this is the code for the render ad
Wedding Woes

Looking for an out?

Dear Prudence,

I’ve been with my fiancé, “Shane,” for the last three years and we are supposed to be getting married in June. He’s everything I could ever want in a partner, save one thing: Shane suffered horrific physical and emotional abuse as a child. When he sleeps, he has terrible nightmares that cause him to cry out in terror. It doesn’t happen as much as it used to, but when it does, it’s frightening for me. He went to years of therapy to process the abuse and he has been able to lead a functional life, but the nightmares remain. I know he can’t help it, but I’m beginning to rethink marrying him rather than listen to this for the rest of my life. Is that a reason to end things?

—He’s Not Completely Fixed

Re: Looking for an out?

  • Is he still in therapy? 

    I think it's up to what you can deal with but I also would question how would you want your partner to behave if the shoe was on the other foot?   

    This just seems selfish to me unless the terrors are abusive.  And I'd recommend your own therapy together because it's understandable to be scared but I don't know why you wouldn't want to be there for a partner at a time he's most vulnerable. 
  • I think it’s valid to feel afraid, but I’d want to know if he’s still in therapy, if there are other ways trauma manifests that makes you feel afraid, and whether there is any violence. I can’t tell from the letter if LW is annoyed they’re being woken up or if there’s a legit fear something could happen. 

    Instead of just walking out talk to him- what would make him feel secure, what makes you feel safe. Is separate bedrooms occasionally an option? 
  • I think it’s valid to feel afraid, but I’d want to know if he’s still in therapy, if there are other ways trauma manifests that makes you feel afraid, and whether there is any violence. I can’t tell from the letter if LW is annoyed they’re being woken up or if there’s a legit fear something could happen. 

    Instead of just walking out talk to him- what would make him feel secure, what makes you feel safe. Is separate bedrooms occasionally an option? 
    And...what would you expect him to do if the shoe was on the other foot?

    I know my grandfather was in WWII and I only found out about 18 mo ago after my mom read The Women at my recommendation (and it's SO GOOD but not an easy happy read) that my grandfather had night terrors until he died.  They married before he went to war and PTSD wasn't exactly treated in our Greatest generation.  And 20 years ago my mom was violently assaulted in her classroom after hours by a person who raped two women in the local area her age.  I didn't ask her about her sleep habits but man, it would have been awful if my father left because life got hard because she was a victim of a brutal assault.  Loving someone and making a commitment to them doesn't mean bailing - especially when they're unconscious. 
  • banana468 said:
    I think it’s valid to feel afraid, but I’d want to know if he’s still in therapy, if there are other ways trauma manifests that makes you feel afraid, and whether there is any violence. I can’t tell from the letter if LW is annoyed they’re being woken up or if there’s a legit fear something could happen. 

    Instead of just walking out talk to him- what would make him feel secure, what makes you feel safe. Is separate bedrooms occasionally an option? 
    And...what would you expect him to do if the shoe was on the other foot?

    I know my grandfather was in WWII and I only found out about 18 mo ago after my mom read The Women at my recommendation (and it's SO GOOD but not an easy happy read) that my grandfather had night terrors until he died.  They married before he went to war and PTSD wasn't exactly treated in our Greatest generation.  And 20 years ago my mom was violently assaulted in her classroom after hours by a person who raped two women in the local area her age.  I didn't ask her about her sleep habits but man, it would have been awful if my father left because life got hard because she was a victim of a brutal assault.  Loving someone and making a commitment to them doesn't mean bailing - especially when they're unconscious. 
    I would expect him to do the same thing- evaluate for himself if there is an actual safety concern he has and what measures they can or should take to alleviate them. And if they can’t- I don’t think someone, anyone, should be shamed for saying they’re not cut out to handle sleeping in fear every night. 
  • banana468 said:
    I think it’s valid to feel afraid, but I’d want to know if he’s still in therapy, if there are other ways trauma manifests that makes you feel afraid, and whether there is any violence. I can’t tell from the letter if LW is annoyed they’re being woken up or if there’s a legit fear something could happen. 

    Instead of just walking out talk to him- what would make him feel secure, what makes you feel safe. Is separate bedrooms occasionally an option? 
    And...what would you expect him to do if the shoe was on the other foot?

    I know my grandfather was in WWII and I only found out about 18 mo ago after my mom read The Women at my recommendation (and it's SO GOOD but not an easy happy read) that my grandfather had night terrors until he died.  They married before he went to war and PTSD wasn't exactly treated in our Greatest generation.  And 20 years ago my mom was violently assaulted in her classroom after hours by a person who raped two women in the local area her age.  I didn't ask her about her sleep habits but man, it would have been awful if my father left because life got hard because she was a victim of a brutal assault.  Loving someone and making a commitment to them doesn't mean bailing - especially when they're unconscious. 
    I would expect him to do the same thing- evaluate for himself if there is an actual safety concern he has and what measures they can or should take to alleviate them. And if they can’t- I don’t think someone, anyone, should be shamed for saying they’re not cut out to handle sleeping in fear every night. 
    Yes I get that.  I realize my response was to you but it was really to the LW.  Ideally there are options here so sleeping in fear isn't the only course of action. 
  • That’s your only issue LW? I’ll legit take him off your hands if night terrors is the only thing. 

Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards