Wedding Woes

He's their dad...

Dear Prudence,

After many years of marriage to my kids’ father, who was an alcoholic and involved in many sexual relations outside the marriage, I finally left the marriage and have tried to maintain a firm boundary of not interacting with him. My relationships with my three sons are struggling because of this.

In spite of their knowing of their father’s behavior, my sons continue having a relationship with him and his new family. I feel that I have gotten little support or compassion from my sons, even though I have shared that I find it hurtful. As a result, I have just kept my feelings to myself and tried to maintain a relationship with them as a good mother. I am thinking that perhaps I need to restrict my relationships with my sons because of how much this hurts.

—Trying to Be the Good Mother

Re: He's their dad...

  • You divorced their father.  They did not divorce their father.

    What you're asking is not fair and you need serious therapy.  You made a choice to end a relationship with a person who was unfaithful and suffering from alcoholism and that makes plenty of sense.  But you're also asking as part of this divorce decree for your children to have cut him off  and that sounds unreasonable.  Be careful for what you wish for because while he may have been the worse parent on paper, if he's not setting these expectations for your sons, they may not pan out.

    Please seek a great therapist to help unpack this and cope with untangling that mess.
  • Nothing says "good mother" quite like threatening to cut your kids out of your life if they insist on having a relationship with their other parent. 

    Just let them go. They're better off without you. 
  • Divorce can be painful and hard with the best of situations and this isn’t that. But you divorced their dad, he is still their father. You have to separate your feelings for him from your feelings for them. They don’t know the details or the pain or what happened in your marriage and they shouldn’t. Get therapy to help you move forward because cutting your kids off isn’t it. 
  • ei34 said:
    Your exH sounds like he was a terrible spouse, but your sons weren’t married to him.  You’re entitled to go low contact but you can’t dictate their reaction to him. Giving them an ultimatum will not go your way. 

    Look, my kids don’t know the worst of exH’s behaviors. I’ll be horrified if they become adults who do some of the things he did to their future partners. But if I try to keep them from him now, I’m the one they’ll resent someday. (Not touching the fact that he often chooses to not see them during his time now. He’s really missing out.) 

    Some people make the mistake of venting to their children about the other parent, when that person is an ex.  Sometimes it can't be helped that children will know about bad behavior, especially when they witness it themselves.  But bad mouthing the other parent usually hurts the kids far more than it does the other person.

    Even when they are adults.  When I was dating him, my ex-bf's (R) dad left his mom.  R was in his mid 20s.  His mother was more sad than angry, but inappropriately shared some of the angst she'd had throughout the marriage.  Like how the dad had been a serial cheater the first few years they were married.  That had happened over 20 years earlier and R didn't need to hear any of that or the other negative things she shared.  It caused him to feel hurt and upset.  At his dad's actions, but also annoyed at his mom for telling him in the first place. 
    Wedding Countdown Ticker
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards