I'm looking at 2 J Crew dresses on either eBay or one of the preowned wedding sites that I really like. Neither dress is from the current collection, so trying them on isn't an option. I've found both dresses in my size and they are both very affordable, but I'm having a really hard time deciding which one to get. Granted if I get one and really don't like it I could always try to resell it.
Details about me and the wedding: I'm almost 41 and this will be a 2nd wedding for both of us. Small wedding in a chapel with dinner following at a nice restaurant. I'm 5'3" and currently about a size 4-6 (though I would like to lose a bit).
Which dress would you choose?
Kate

Vivian

I know they are both pretty simple. That is pretty much my style so that's what I'm drawn to.