrooms. I said no and reminded him of how unhappy we all were on “vacation” last year. I told him I will ultimately leave it to him to decide, since it is his family, but if he agrees, I will not be coming on the vacation. I think for him this is just normal, because vacations growing up always included large extended families with lots of blowouts and disagreements. I, on the other hand, actually want my vacations—which I don’t get very many of—to be relaxing. So what can I do? I have two weeks to remind him that this is not what he wanted, and to actually have my vacation with my family.

—Stressed Out in Scottsdale

Re: H*ll no, we won't go

  • Nope nope nope.  I work too hard to be miserable on vacation.  

    If this is your husband's idea of vacation then make a compromise?
    1) You'll go this time but you have booked something else just the two of you shortly after OR he will owe you the X of your choosing (I'm thinking furniture here).
    2) He needs to say no to the next one.
    3) You're in charge of next year's vacation which is booked and private.

    We have kids and I already know that there are not many people we can vacation with.  Unless we're in a HUGE house it's a no and I'd absolutely not vacation with my MIL and FIL. 
  • My IL's have been pushing this for YEARS and i just cannot. They are the type of family who will insist on spending 100% of our time together and all stay in the same house and just in general, they make everything 50x harder than it needs to be. We've been able to push it off, but i can tell they're pissy about it. 


  • We go on a family beach vacation each summer (all under one roof) bc I have a lot of time off, it doesn’t cost much (my extremely outgoing / affluent sister and BIL pay for most of it), and my kids look forward to the nonstop cousin fun all year long. But if all three of those boxes weren’t checked off it’d be a no. I think LW is being completely reasonable both in the boundary and in saying if H goes, she still isn’t.  Stand firm LW!
  • I got side tracked by my IL frustration but I meant to include that I don't actually love her solution of "fine, you go, but i'm not". To me that feels like a decision to make together. It's still your H and kids and your time off. I'd be more pissed that H is going back on an agreement they had made previously that they weren't going to go, and honestly i'd push him harder to stick to that and not leave the decision all up to him. 
  • Oh I missed the small kid part. 

    Nope nope nope.  Although I would be more inclined to tell the H to take the kids and go without me so he could have ALL the fun and childcare he insists will be great. 
  • Casadena said:
    I got side tracked by my IL frustration but I meant to include that I don't actually love her solution of "fine, you go, but i'm not". To me that feels like a decision to make together. It's still your H and kids and your time off. I'd be more pissed that H is going back on an agreement they had made previously that they weren't going to go, and honestly i'd push him harder to stick to that and not leave the decision all up to him. 
    This is where I would be fine with it, assuming this isn't going to drain their entire vacation budget for the year. If I were LW, I would work that week, and then take time off at a different time to either travel with friends or do something with the kids myself, even if that meant doing it without the husband. 
  • That seems like a fair ultimatum to me.  With the hope being that it further underlines/reminds the H of how unhappy they all were during the last vacation and he agrees.

    The LW is still willing to go to the same place and vacation with his family.  The only thing she is asking is for them to get their own accommodations.  That's pretty minor as compromises go. 
    Wedding Countdown Ticker
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards