I am Catholic, FI is not. His brother will be signing the marriage license as Best Man, and I have twin best friends who are my Matrons of Honor. I am struggling to select the twin who will sign the paperwork. We have been best friends for almost 30 years and I just cannot decide!
They are both Catholic; Twin A is married to a non-Catholic and Twin B is married to a Catholic. Twin A lives within 20 miles of me, so I see her a lot; Twin B is about a 2-hour drive away. Twin A's children are our flower girl and ring bearer; Twin B is expecting in August (yay!) I'm wondering if I should ask one to sign as our witness, and ask the other to be our first-born child's Godparent?
Edited: paragraphs are wonky today.