this is the code for the render ad
Wedding Party

Bridesmaid Woes: Need Advice

Recently, I have been having some issues with one of my bridesmaids. She really hasn't done anything wrong, in fact, if anyone is to blame would be me. 

We use to be best friends in middle school however during high school we drifted apart. We never had a fight or a fallout or anything to that effect, but we did grow apart. After high school (and college) whenever we ran into each other it has always been pleasant and seemed natural as if we have seen each other everyday. She later moved to San Diego and did not mention anything to me. I pondered the idea of asking her to be a BM but FI advised against it. In hindsight I see his logic, our relationship is not what it once was, but I asked her anyway, and she was excited to accept. 

Earlier last month, I had called her to see how she was doing and she brought up some wedding plans. She explained to me that I "should fire her" because she is under some tight financial constraints. My heart sank a little because it came to me as surprise. I explained that she only had to buy the dress and didn't have to participate in any pre wedding parties. I also offered to pay for her transportation and hotel room for both nights. I than also offered to pay for her dress and her hair since she feels she cannot do anything with her hair. 

I tried calling her that weekend and she said she couldn't afford the phone call so I quickly hung up. I began to think, she really cannot afford to do this. She must have a prepaid phone and is it really fair for me to pay for everything for one of my bridesmaids and not all of them? I send her an e-mail explaining with utmost tact and kindness that all that really matters is that she be present for the wedding as a guest. It does not matter where she sits or what dress she wears as long as she is there.

She called me a few days later and she thanked me for my kind e-mail. We talked a little about it and as I was hanging up she asked if I sent her dress yet as her mailing address has changed. I then reiterated that she not have to be a part of the wedding party and that I will not be offended. She said she has another wedding to attend around that time and so she will already be spending money. She also than said she is going to have buy a dress for my wedding anyway at that point so it should cost the same whether she attend as a guest or as BM. I said, ok if you are sure, but I don't think its fair that I pay for your dress, hotel, hair, and transportation but not the other ladies. She got a little upset and began to argue with me about it, I realized it was becoming an emotional issue so I explained all you have to do is show up in the dress and be on time. I explained why I asked her to be a bridesmaid and that I knew we had a falling out but that she was my first friend when I moved to this town. That I don't care how you do your hair, I don't care what kind of shoes you buy, you don't have to show up for the rehearsal, just be on time. I offered some suggestions for shoe color as she was clueless as what to buy and she laughed at me saying color suggestion was ridiculous. We ended the conservation on a bad note. 

BM contacts me via email and asks if I was still having "that girl do her hair" and that she realizes she should be there the day before the wedding hinting that I offer to pay for her hotel. I told her the time of the ceremony and that "I suggest you be ready to go at the hotel no later than 5:00PM as the ceremony is at 5:30PM that way we won't make guests wait on the beach for us."  I also reiterated that she can do whatever she chooses with her hair and that my friend will not be asked to travel out of town to do her hair. I said no one is expected to pay for their hair or make-up and can do their own. 

No reply. 

I really don't feel good about having her stand with me in the wedding and realize that she does not share the same sentiments about our relationship that I do. I see this in hindsight and I realized part of the reason why I invited her was because I wasn't sure who else to invite and I always thought she would stand with me if I ever got married. Bad reasons I know. I am awful. But, what I did is done and am not sure how to move forward at this point. 

Any suggestions?

Re: Bridesmaid Woes: Need Advice

  • Ok, first off I do agree that you are partly to blame for all of this. However, if she is in another wedding and buying a dress and incurring other expenses for that wedding without issue then it is unfair for her to expect or to accept your offer to cover these things for her, especially since it is not something you had planned on doing for everyone. 

    At this point I think all you can do is to honour your offer to pay for her hotel and the minimum of what else she would need to be involved in your wedding. It would not be advisable to kick her out of the wedding party unless you want to end the friendship. Good luck to you.
  • Jen4948Jen4948 member
    Knottie Warrior 10000 Comments 500 Love Its 25 Answers
    It does seem to me that you put a little unwarranted pressure on her to participate as a bridesmaid, especially when she said she wanted out of the wedding party at first.  I do agree with @singinchick13 that it is unfair for her to expect you to cover all your costs.

    Since you offered to pay for her hotel, it would be fair to expect you to honor that offer, but aside from that, I would not go out of your way for this BM.  That said, you can't kick her out of your wedding party without jeopardizing your friendship.
  • Well, I didn't mean to place unwarranted pressure on her. When she joked I should fire her due to her financial situation I felt like I was pressured to pay her way. When I tried to let her know she shouldn't feel obligated to be in the wedding she got upset and became argumentative. 

    I guess I know why I wanted her to be a BM but not really sure why she wants to be one. 
  • You should not have offered to pay for things and then changed your mind. None of the other bridesmaids need to know you're paying for her hotel and hair. People just have different financial situations. We put up one couple in our wedding party. Granted, it was at my grandmother's house rather than a hotel, but we would have paid for a hotel if it was the only way to get them to the wedding since they were/are kind of extremely broke.

    Back off and only talk non-wedding things for a while to give her time to decide and follow through with whatever she's going to do.
    image
  • IMO, if you offered to pay for her dress, travel and hotel, I think you should honor that. The other BMs don't need to know. Like a PP said, everyone has different financial situations. 
  • I have backed off, and I don't instigate any contact. I have not e-mailed her again since our last conversation either. I think we have had a total of 5 conversations, including email and phone calls, since she has accepted the role 6 months ago.

    She accepted and then 2 months later joked I should fire her due her financial situation because she stated that she accepted excitedly without giving it much thought. I can understand that. I felt guilty and then offered to pay. As a recent college graduate, my cousin is not doing well either financially.. and she is coming out of state. Its really not fair that I pay for one BM and not the other. Whether or not they know about it. 
  • KGold80KGold80 member
    500 Love Its 500 Comments Name Dropper
    perdonami said:
    I have backed off, and I don't instigate any contact. I have not e-mailed her again since our last conversation either. I think we have had a total of 5 conversations, including email and phone calls, since she has accepted the role 6 months ago.

    She accepted and then 2 months later joked I should fire her due her financial situation because she stated that she accepted excitedly without giving it much thought. I can understand that. I felt guilty and then offered to pay. As a recent college graduate, my cousin is not doing well either financially.. and she is coming out of state. Its really not fair that I pay for one BM and not the other. Whether or not they know about it. 
    No, it isn't fair, but it also isn't fair that you offered to pay for her stuff and now you don't want to. I think you got yourself stuck between a rock and a hard place here.
    Wedding Countdown Ticker


    image
  • KGold80 said:
    perdonami said:
    I have backed off, and I don't instigate any contact. I have not e-mailed her again since our last conversation either. I think we have had a total of 5 conversations, including email and phone calls, since she has accepted the role 6 months ago.

    She accepted and then 2 months later joked I should fire her due her financial situation because she stated that she accepted excitedly without giving it much thought. I can understand that. I felt guilty and then offered to pay. As a recent college graduate, my cousin is not doing well either financially.. and she is coming out of state. Its really not fair that I pay for one BM and not the other. Whether or not they know about it. 
    No, it isn't fair, but it also isn't fair that you offered to pay for her stuff and now you don't want to. I think you got yourself stuck between a rock and a hard place here.
    I think so too. Worst part is as of right now I am just ignoring the situation. Haven't called for a follow-up or emailed her. Just kind of letting things go and see what happens.
  • Jen4948Jen4948 member
    Knottie Warrior 10000 Comments 500 Love Its 25 Answers
    perdonami said:
    KGold80 said:
    perdonami said:
    I have backed off, and I don't instigate any contact. I have not e-mailed her again since our last conversation either. I think we have had a total of 5 conversations, including email and phone calls, since she has accepted the role 6 months ago.

    She accepted and then 2 months later joked I should fire her due her financial situation because she stated that she accepted excitedly without giving it much thought. I can understand that. I felt guilty and then offered to pay. As a recent college graduate, my cousin is not doing well either financially.. and she is coming out of state. Its really not fair that I pay for one BM and not the other. Whether or not they know about it. 
    No, it isn't fair, but it also isn't fair that you offered to pay for her stuff and now you don't want to. I think you got yourself stuck between a rock and a hard place here.
    I think so too. Worst part is as of right now I am just ignoring the situation. Haven't called for a follow-up or emailed her. Just kind of letting things go and see what happens.
    Probably what will happen is that she won't get the dress or a hotel room and thus take herself out of the wedding party.

  • Jen4948 said:
    perdonami said:
    KGold80 said:
    perdonami said:
    I have backed off, and I don't instigate any contact. I have not e-mailed her again since our last conversation either. I think we have had a total of 5 conversations, including email and phone calls, since she has accepted the role 6 months ago.

    She accepted and then 2 months later joked I should fire her due her financial situation because she stated that she accepted excitedly without giving it much thought. I can understand that. I felt guilty and then offered to pay. As a recent college graduate, my cousin is not doing well either financially.. and she is coming out of state. Its really not fair that I pay for one BM and not the other. Whether or not they know about it. 
    No, it isn't fair, but it also isn't fair that you offered to pay for her stuff and now you don't want to. I think you got yourself stuck between a rock and a hard place here.
    I think so too. Worst part is as of right now I am just ignoring the situation. Haven't called for a follow-up or emailed her. Just kind of letting things go and see what happens.
    Probably what will happen is that she won't get the dress or a hotel room and thus take herself out of the wedding party.
    So do I just not say anything then?
  • First, you are not awful.  Yes, you did some things that put you in this mess, but so did she.  Your biggest mistake was asking someone to be a BM that you really aren't that close to.  It wasn't the best decision, but it certainly doesn't make you a bad person.  You shouldn't beat yourself up for this.  

    Even though she joked that you should fire her, you really can't kicker her out now without looking like a jerk.  You shouldn't feel obligated to bend over backwards to get her there, but you should live up to the promises you made her.  If you said you'd pay for her dress, you should pay for it.  True, it isn't "fair", but you didn't promise your cousin you'd pay for her dress.  

    Can you offer her a place to stay with you or with a friend/family member?  Do you have a friend that could do her hair on the cheap?  Can you get her a cheap dress off ebay?  

    When is your wedding?
  • MyNameIsNot Our wedding is the first week of September. If I provide her lodging it will have to be for a hotel as it is somewhat a DW. Its about a 2 hour drive from my residence and it is a late evening wedding as the reception ends at 11:00PM. As for the dress situation, one of my BM already purchased it and so changing the attire at this point would be super unfair. Although, maybe there is a version of it that I could find for her. 


  • Jen4948Jen4948 member
    Knottie Warrior 10000 Comments 500 Love Its 25 Answers
    perdonami said:

    Jen4948 said:
    perdonami said:
    KGold80 said:
    perdonami said:
    I have backed off, and I don't instigate any contact. I have not e-mailed her again since our last conversation either. I think we have had a total of 5 conversations, including email and phone calls, since she has accepted the role 6 months ago.

    She accepted and then 2 months later joked I should fire her due her financial situation because she stated that she accepted excitedly without giving it much thought. I can understand that. I felt guilty and then offered to pay. As a recent college graduate, my cousin is not doing well either financially.. and she is coming out of state. Its really not fair that I pay for one BM and not the other. Whether or not they know about it. 
    No, it isn't fair, but it also isn't fair that you offered to pay for her stuff and now you don't want to. I think you got yourself stuck between a rock and a hard place here.
    I think so too. Worst part is as of right now I am just ignoring the situation. Haven't called for a follow-up or emailed her. Just kind of letting things go and see what happens.
    Probably what will happen is that she won't get the dress or a hotel room and thus take herself out of the wedding party.
    So do I just not say anything then?
    The only thing I'd say to her is that you're prepared to honor your promise to pay for the expenses that you already agreed to.  If she makes her participation conditional on anything in addition to this, I'd just tell her that it isn't possible but not say anything further.  Then if she doesn't follow through, she's not a bridesmaid and that's that.
  • phiraphira member
    5000 Comments 500 Love Its Second Anniversary 5 Answers
    You offered specific financial assistance; barring really dramatic circumstances regarding your finances, you should honor your promise. It's okay that you're paying for one person and not another. Just don't broadcast it. You're not obligated to make additional financial promises, obviously.

    I just want to point out that it really sounds like your friend is playing a really annoying game of chicken when it comes to being a bridesmaid. I had something a little similar happen to me. Basically, it's really, really inappropriate and rude to kick someone out of the wedding party. It's NOT equally rude or inappropriate to back out of a wedding party, but for a lot of people, it seems like it's  impossible to do. So essentially, she doesn't want to be the bad friend by saying, "I'm sorry; I can't be a bridesmaid." Instead, she's making excuses, hoping you'll kick her out (so it can be "your" decision and she's not being a bad friend or letting you down by dropping out).

    Unfortunately, though, you're not really able to kick her out, because that's rude.

    What I think you should do is keep wedding talk as minimal as possible for a bit, until you need to confirm any arrangements. If anything starts to sound kind of hinky, like she's back to making comments about how she can't afford such and such, or you deserve a better bridesmaid, or anything like that, then say, "[Friend], it means a lot to me that you're my friend and that you're in the wedding party. I'm not going to be upset with you if you really just can't be a bridesmaid. However, I need you to understand that if you're not up for it, you can back out of the wedding party, and I will be 100% not upset with you. But I can't kick you out, and I'm not going to kick you out."
    Anniversary
    now with ~* INCREASED SASSINESS *~
    image
This discussion has been closed.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards