Dear Prudence,
I (she/her, early 30s) am struggling with some weird and surprising emotions. My best friend (also early 30s) is stunningly beautiful. She’s generous, smart, and capable, and we deeply get each other. When we first met years ago we shared a mutual crush, but nothing ever happened. I’ve always said I’m grateful we never pursued anything since she’s such a wonderful friend.
A few days ago, she texted me that she has a new boyfriend. I told her how excited I was for her, but if I’m totally honest my stomach dropped reading her message. I thought maybe I was jealous of her finding a deeper connection (I’ve been having some existential dating anxiety lately), or that I was disappointed we won’t be single girls together anymore… But now I’m worried I’m just upset that her new person isn’t me.
I’ve never been jealous of her boyfriends before. We are devoted to each other, but we’ve always maintained some distance. I don’t want to risk such an important friendship. We’ve even talked about retiring together. I do not understand what has changed… How can I navigate these new (or maybe not so new) feelings? Help!
—Hopefully Overreacting