August 2012 Weddings

Bridesmaid etiquette question?? Semi long!!

Ok, so I have been having trouble getting one of my bridesmaids to commit to much, and we were supposed to go dress shopping this weekend.  Today she calls me and explains that with both her and her husband in the wedding it is too much of a commitment since they have a fairly young child, and are worried about who will watch him during the wedding etc.. She kindly explained the situation and asked me if there was anyone I could replace her with.  I told her that I understood (because I do) and am not offended or hurt (because I'm not because I get where she's coming from). 

I have a sister in law who would likely step into the spot for me (she is my personal attendant and I had thought of her right away as we are close), but I know my FI has 2 sisters who would also love to be asked.. About a month ago they threw a hissy fit because they weren't in the wedding to begin with!  I cleared up their hissy fit by asking them to be ushers (which they agreed to because then they could wear black dresses that are similar to the bridesmaids red ones).

My only fear now is that if I ask my sister in law, that there will be a WHOLE drama fest with my FIs sisters because they aren't asked again..  FI does have another friend who we can ask to be a 4th groomsman (or he can ask my brother), but I feel icky about doing that because we had agreed on 3 on each side when we started planning. 

Another problem is if I choose my sister in law, my 3 attendants will be in 3 different states (my best friend is with me in MN, my sister is in Texas, and sister in law is in Utah).  If I choose my 2 FSILs they are both in MN.  This is stressful for me.. I plan on calling my Mom to ask her opinion, as well as talking to FI, just looking for suggestions on how to handle this delicate situation?? 
Wedding Countdown Ticker

Re: Bridesmaid etiquette question?? Semi long!!

  • because she stepped down I think it is fine to replace her and I would ask whoever you really want to be in the wedding
  • It sounds like it could start drama with your new family to not ask these girls.  Will your sister-in-law be offended if you don't ask her?  If yes, just don't ask anyone and leave the sides uneven.  If no, ask both your FI's sisters, since they want to be involved.
    127image 88image 39imageWedding Countdown Ticker
  • DO NOT REPLACE YOUR BRIDESMAIDS. EVER.

    Even if your BM tried to strangle your cat and have sex with your future husband, there is no deed bad enough to warrant replacement. Because, not only does it send the message to your ex-BM that she's replaceable, but to your new BM, it feels like she's the second choice, and therefore not a truly "great" friend. Do not replace her. You will get more weird looks from your guests if they find out you replaced your BM than you would if you had uneven sides for your bridal party. No one will care.
  • p.s. I was a replacement once. It was awkward. I loved the bride and was so honored to be asked, but once I got involved in all the BM happenings, it was super awkward with her family and friends. The other BMs were awesome... but I dunno replacing a close friend with another person does seem unnecessary.
  • Thank you for your input ladies!! :)  I truly appreciate it!!

    I talked things over with my FI and my Mom (who has been my go to person with all my questions), and they both agreed 100% that I should ask my SIL to be a bridesmaid (since if my FI had chosen 4 men, she would have been a BM anyway), and my ex-BM is going to be my personal attendant (less commitment but still wanted her in a position of honor, also my SIL's old position so they just kind of switched spots)!!

    My FI told me not to worry about his sisters, that if anything came up he would talk to them, he also noted that my SIL is family, so they should understand since their biggest point before was "family before friends"! 

    What I am doing with his sisters, is allowing them to purchase gowns like the BMs only theirs will be in Black since they are ushering (the BMs will be in Apple Red)!!
    I know that may not be etiquette but his sisters are important to me as well, and they consider ushers to be part of the wedding party, so we have 6 ushers lol (4 men, 2 ladies)!!
    Wedding Countdown Ticker
This discussion has been closed.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards