Wedding Woes

I don't think she's a good 'crisis' friend.

Dear Prudence,

I need advice on how to deal with a friend whose selfishness is really, really getting to me at the moment. She has always tended to be one of these people who has to “one-up” you when it comes to hardships in life—e.g. you say that you didn’t get much sleep last night, and she’ll laugh and say, “Yeah, I’ve had insomnia since I was 10, so I don’t even REMEMBER what a good night’s sleep feels like!” I once complained about ableist discrimination I faced at my work (I’m partially deaf) and instead of sympathizing or even asking me what the outcome was, she turned it into a conversation about the discrimination she faces as someone who needs a walking stick. There are many, many examples, but you get the idea.

Aside from this habit, she is a great friend in many ways—she put me up when I was homeless once, we laugh a lot together and bond over some niche shared interests. But her selfishness is becoming a real problem. I recently messaged her about a very serious crisis I’d been dealing with —I was violently sexually assaulted at work, my partner has fallen sick, and my mental health has been devastated as a result of the above. I sent her a message saying what was happening and indicating I needed someone to talk to about it. She didn’t respond for three days (unusual for her) and then replied with a lengthy message about her own current mental health crisis, which she made sure to emphasize was worse than mine (“I don’t have a partner to support me either and actually needed hospital”) and included not a single question about the things I had told her about my situation. I was too angry and upset to reply. My question is, what on earth do I say?

—She Always Has It Worse

Re: I don't think she's a good 'crisis' friend.

  • Ignore.  She’s not someone to confide in anymore.

  • She isn't a good friend.  Save her for wine nights and shopping but do not consider this person a good friend or even truthful. 
  • She is a good times friend. Don’t expect more from her and lean on other people who are reliable. Not everyone friendship can be everything to you. 
  • This person reminds me of a majorly problematic girl in my daughter's grade.  Chiquita arrived home after the first day of school this year to tell me she told this classmate what happened and the classmate invented a major break in her arm causing her to be able to only move it partially.  Somehow the arm was fixed the next day.


  • She is a great friend for certain things.  That's okay, that's true of people.  Accept her as she is or end the friendship b/c you keep expecting something different.
  • I understand that some friends are better for certain situations than for others.

    But this friend's response, or lack thereof, would be friendship ending for me.  The LW reached out in crisis and told a friend they were violently sexually assaulted at work (which also has ramifications for their employment), their partner very sick, and they were feeling emotionally devastated.

    Even for a friend who isn't the best at sympathizing, I would at least expect them to reply quickly and say something like "I'm so sorry to hear about what happened to you!"  At least some kind of acknowledgement and feeling bad for their friend. 
    Wedding Countdown Ticker
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards