Wedding Etiquette Forum

Etiquette Check for Planning

I've been lurking around the Knot, and I've posted a few times about my crazy-ass FILs.  At this point, we've moved the wedding up from July 2016 to December 2015, and we're about to book venue/ceremony space.  The wedding will be under 20 people at a restaurant, hence why I'm not sweating it 8 months out.

We're going to be married by the owner's relative who is the "marriage officer" for the local township; I have no idea what this is, but it sounds like the right department to me.  We'll be married at the restaurant, probably at the table, and then just head on into dinner.  Dinner will be "order anything you want, we'll pay."  I'm hoping to get menus without prices from the restaurant, but if not, we'll just have to DIY on nice paper. No cake; the restaurant has good rep for desserts.  For a favour, we're looking at a brass Christmas ornament with our names and the date on it,  and Black and White Cookies (NYC staple, 2 per person, and my favourite dessert) for the road. 

I'm in the UK right now, and the groom is in/from Texas.  Rather than making everyone haul to the UK, we're having it in NY/NJ near my parents.  Mom will be handling RSVPs and  the investigation for the site, etc, so my parents are hosting.  FI and I are paying for everything, however.  Ma's been a good scout so far, and I'm quite grateful.   

FI's parents....we're anticipating flak.  Everything FI has shared with them so far has been met with objection and derison, and some of the request the mother has made have been outrageous "You're 8th generation Texan, so we will pay for Slayer to fly out to get a marriage license here."  (Have not been offered any other money toward the wedding, nor has a check for that flight+cat sitter+hotel materialized) .  "You need to have your brother as best man." (brother is on verge of divorce and not that tight with FI)  "Your father was the first person to hold you because you a C-section, so I want him to marry you off." (First, wtf.  Second, this is what happened at the brother's wedding; we do not want a repeat.) 

As a consilatory gesture, FI asked whether she would like him to wear her father's watch during the wedding.  "It would desecrate his memory to take the watch out of TX."  It's legally FI's anyway, so it will happen if he wants it, but holy cow.  No pleasing this lady.   We've stopped sharing wedding info; their next notice will be the invitations. 

We're expecting pushback in regard to the location (not in Texas), the invitations (they're not hosting or contributing, and it's not a family tree), and how small/minimal it will be.  I'm honestly a little worried about the last bit.  We're doing it within the budget we wanted (including a round trip plane flight for me to get there), and we're doing it at the half-way point between TX and UK, where the two of us are.  In contrast, FI's brother had a multiple day event at a golf course, and ours is jetset -- in, wedding and dinner, out.  I feel a bit bad for making people fly from TX for a dinner wedding, but at the same time, I'm flying transatlantic for the same purpose (and seeing the fam for the first time in 2+years). 

Anyway, I'm posting here to see if anything I'm doing is egregiously rude.  I can understand people RSVPing no for how far and what it is, but that's them making a choice; I just want to make sure I'm not doing something shit-show horrific (I'm not booking transport to/from the airport, and I should.  I'm not having a cake, and I should, etc etc etc.)  Thanks in advance!

Re: Etiquette Check for Planning

  • I don't see anything wrong here. It sounds like you are hosting your guests properly and trying to be considerate with regard to the location. If a guest decides it's too much travel for a low-key wedding, they are free to decline.

    I'm sorry you're going through all that with your FMIL. When she gives unsolicited input your FI can say "Thank you for that suggestion, but __________ has already been finalized." Repeat as necessary.
    Wedding Countdown Ticker



  • It sounds like you're hosting properly, and frankly sounds like a perfect event. I'm sorry you have to deal with your FILs being so difficult over not getting married in Tx. You're going to be married, that's all that matters. Have fun!
    image
  • Everything sounds great!  As long as your FI is backing you up and is in agreement with all the plans then that is all that matters.  His parents sound cuckoo.  I mean I know Texans are very proud of their state but this is just crazy.

    I would rethink the Christmas ornaments though.  Or at least rethink putting your names and wedding date on them.  I like Christmas ornaments but I really wouldn't use one that has someone else's names and wedding date on it.

  • Good point re: the ornaments.  I just feel as if I have to have something more permanent than cookies to give someone traveling so far.  I picked the brass ornament idea because my parents were given a series of them by my mom's bestie to commemorate major events: wedding, baby #1, new house, baby #2, etc.  Any ideas?  Perhaps just the ornament in the shape of wedding/holiday bells?  Or something completely different?
  • I think the ornament is fine as long as your wedding date isn't engraved on it. it will be near impossible to find a favor that everyone will like, keep and use.
    BabyFruit Ticker
  • I think your plans sound really nice. You aren't doing anything rude or wrong. 

    I agree on skipping the ornaments, though. Maybe have one made for just you and your parents. I like wedding favors I can eat (like the cookies). The generic bottle openers and wine stoppers and whatnot always end up being donated to Goodwill. (Plus, walk down the glassware aisle at any Goodwill and you'll see tons of wine glasses, champagne glasses, and shot glasses with random people's names and wedding dates on them) 
    image
  • Good point re: the ornaments.  I just feel as if I have to have something more permanent than cookies to give someone traveling so far.  I picked the brass ornament idea because my parents were given a series of them by my mom's bestie to commemorate major events: wedding, baby #1, new house, baby #2, etc.  Any ideas?  Perhaps just the ornament in the shape of wedding/holiday bells?  Or something completely different?

    You don't have to reward your guests for coming to your wedding, regardless of how far they have to travel.  They are travelling because they want to.  And sorry but an ornament isn't going to make me go "I am so happy I traveled to this wedding because I get an ornament!"  No, I am traveling because I want to see you get married and celebrate with you, an ornament isn't going to top that.

    And if you want to do the ornament I would just leave any wedding-ness out of it.  Why not pick a design that means something to you and your FI?

  • I think what you are planning is awesome. It hits all the points you need.

    1. You are properly hosting your guests.
    2. The people paying are getting the appropriate amount of say. (AKA you two and 100%)
    3. You are limiting wedding talk with those who are going to complain.

    The only thing I can/could add is letting your FI deal with his family if/when something comes up, and it pretty much sounds like you are. So keep going with your bad self. :)

    Oh and side note: I am a life long Texan and I love my state dearly but the reasons she is giving are crazy. My gut says this has nothing to do with Texas, there is something deeper at play here.
  • aliwis000 said:

    I think what you are planning is awesome. It hits all the points you need.

    1. You are properly hosting your guests.
    2. The people paying are getting the appropriate amount of say. (AKA you two and 100%)
    3. You are limiting wedding talk with those who are going to complain.

    The only thing I can/could add is letting your FI deal with his family if/when something comes up, and it pretty much sounds like you are. So keep going with your bad self. :)

    Oh and side note: I am a life long Texan and I love my state dearly but the reasons she is giving are crazy. My gut says this has nothing to do with Texas, there is something deeper at play here.

    Thanks for the kind words -- that goes for everyone.  I'm glad I'm doing everything ok etiquette wise. 

    As your gut feeling, absolutely.   But it's her favourite tool to use, and it's evolved to spectacular levels over the course of the 11 months we've been engaged.  I frankly wouldn't give a toss about her shenanigans if they didn't wear on FI so much; the line about his grandfather hurt, and deliberately so.  So mum's the word on future planning.  My side has made the process easier, fortunately. 
This discussion has been closed.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards