Texas-Dallas and Ft. Worth

Cake Tastings Today!

Hi everyone! We had three cake tastings today, and I wanted to share my experiences with all of you before I slip into a sugar coma. My fiance and sister were both able to come, and we had a blast.

Hot Chocolates, Hurst - They are really nice and have a lot of fun ideas for designs. The cakes were pretty good and they have interesting flavors. They gave us a cupcake of each flavor and big piles of frosting and fillings, and we got to take home the leftovers. The quality of ingredients is not the best and I'm pretty sure they use mixes for the cakes. The price was the highest of the three we visited. They also do candy buffets for a reasonable price.

Panini, Dallas - Extremely sweet people. The cakes are excellent, wonderfully light and fluffy! They don't have many flavor options, because they choose to do a few things really well rather than do many things not very well. The sample pieces were of a good size, and they gave us a piece to take home for my mom for free. Their price was the lowest of the three. 

Romano's, Dallas - Maybe it's because it was our last stop, but I didn't really like this place. Their showroom is impressive, but I felt like I was on a conveyor belt, being shuffled in and out so quickly. It seemed a bit impersonal. Also, they called this morning to move our appointment from 2:30 to 2:00, and that really turned me off. Their designs are beautiful, but I care much more about the taste, and I didn't think their cakes were very good. They were far too dense and sweet for me. Their price was in the middle, but closer to the high end.

We're going to think about it for a couple of days, but we'll probably get our cake from Panini, though we might have Hot Chocolates do the candy buffet for us.

I hope this helps anyone who is still looking for a bakery!


Re: Cake Tastings Today!

  • fallbride1109fallbride1109 member
    5000 Comments Fifth Anniversary 5 Love Its Name Dropper
    edited December 2011
    Mmmmm, cake tastings!  Fun!

    I was also very unimpressed with Romano's.
  • edited December 2011
    Ugh, now you have me wanting cake Bananna!!  I've heard great things about Panini...yay for an almost check :)


  • edited December 2011
    We have our cake tasting at Romano's tomorrow over lunch (nice and healthy lunch mmm).

    We've had two others:
    Cake Rejoice - cake just ok but the price was great.  Joyce seemed a little unenthused and didn't bring must to the table in the way of designs.
    Delicous Cakes - cake was great and they were really excited about our cake idea and even asked if they could submit it to a magazine.  Yea!  Only bad thing is that they came in twice as expensive as Cake Rejoice and $160 over our cake budget.

    I'm hoping we'll find someone in the middle that is as excited about our cake as we are.

    I was under the impression that Panini's was really expensive.  Glad to see it's not.  MIght have to add them to the list!
  • edited December 2011

    Sounds fun! I was extremely disappointed with Romanos as well. It was the first time my husband ever spit out cake.

    Good luck! What a fun day.

  • edited December 2011
    Bananna what is the price range for panini cakes I tried to call after I saw your post but they are already closed.
  • BanannaPBanannaP member
    1000 Comments
    edited December 2011
    Thanks, girls, it was fun!

    Amber - For 130 servings it's $525. That includes delivery and some simple decorations. We're not doing a groom's cake. And, I forgot that they include a freshly-made small cake for your anniversary in the price.
  • edited December 2011
    Thanks for those tips, I'm going to add Panini's to my list of potentials!
  • amberproamberpro member
    1000 Comments
    edited December 2011
    We tried Panini's, too, and loved it!  2nd choice.  We were told to run screaming in the opposite direction from Romano's by a non-cake vendor, so it didn't even make our tasting list. 

    Glad it went well- now where can I get some cake...
    photo images_zps41edd072.jpg

    Carter born 5/28/11
    BFP 9/27/12 EDD 6/11/13, MC 9wks, no HB

  • edited December 2011
    Yum!  We had our bride and groom's cakes from Paninis. So delicious! I so want some now.
  • edited December 2011
    We also had 3 cake tastings- Colleen's Cakes, Delicious Cakes, and Moonlight Cakes. Delicious Cakes was pretty good but I thought that the cakes were a little expensive. Moonlight Cakes was pretty good as well but only had a couple of flavors. Colleen's Cakes, IMO, was the best! 16 flavors and the cheapest price. She also told us to stay away from Romanos after the FI told her we had a tasting there. But she also referred us to Delicious Cakes
  • edited December 2011
    Ericandsheldon- We went with Colleen and she was on of my favorite vendors!
  • edited December 2011
    shortgirltx: We were going to go with her, but after seeing how much it was going to cost us to pay for the wedding (FMIL was going to pay for the cake and my parents aren't too happy about us getting married) we decided to go to Mexico and get married!! It's gonna be at least $5000 cheaper AND we're also gonna honeymoon there as well!
  • edited December 2011
    I'm sorry to hear about your parents but have fun in Mexico!!  There were a lot of times I wanted to elope.
This discussion has been closed.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards