Dear Prudence,
For reasons I can’t fully articulate, I enjoy writing fake Reddit posts as a creative outlet. I am a prolific poster. I concoct outlandish but plausible situations to post in “AITA” and similar subreddits. Sometimes I take details from real life as inspiration, but in general everything is completely fabricated. Recently, my boyfriend found my Reddit account and read all my posts. Crap.
He was understandably upset—based on my post history, it looks like I’ve cheated on him with dozens of people, had a life of crime, lied about my identity, you name it. But it’s all fake, and just something I do for fun. I tried to explain my weird hobby to him, but because there are a few snippets of real life in there, he refuses to believe me. How can I prove to him that I’ve always been faithful and the posts are all false?
—Unreliable Narrator