this is the code for the render ad
Wedding Woes

LW is sending mixed messages, imo

How do I balance my kid’s negative self-talk about their body with both the messaging that “fat” isn’t bad, but also, there can be connections between what you eat and how your body feels and looks? I have a very sensitive 11-year-old boy who struggles with anxiety and depression, and he has expressed recently that he is unhappy with his body, that his belly is too big, and his arms aren’t strong enough. We’ve talked about all bodies are good bodies; that what you see on TV and online isn’t reality; that the professional athletes he admires focus their entire lives on diets and exercise because that’s what their bodies need to perform; that all of us are bigger or smaller or stronger or not at times, and it’s very normal to sometimes compare ourselves to others and feel sad or worried about it.

And at the same time, this kid inhales candy and sweets like there’s no tomorrow and has to be constantly redirected towards fruits, vegetables, and proteins. I don’t restrict any foods, and don’t make judgments about good or bad. But I’m struggling to hold all of this. I want him to feel good about himself, I don’t want to make things worse, and I would love it if he laid off the candy a bit.

—Fat Isn’t Bad, but Fruit Is Good

Re: LW is sending mixed messages, imo

  • I think you need to get the candy out or restrict it.  It's flat out not smart to overdo the sugar no matter how tasty it is.  So rather than fat shame, start by working on a smart diet.  Admit you screwed up and were lenient and start to educate the kid on what a good diet looks like so he can make smart choices.  

    I struggle with this SO MUCH with the kids and say, ALL the time how we're not just going to eat sweets.   It's not that I'm fat shaming (my kids are not overweight and actually the opposite) but I'm not going to promote bad eating habits and a diet of refined sugar that's actually linked to a lowered immune response. 
  • I agree with @banana468 that being a bit stricter about sugary foods might be necessary - foster the idea that candy and sweets should be more of a treat than a habit. Maybe it can go hand-in-hand with LW working with their son to find healthier snacks that he will enjoy. 
    image
  • This is such a hard thing to balance. My dudes are still little enough that they're not getting snacks and treats on their own and we generally follow the philosophy that they can have an unlimited about of whatever is "available". I don't want them to feel scared of sugar or "treats" but learn that everything needs to be eaten in moderation. I don't want them eating 6 servings of broccoli just like i don't want them to eat 6 cookies. Neither will make you feel good. 

    So i might put cookies on the dinner table once a week. They might take a couple, they might take none - either is fine, but there's only that amount available. Same with fruit, or pasta, or whatever. I DON'T make that kind of stuff available 24/7 in unlimited amounts or in a place they can access themselves. That's just silly. 
  • Listen, if most adults can’t control their sweet intake when it’s a free for all, you can’t expect your 11 year old to. You are the parent. Restrict what is available in the house. Invite him to help you cook healthy meals. If he’s truly struggling with body image then you might need to see a therapist who specializes in that along with a nutritionist. Boys can have eating disorders too. 


    image
  • We do the same @casadena, we don’t do unlimited sweets or any other food but we try and do moderation and offer lots of options. But my kid is 3.5, not 11. 

    I think LW needs to think about their own connection between candy/sweets and body image. If 11 is talking about his belly, his arms not being strong, etc- how is LW talking about how to keep bodies strong? Is he in sports or activities? Does he know about exercise making you feel good and strong? Is LW making comments about their own body?

     Eating candy alone isn’t going to make you feel sluggish and weak and if he suddenly stops with the candy and starts loving veggies and meat it’s unlikely to solve this problem. 
  • short+sassyshort+sassy member
    Knottie Warrior 10000 Comments 500 Love Its 5 Answers
    edited February 2024
    It's such a tightrope to walk and I don't think there is a perfect answer because everyone is different.

    I know my parents did their best, but I also feel they had too many "no, no" foods that were rarely in the house.  Like CHIPS!!!!!  Anytime I could get my hands on chips, I would gobble down as many as I could.  They were one of my favorite foods, but I almost never had access to them.

    And chips are still ingrained in me as one of the most delicious, but "forbidden", foods ever.  I mostly gave them up about 7 months ago, when I went on a stricter, mostly protein diet.  I haven't missed them as much as I thought I would.

    However if God came down and granted me one day where calories didn't count, I'd eat entire large bags...with an "s"...of chips, lol.

    But then, my parents also rarely had candy/cookies/desserts in the house, but I've never had a sweet tooth and didn't care about that.

    On the bright side, my mom loved to cook and both of my parents liked a wide variety of food.  Most of it was fairly healthy.  Or at least my mom never fried things.  I was never picky about food...other than not liking most vegetables...because I was fed all kinds of different meals.  And I grew up to be an adventurous eater and enjoy a lot of healthier foods, as long as it's flavorful.  Be liberal with seasonings.

    But then I also spent my formative years in the '80s.  The Scarsdale diet.  Slimfast shakes.  Being fat is bad and a moral failing.  Healthy is eating as few calories as you can!  At least for women.
    Wedding Countdown Ticker
  • It's such a tightrope to walk and I don't think there is a perfect answer because everyone is different.

    I know my parents did their best, but I also feel they had too many "no, no" foods that were rarely in the house.  Like CHIPS!!!!!  Anytime I could get my hands on chips, I would gobble down as many as I could.  They were one of my favorite foods, but I almost never had access to them.
    This was my childhood.  I found ways around it.  Like going to my friends’ places who didn’t have restrictions or just walking to mac’s with my allowance.

Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards