Ring help!?

pillsburyaj

First of all, here is my ring:

Am looking for wedding band. Torn between 4. There are pro's and con's to each.

A) http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&item=270764954862#ht_1253wt_1219

Very pretty, front runner. No warranty or appraisal.

http://www.pompeii3.com/showproduct.aspx?ProductID=981&SEName=50ct-diamond-eternity-ring-14k-white-gold

Similar to one I tried in store and loved. Can buy warranty and appraisal.

C) http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&item=400235400131#ht_2117wt_1007

Love this. Could definitely be worn alone. Am afraid it will overwhelm my diamond.

D) http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&item=180643456300#ht_1889wt_986

Pretty and sparkly. But, not sure that I like that the diamonds don't go all the way across. 

I am def taking a crap shoot by ordering online and I would be able to return any of these rings if need be. I'd just like to order the right one the first time. 

Would love some input. FI says whichever one makes me happy, so what help he is. 

Joanne1984

I like #2. But, I think you can get bands that are equally as pretty in store for a similar price. I would be very hesistant to by diamonds online. 

Madisonpenny

Mine is very similar to the last one you posted.  My engagement ring is similar to yours.
It's really hard to choose a wedding band unless you put it with your engagement ring to see how it looks.
I definitely would not buy a ring without some type of warranty so that automatically takes the 1st one out of the running.

michelle11988

I would say second ring is the best.  Any idea what size stone your e-ring has in it? Maybe go to the store and see what size stones look good next to it and shop from there online.  I wouldn't buy anything like this online without an appraisal and warranty.

butterflyjumper1

i definitely, definitely would not purchase my band online. you can find options that are just as pretty and just as reasonably priced in a chain store as you can online.  i wouldn't be comfortable purchasing something that i could not get appraised that would not have a warranty.  that being said, i think the second one is gorgeous!! 

i think you should at least go into a store and try on similar bands and see how they sit with your engagement ring. a picture doesn't show you how the band will actually sit when it is on your finger next to your e-ring. 

good luck!!! please keep us updated! 

ajmom2two

I like the first 2.  My e-ring is very similar to yours and I tried on bands very similar to the first 2 in store and really liked them both with my ring.  Good luck!  I would go in to a few stores and see what you like with your ring.  There were a couple that I tried that I just didnt think went well with mine.

bblouin

I liked the lAst one the best. I like how it doesn't go all the way around because then it can be sized if you gain or lose weight. I would never buy a ring without a warranty. With ebay I feel as though you never know what you are getting yourself into

AllyG303

I like #2 since the diamonds around the band look smaller than the others.  I think it would compliment your e-ring rather than overwhelm it.

elizabethmae315

I like number 2, but im a big sparkle fan. 

I would agree with PPs though, be very careful about online buying! there are usually great deals in store that you can get, and be able to try them on. Putting it on was a big deal for me, to see what the ring will look like for forever after july. you want it to be perfect!