Help me make a decision? (Bedding related)

divinemsbee

So, FI and I are down to the final four of new duvet covers we like. Of course, at this both of us have seen the pics so many times we're done, so I though I'd offer it up to some fresh eyes. Let me know what you think...

1. http://www.bedbathandbeyond.com/product.asp?WRN=-482036932&SKU=200179&RN=27&

2. http://www.bedbathandbeyond.com/product.asp?WRN=-482036932&SKU=200177&RN=27&

3. http://www.bedbathandbeyond.com/product.asp?WRN=-482036932&SKU=121705&RN=27&

4. http://www.bedbathandbeyond.com/product.asp?WRN=-482036932&SKU=127202&RN=27&

I want something that's fun but also classic and not too trendy, I want it to be something we don't want to replace in a year. He really likes traditional manly things, but likes any of these. We both want something that either has some color in it or will look good with some brightly colored or matching curtains or art since we rent and can't paint walls.  Most of our sheets are white, and that's the only color sheets we registered for. 

Zimsgirl

I really like #2

FutureMrsSS

I like 1. I think it looks classy, and since it is more neutral colors it can go with any curtains or art. 

tyleet87

I am IN LOVE with #3! I actually almost put it on my registry but didn't. Re-thinking that now.

Irishcurls

I'm partial to 1 and 3 only because they're more neutral and can be changed up with other colors when you move (unless you don't plan to keep it that long). Three is just a touch more funky and there are a lot of colors you could play with for curtains, throw pillows to change the look.

BinxRose

I like number 3

AmandaSC1988

I like 1.

crimewatcher

We have #3 as our Guest Room set and LOVE IT! We registered for it and didn't get it, so my Mom got it for me as bday gift. The accent pillows are spendy!! I use a purple and orange flower pillow I already had from a crazy Ant. You really can pull any of the colors out. We even have a funky orange lamp that matches.

kara811

I would also go with either 1 or 3, I'm a bit more partial to 3 though as I really like that color pallette. Plus it's very spring/summer and I do my sheets according to seasons! 

CAB1217

#3

Sammy0709

#3

lrh17

I vote #1, but #3 is a close second

divinemsbee

Thanks guys! I had actually put number 3 on my registry when I was in the store, but took it off later because I wasn't sure. We both really like number 1, FI likes the pattern and the colors (his favorite was 4, which is not mine, at all).