Dear Prudence,
I’ve been dating “John” for several months. Because of certain practical issues, we haven’t slept over with each other much. I am a bit of a light sleeper and don’t really like sleeping in someone else’s bed. Recently, there were a few instances where it was more convenient for me to sleep with him. The only reason I agreed to this is that he sleeps like the dead and has a nice setup so that I wouldn’t hear him when he gets up. I sleep well with him, but the issue is that he doesn’t respect my desire to get a full night’s sleep. I have a chronic illness that can mildly flair if I don’t get enough sleep. I can sometimes get away with an hour less, but not more. I have always, even before I was sick, valued my sleep. John doesn’t. He likes to get up early to do things even if we have had a late night out. I have told him a few times that I don’t want to wake up early for things. He is usually good about this, but every so often he thinks something is so important that he should wake me up.
This happened over the weekend. To be fair, he found an event that I would have absolutely loved, but it was fairly early. Usually if he does this, he will let me go back to sleep but for some reason, he didn’t this time. On top of that, if I am awake too long in the early morning, I won’t go back to sleep. John was pretty relentless about getting me up, so finally I turned over and sleepily said “leave me the fuck alone.”
He looked stunned and I was, luckily, able to fall back asleep. When I got up, John was gone but left a note saying my behavior was shockingly atrocious and he didn’t want to see me for a while. I have gone back and forth about my behavior. Generally, when in a fight, I think it’s not ok to say something bad about the person or to use something I know about them against them, but I’ve never cussed someone out before. I’m worried I crossed a line. On the other hand, I could not get him to leave me alone and it seemed like a bit of a sleepy “survival” tactic at the moment. I am a bit upset that John didn’t listen to me the first time. I’m wondering if you can give me a verdict on whether my behavior was as bad as my boyfriend sees it.
—Sleepy Fight