Wedding Vows & Ceremony Discussions

Remarried father won't walk me down the aisle

I'm hoping some fellow Knotties might help me with this one. 

My parents have been divorced for 15 years, my father has been remarried for 10. I had hoped, and still do, that both my parents would walk me down the aisle. While my relationship with my father has been more complicated than the one I have with my mother, it is deeply important that the two of them walk me down the aisle and give me away. The ceremony will be at a charming hotel, officiated by a friend, so it's fairly informal and only somewhat non-traditional, but I do want both my mother and father to walk me down. 

A few months ago, my stepmother informed me (among other details) that my father wouldn't walk me down the aisle with my mother. She claimed it voids out his current marriage. The whole conversation left me somewhat flustered because the day really isn't about my parents' relationship(s), it's about the relationship between FH and me. I confirmed with my father and he said he will not walk me down with my mother. He suggested that he walk me halfway and my mother walk me the second half. While this seems like a possible fix, it also symbolizes the divorce and the divide in my family, which is the last thing I'd like to call attention to on my wedding day.

Apologies for being sentimental, I know that often, brides with remarried parents may have the stepparent and biological parent walk them halfway and then the other bioloical parent (and possibly other stepparent) walk them the other half.

If this didn't feel like a flashing neon divorce sign, I might consider the half and half walk. It also seems largely fueled by whatever insecurities my stepmother harbors toward my mother. However, I really don't feel like symbolizing their differences and dislike of each other on a day that is a-not about them and their divorce and b-supposed to be full of love and good wishes for my future marriage.

Has anyone else encountered a situation like this? I know I can't make my father walk me down and I have expressed how important it is to him that both he and my mother walk me down. I also could use tips on how to break the news. It has been a few months since we discussed it and it hasn't come up since. Is it a terrible faux pas to wait until closer to the wedding to let him know? I'm thinking of posing it to him as such: "Dad, it's still my wish that you and mom both walk me all the way down the aisle, but I will respect your decision if this is not within your comfort zone." I don't expect my father and mother to dance or be seated together. It's just that the walk down the aisle feels pretty important. Thanks in advance for any ideas on this.

Re: Remarried father won't walk me down the aisle

  • Im sorry, youre father is being very selfish. Nothing states that if he were to walk you down the aisle with your mother it would void his current relationship. Although I dont know your stepmother I feel like something she said to him may be the reason why he has refused to.

    If you dont want to do it the way your father suggested (& I dont blame you), I would suggest to just have your mother walk you down the aisle and tell your dad something like "It would mean a lot to me if you would walk me down the aisle with mom the entire way, I respect youre decision not to and in that case I will just have mom walk me down the aisle. If you change your mind you are more than welcome to as well". Maybe he will change his mind after that but he seems pretty set against it. I dont understand why he cant put aside anything for not even 2 minutes and walk his daughter done the aisle.

    522805_10151186959893168_80368830_n_zps80e4c057
    Wedding Countdown Ticker
  • Could you give him a different role? Like pp said you have already said what you want, and he can take it or leave it, I wouldnt push the issue, but maybe if you have something else for him to do so its not an all or nothing dependent on walking with someone he doesnt want to (for whatever reason), maybe he can answer for the parental 'giving/blessing' question, or do a reading or something else that includes him? Relationships are tricky things, I wouldnt want to stir the pot too much! (Especially at the time of a wedding...no one needs extra family drama when they are about to all have to spend time together!)

    May 2012 July Siggy: Favorite Vacation Spot Kaleden, BC
    July Fave Vacation Spot photo IMG_0268-1.jpg

    Daisypath Anniversary tickers
    My Blog:Through My Eyes

  • spimentspiment member
    10 Comments Second Anniversary
    Wow--I'm so sorry this would have me so angry--particularly at father's new wife. I agree, though, you can't make him do anything. 

    Personally, I'd probably ask him out to lunch alone, just him and let him know you find this hurtful and that at the end of the day he and your mother did have a relationship, and you are half each of them and that it's really ugly to have their divorce on display on a day where it is supposed to be about unity and forming a new family and ask him to go home and seriously reconsider it.

    And if he still says no and that his new wife's insecurities trump your wishes (What a load of bull) then just have your mom walk you down all the way.
  • I have to agree with the others. If he chooses to put his new wife's wishes above yours, for two minutes on your wedding day, then he's forfeiting the right to have ANY honor at the wedding at all.  I wouldn't reward his childish tantrum by giving him something else important to do.  He doesn't want to walk you down the aisle, fine. He doesn't have to do it, and he can be seated like any other guest.  He can have his way, and your mother (who I assume is willing to walk with her EX and is acting like an adult about all this) can have the sole honor of giving you away. 

    I also think that, if my father did something like this, it would seriously color my view of him and it would have lasting negative affects on our relationship. If you think this might be you too, I think he has the right to know that and to use the information when making his final decision. If he's willing to give up what's left of his relationship with you over this, then that's up to him, but he should know that's what he's sacrificing to get his way.
  • If I were in your position, I would just have mom walk me down the aisle.  Your father is being selfish. 

     

    Sounds like your step mother is insecure about her relationship with your father, and they are making it your problem.  I would sit down and tell him one last time that this is how you want it done.  Let him know it has nothing to do with his current wife.  They are both your parents, and this is what you want.  If he still refuses, tell him he can sit this one out.

     

    I agree that the half/half walk is a little tacky.  (Sorry to anyone that has done it). 

     

    If your relationship with your mom is great, her walking you down the aisle will symbolize that. 

      
    image
  • I agree with PP's. I would try and talk to him and let him know how important it is that he walk you down the aisle on your most important day. The fact that your mom will be walking with you too should have no bearing...he should be more than happy to respect your wishes and suck it up for 3 minutes. Like PP said, I have a strange feeling your stepmother may have said something to get in your dad's head and make it even worse.

    That being said, I know exactly how you feel. This will be my 2nd marriage, and my dad didn't even show up to my first wedding. His current wife and I don't get along at all (haven't since I was a child...my parents divorced when I was 5) and I wasn't given any notice that he wasn't going to be there like he said he would. Good thing I suspected this would happen and had my younger brother fitted for a tux just in case.

    I'm about 99.9% sure he won't be at this wedding either and as much as it sucks, I've come to terms with it. I have a lot of anger towards him for not coming to my first wedding and if he doesn't come to this one either, I don't know when or how long it would take me to forgive him. It sounds like things with you and your dad and stepmom are not anywhere near the way they are with me and my dad, and I hope that your dad will come to his senses and realize how much this means to you. Regardless of whether he does or not, I think it's wonderful that your mom will be walking you down the whole way.

    Good luck to you, hope it all works out!
  • PeavyPeavy member
    1000 Comments 5 Love Its
    I am a MOB, and here's my opinion -- He and your mother made a beautiful child together - you.  No matter what their differences, that fact remains.  So he can suck it up for two minutes and walk down the aisle with the mother of his child.  It's absolutely no reflection on his current marriage, only of his relationship to you as your father.
  • Your dad is an idiot.  Regardless of their current relationships, they are still your parents...that's what having them both walk you symbolizes (that they are your mother and father, not husband and wife).  If he can't put aside his petty and childish feelings to escort you as your parent, then I'd tell him that he's more than welcome to just sit down and take no part in the ceremony and your mother will walk you the full way.

    I wouldn't give in to the compromise of having them walk you only halfway because you are right, that would draw much more attention to the fact that they are divorced (and that he apparently can't be civil for less than a minute) then it would be to just have your mother walk you by herself.
    Anniversary
  • I agree with PPs. My bio-father and step-father are both walking me down the aisle and they are both completely for it. My bio-dad actually told me that if I only wanted my step-dad, he would understand since my step-dad really has been more of a dad. I chose both. They REALLY don't like each other but are putting their feelings aside for me. Your dad is being a child and his wife is being a biitch. Have your mom walk you all the way if dad wants to be like that.
    Wedding Countdown Ticker
  • I agree with PP's.  I'm not thrilled with my ex-husband, and I don't think my teenage daughter is either, but when the day comes, if she wanted us both to walk her down the aisle, I could suck it up for her sake.  Your dad is being a putz, sorry you have to deal with that.  Void his current marriage, wow I think I have really heard it all!
    Wedding Countdown Ticker
  • i agree with all of the pps !

    definitely sit down with him (without your stepmom cause like everyone else i think she said something to him too) and explain to him the situation (like everybody else suggested) and basically make it an all or nothing type deal and he can sit with that and if he decides to be selfish... thats his problem and he will regret it in the future!
  • Well I am so sorry to hear that they are being so selfish.  I do understand where you are coming from both my parents are remarried and both of his parents are remarried and the only thing everyone agrees on is they all hate each other :)

    But to get back to the point. Yes I think you can put it on the back burner and maybe he will feel differently in a couple of months. PP are right about a lunch with just the two of you and just be honest. This is want, are you in or not? (probably should say it nicer than that)

    Good luck.
  • A few months ago, my stepmother informed me (among other details) that my father wouldn't walk me down the aisle with my mother. She claimed it voids out his current marriage.

    You're stepmother is completely wrong. Regardless of their divorce, they're still both your parents and that's what them walking you down the aisle symbolizes. You can't void a marriage doing this. That's absurd and she sounds insecure and paranoid. I'd let your father know he can either walk you down the aisle with your other parent or not walk you down at all. No giant loss, really. He misses out, is all. 
    image
  • Sorry to say this because you sound like a lovely young woman but I will put it to you bluntly. It is your dad's loss. Have your mom walk you down the aisle and enjoy your day...this is about you, your FH and the FUTURE...not their past. Be happy!
  • Lisa50Lisa50 member
    2500 Comments 5 Love Its Combo Breaker
    In Response to <a href="http://forums.theknot.com/Sites/theknot/Pages/Main.aspx/wedding-boards_ceremony-ideas_remarried-father-wont-walk-me-down-the-aisle?plckFindPostKey=Cat:Wedding BoardsForum:10Discussion:74a58501-cbdf-405a-986d-020b52b6c43cPost:077f695d-425b-4762-98af-1d23bc03c9de">Re: Remarried father won't walk me down the aisle</a>:
    [QUOTE]I am a MOB, and here's my opinion -- <strong><font color="#0000ff">He and your mother made a beautiful child together - you.  No matter what their differences, that fact remains.</font></strong>  So he can suck it up for two minutes and walk down the aisle with the mother of his child.  It's absolutely no reflection on his current marriage, only of his relationship to you as your father.
    Posted by Peavy[/QUOTE]

    I agree, wholeheartedly!  As a mom of an adult son (divorced his father when my son was 5), I cannot imagine something as important as his wedding coming along and either his dad or me refusing to engage in whatever he asked of us as part of the ceremony/celebration.  *sigh*  My heart goes out to you.

    I'm not so sure I'd go as far to call your dad an idiot, but his wife is certainly a piece of work.  I am so sorry you have to deal with this. It's really a shame.

    Keep holding your head up.  You've done what you can to bring him into the fold of your wedding ceremony.  The next step is his.  I wish you all the best.
  • edited May 2012
    If voiding a marriage was that easy, there would be hardy any demand for divorce attorneys.
    Your father's wife sounds like a petty b!+ch and your father sounds like a spineless milquetoast. They deserve each other.

    Let your dad know it's important to you that both of them walk you all the way. If he doesn't want to do that, he can watch your mom walk you all the way, from his seat.
                       
  • I agree with all the others PP...
    Your father has decided not to be a part of your wedding... It has never been you that decided that.
    In fact i think that your step-mother has much to do with his decision, because no father in the world would give up on that. She told you the "news" herself, sounds like it was her decision.
    Try to talk with him without your step-mother, tell him what it means to you and that your wedding it's about you and your FI, it's all about your relationship and not about his with your mom. And tell him that walk half with him and half with your mom sounds like divorce, and the day is NOT to be about it, it's suposed to be about love, and about THEIR daughter

    .

  • aragx6aragx6 member
    2500 Comments 5 Love Its Combo Breaker
    I agree with everything that's already been said, but I wanted to add that I hope you come back and update us!
    Lizzie
  • Thank you all for your thoughtful comments and suggestions. This is my first post I've ever made and I'm really appreciative of all you've offered for me to think about. 

    Update: I'm in CNY and my dad is in Wisconsin. Unfortunately, we won't be in lunch and talking range before the wedding otherwise that would be my first choice. My plan is to talk with him over the phone or to write a letter emphasizing how much it means to me that both he and my mother walk me down without the halfway hand off. I agree it does seem more like my stepmother's decision and I have thought of speaking to her, but in the end it's my father's decision. Hopefully he changes his mind but if not I will have my mother walk me all the way down. It's too bad my father and stepmother can't see this is about my father's relationship to me and not my mother, which is probably why it hurts and why I take it so personally. I will update when I have some news.

    Thank you all again. 
  • My parents split 15 years ago as well and don't get along at all. When i first told my dad about about the wedding his first response was that if my mother goes he won't! His feelings towards my mum are that raw. Obviously this upset me very much, a good friend (my boss who also knows my dad) saw him at my place of work and took him aside for a quiet chat and pointed out the sterling job he's done bringing me up and asked him why he would (a) wish to hurt me by not being there and (b) not take that pride in himself for being such a part of my life.
    Maybe you have an objective friend or family member that can lay it out for him in similar terms without emotion and make him see that it's not about his feelings although it's very hard for him and that he should be there to take the credit for creating the person that i am. It was very effective, not only has he agreed to walk me down the aisle he's also going to suck it up for the whole day and not be unpleasant to my mum or my step-dad! Result!
  • It sounds to me the insecurity and displeasure is from your stepmother. I am not sure what your relationship with her is, but maybe you could do something special for her to make her feel more secure? I'm not even sure what to suggest, maybe your father could walk her down and seat her then later walk you down the aisle. I would not compromise on your wish. If you father insists on not doing it, I would let him seat your stepmother and have your mother walk you down the aisle. It is your day. As you said it isn't about your father and mother's relationship, it's about a new chapter in your life you are starting with your FI. I hope it works out for you.
This discussion has been closed.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards