I actually don't live in Pittsburgh, but we used a Bethel Bakery for our daughter's baptism last weekend and I wanted to rave about how wonderful they were!
We used Bethel Bakery (based off a recommendation someone gave to my Mom who is originally from the Pittsburgh area- she visited family and brought the cake to NYC for our baptism). The cake was delicious and beautifully decorated. They made it super easy to order, we did everything over the phone. I can't speak highly enough regarding how great the service was and how awesome the cake was.
(I always rave about our travel agent and photographer on here, so I'm adding Bethel Bakery to my vendor list
)
Good luck ladies!