Wedding Woes

It's up to you to respect your boundaries and they can be mad all they want.

Dear Prudence,

Let me first start by saying my husband and I have a very solid relationship and I feel very fortunate to have a loving and supportive partner. Where we struggle is with my in-laws. My husband and I were both raised in households where family time was a big priority. However, the way in which our families differ is how they go about wanting to spend time with us. My in-laws forcefully insist on spending time with us and struggle with the boundaries we have put in place over the years. I often am made to feel bad if I can’t attend a family event (sometimes there are multiple a week).

The latest is a debacle over Easter. After changing plans to better accommodate their schedules, we agreed on celebrating my brother-in-law’s birthday Friday night with my husband’s family, then celebrating my nephew’s birthday with my family on Saturday, followed by Easter on Sunday including both families. After lunch, my husband and I planned to go home so I can prepare for an international trip that I leave for on Tuesday. However, my father-in-law is insistent that we go to their house after to spend more time with them. I nicely but firmly stated that I really needed the afternoon to get my work and affairs in order for my trip, to which he responded that we “should come for an hour.” I feel like no matter what I say or do my boundaries are not respected. When incidents like this happen my husband will have a conversation with his parents but things never seem to improve. I genuinely do not know what to do anymore, the only strain in our relationship involves his family and I am tired of things not getting better.

—At a Loss

Re: It's up to you to respect your boundaries and they can be mad all they want.

  • This isn’t what boundaries are. You don’t need to get him to like it or stop asking. “Our plan was to join you for lunch and then go home and that’s what we are doing.”  “This isn’t up for discussion.” “Ok we are heading out bye.”
  • "We are not doing X" 

    Old men can keep telling you what you think you need to be doing.  You're a grown up.  Tell old man you make your decisions not him. 
  • I understand it's annoying, but they can't really change their in-laws/parents.  Just keep standing firm on boundaries and don't let them get trampled.
    Wedding Countdown Ticker
  • There's no magic conversation here that will make them see why their 'demands'/behavior are problematic.  Just because FIL thinks stopping by for 'just an hour' after brunch is no big deal doesn't mean anything. 

    Stop over-explaining yourself.  "We can come to brunch and then we have plans in the afternoon."  Those plans can be a nap, but it doesn't matter.  They don't own your time and you don't owe them anything beyond what you can commit to. 

    If you H can't stand up for you/your family and is pressuring you to cave to them, then you have a husband problem.  


  • Unless he’s being rude or threaten to disinvite you if you don’t go for the extra hour- ignore him and go about your plans. H’s parents will invite us to things after we’ve said we can’t make it- I prefer to frame it as “they’re letting us know it’s okay to show up for any amount of time if we can or if our plans fall through”. They rarely change but how I feel about it is significantly better. 
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards