Wedding Etiquette Forum

Lovely ladies of The Knot are RIGHT about your PPD!

Hi everyone!

This is really more of a post to say thank you, and a word to the newbies, rather than a question I have.

I came to these boards originally with a question about the wedding I'm planning for next November 2015.  I later learned what I was asking about was considered a PPD.
I was utterly convinced what I was considering was NOT wrong, or inconsiderate - I even spouted the classic "MY circle of people wouldn't care."  I honestly cringe at the fact I said that.  I have come to understand where I was wrong, and why.

I have also come to learn that the opinions of the ladies on here can be brutal, but they are HONEST!  I've lurked quite a bit since I made that post and now after reading numerous posts with all the comments/advice from these Wedding Veterans on here, I can't tell you all how much I appreciate your advice.  I read a post on here recently "It's no wonder etiquette has gone to hell" which I feel really zero's in on where I was coming from.

BritLady talked about how people are not brought up this way anymore.  It's a sad fact that our culture and society IS deriving from this, and into this "IT'S MYYY DAAAYYY! And I'll do what I want.  Anyone who doesn't like it doesn't have to come." 

HisGirlFriday13grumbledoreSchatzi13  who always seem to be completely spot on.  My grandmother would be the person to ask for all the correct and proper ways to host this wedding for my friends and family, but I lost her years ago - well before getting married was even a passing thought in my head.  Thank you all for being such a reliable and honest resource for me to seek out when I (and others alike) need to know what the "Right" thing to do would be.

To all the the PPD planners - Take it from someone who was in the SAME boat you are, these ladies are absolutely correct in saying it is WRONG for you to try and get married on one day, and then have a "Real" wedding on a different day.  The argument that got through my thick skull was this:  You don't want to deny your family and friends, the people you love, the experience of witnessing your REAL ceremony.  My reason was because he's foreign and we have to work around some Visa time constraints.  My thought was to get married in time for the Visa, but then to have our "real" wedding on a different date I had told his family from New Zealand would be on.  I wanted his family to have the traditional wedding experience, even if it wasn't on the day we signed papers.  But by thinking this way, that was EXACTLY what I was doing.  I was denying them the opportunity to see their son make a life long commitment to me.

The argument of saying if they REALLY care about you, THEY WON'T CARE is BS.  If they REALLY care about you... they'll get there on the day of your real wedding (even if that meaningful dating anniversary falls on a Tuesday) and appreciate it for what it is (even if it is small and a casual courthouse wedding), because THAT was the day you made a promise to your partner to be with them and love them
- in sickness, and in health; for richer, for poorer; to love, and to cherish for as long as you both shall live.

/endthanks
/endrant


image
Wedding Countdown Ticker


image

Re: Lovely ladies of The Knot are RIGHT about your PPD!

  • kitsunegari89kitsunegari89 member
    500 Love Its Third Anniversary 100 Comments Name Dropper
    edited March 2014
    http://media.tumblr.com/9bc34396ae34da82a46c07b34027920c/tumblr_inline_mifk5fR0eB1qz4rgp.gif

    And just because you can't have a "wedding" doesn't mean you can't have one helluva party to celebrate your marriage!
    My colors are "blood of my enemies" and "rage".

    http://media.tumblr.com/tumblr_m3h1kr8sYk1qzve89.gif
  • Amen sister!  I think that is the #1 thing for me - if you really want your loved ones to be there when you get married, then do it in a way where they can  be - when you really do it, when it's REALLY binding, when it's real.  That's what's important.

    Wedding Countdown Ticker
  • I agree @grumbledore! OP, it's good that you learned the difference between the two. It's a great feeling to have all of your loved ones there watching you get married and it be real, not something that's pretend. I know that will mean a lot to them as well! Happy planning and welcome to TK! :)


    image
    Wedding Countdown Ticker


    image
  • Beautiful, just beautiful.

    I ♡ you.
    Anniversary
  • How wonderful to see someone who originaly disagreed come back with a different mind set. When people seem to be sticking their fingers in their ears at advice I'm always hopeing they are still learning even if they don't see it yet. You give me so much hope. It would be great if all the newer people could come across this post before posting anything. Wish it could be a sticky.
    image
  • Can I just ask about what would be classed as a PPD? I know it's a wedding after the legal wedding, but I've been to a 'wedding' of a catholic and an atheist. The ceremony and reception I went to was the catholic ceremony with over 200 people, but literally the day previously, they had had an atheist ceremony (which was the legal ceremony) which only had five people there; the Bride and Groom, officiant and the Brides parents (who also acted as witnesses). It was very important to the groom that he get married in the church he attended every week, but there preist wouldn't let the bride say non-catholic vows, so as it was also important to the bride that she had her beliefs recognised, so they had to gave two ceremonies. The first ceremony was just a ceremony, no reception or anything.

    I was just wondering if that counts as PPD, since they had no real guests at the first ceremony? (Not that I'm considering it, just wondering). Nobody bothered that legally they were already married, since the only guests were the Bride's parents, and they were only there because they needed witnesses.
  • Can I just ask about what would be classed as a PPD? I know it's a wedding after the legal wedding, but I've been to a 'wedding' of a catholic and an atheist. The ceremony and reception I went to was the catholic ceremony with over 200 people, but literally the day previously, they had had an atheist ceremony (which was the legal ceremony) which only had five people there; the Bride and Groom, officiant and the Brides parents (who also acted as witnesses). It was very important to the groom that he get married in the church he attended every week, but there preist wouldn't let the bride say non-catholic vows, so as it was also important to the bride that she had her beliefs recognised, so they had to gave two ceremonies. The first ceremony was just a ceremony, no reception or anything.

    I was just wondering if that counts as PPD, since they had no real guests at the first ceremony? (Not that I'm considering it, just wondering). Nobody bothered that legally they were already married, since the only guests were the Bride's parents, and they were only there because they needed witnesses.
    Honesty, I am surprised a Catholic priest would have married them knowing they were already "legally" married. That is NOT taking the Sacrament of Marriage in the Catholic church. If they were already married, they would have needed a convalidation. Right @HisGirlFriday13
    Anniversary
    image
This discussion has been closed.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards