We are in the search of a location for our rehearsal dinner on a Thursday for 65 people. Our church is in Commack and we have some guests staying at the hotel in Westbury. I would like to find a place closer to Commack if possible, but if not, then anywhere in between the two locations. With our larger group we have trying to find a restaurant that would have a private area.
So far have looked at : Orlandos, La Scala, Maninos, Butterfields, Taoromina, Olios, John Harvards, Old Street Pub
Orlandos has been the most affordable- $27 a person (including wine and beer) and we have been there before and loved the food but want to keep looking- Does anyone have any other ideas?