Wedding Customs & Traditions Forum

Problems changing last name

I always assumed that when I got married I would keep my maiden name.  I feel very strange and anxious at the thought of taking another person's name - and I always had, even as a young girl.  I understand that today - it is not necessary to change your name when you get married, and I intend to keep my maiden name.

I am very much in love with my FI.  We are getting married the summer of 2011.  I can not wait to spend the rest of my life with him.  He is upset that I won't "take his name", however, he is willing to accept that.

However, his family, of course, has a thing or two to say about it.  His mother states - in a very dramatic way - "She won't change her name?! It looks like I won't have a daughter-in-law then!"

His twin brother continues to bash my decision, telling me "that's what lesbions" do and that I have no choice in the matter.  He then picks on his brother that he's "marrying a les-bo" and that he's "not a man".  (immature, I know, but they are the same age)

I really do not feel close with his parents or brother at all.  They come across to me as rude and insulting to people's life decisions (besides this one now).  This is very different than how my parents are.  I never felt comfortable to be myself around them, ever, because they are very harsh to judge and talk about others rudly behind their backs.  Even if I did decide to change my name down the line, I don't want to share their name just because of this feeling.  I feel close to my family and do not want to leave that.  Getting married now-a-days does not mean leaving my family to join his.

This has nothing to do with my love for my FI.  Having my name does not mean that I love him less.  I had made this decision way before we even met. 

How do I deal with the family?  For now, I plan to just ignore everything.  However, I don't want my FI to resent me later for this.

Re: Problems changing last name


  • I plan for our children to have his last name.  I do not plan to hypenate anything.  I was born with this name my parents gave me and I will die with it the same.

    I don't mind if socially I was called by his last name (i.e. by kid's teachers).

    Reciently I have kept my mouth shut about it (he was the one who brought it up,so I know my FI is still a little bitter about the decision).  I am just assuming his family and I are never going to get along!

  • Wow how wonderfully open minded your FILs are.  Geez.  Stand strong as it is your identity, not theirs.  You have a right to choose.  And if you FI accepts it good as he is the only one who should care.
  • Ugh.  They sound like horrible backwoods hillbilly trash.  I would just ignore them and know that I'm better than them.  What does your FI say with his brother says awful things like that?  My FI would have some choice words if his brother insulted me like that. 

    In the end, it really doesn't matter what they think.  
  • If your FI has accepted your decision, I don't think you have anything to worry about.  In laws might complain at first, but over time they will either have to get used to it or learn to shut up about it. 
  • redheadfsuredheadfsu member
    2500 Comments
    edited March 2010
    Whether a woman changes her name (for marriage or for divorce)  is 100% her decision. His family sounds like idiots. Even if your FI wishes you took his name, he needs to tell them to be quiet  out of respect for your decision.

    Planning Bio
    Married 9/15/11

    image
    *This is Not Legal Advice*
  • I think keeping your mouth shut about it is only going to make them think they can badger you into changing your mind.

    Like PPs said- be blunt and it usually makes people shut it. 

    And ditto on the lesbian name change thing, they change their names quite often to show committment. 
    image
  • Oh yeah, I know lesbians change their names - and so does my future brother-in-law.  Buy you know how people like that say obviously ignorant things just to be an ass? 
  • It's sad that you and your future in-laws don't get along, but don't lose sight of the fact that it's a fundamental difference between you and them.  The last name is just one incarnation of your differences, so even if you gave in, you wouldn't get any relief! Don't do anything you don't want to do -- it's your identity, and I hope that instead of badgering you, your future in-laws learn to leave certain topics alone! Good luck and be happy!
  • This has nothing to do with my love for my FI.  Having my name does not mean that I love him less.  I had made this decision way before we even met.

    EXACTLY!

    Your FI should really be defending you to his family. What does he say about their comments?
    my read shelf:
    Meredith's book recommendations, liked quotes, book clubs, book trivia, book lists (read shelf)
    40/112

    Photobucket
  • I was thinking of taking his name and keeping my own name so that I can sign either way and its all good! I really want to keep my own name for all the same reasons you mentioned. I don't understand why people get so huffy puffy about it...honestly, people get married 3 and 4 times and that seems to be less offensive and up debate less than a woman who decides to keep her own name...

    Seriously, its your damn name... you do what you want girl!
  • In Response to <a href="http://forums.theknot.com/Sites/theknot/Pages/Main.aspx/wedding-boards_customs-traditions_problems-changing-last-name?plckFindPostKey=Cat:Wedding BoardsForum:36Discussion:8c675d13-d839-48d4-bcf2-84963ec36d5fPost:177dcbf6-7b36-46c1-9d0c-a01359859646">Re: Problems changing last name</a>:
    [QUOTE]Oh my. I know how evil ridiculous in-laws are like! Don't most girls? lol. I think weddings bring out the worst in some people! I had a situation similar to this with my in laws. I had said that I wanted to change my MIDDLE name to my last name and then still take my fiance's name. I wasn't planning on hyphenating or anything...mearly keeping my name because my family is a part of who I am. To which my white trash, self centered in laws replied "well, you should just stay single then" and " when you get married you are supposed to forget about your family and start a life with your new family" to which i promptly and stearnly replied "Sorry, you misunderstood...and i am not forgetting about my family, I have a fantastic family and they are part of who I am. NOT only that, but it is MY decision, not yours. You got to decide what you were doing when YOU got married...now its me and Dan's turn" Needless to say, we don't speak to them anymore and they uninvited themselves to our wedding. They really are the lowest of the low. Moral of the story: Do what YOU want and as the ladies said up there, tell them you don't care what they think. Who needs in laws anyway, right? lol.
    Posted by mininickle[/QUOTE]

    Holy crap.  I thought the dark ages were over. 
  • In Response to <a href="http://forums.theknot.com/Sites/theknot/Pages/Main.aspx/wedding-boards_customs-traditions_problems-changing-last-name?plckFindPostKey=Cat:Wedding%20BoardsForum:36Discussion:8c675d13-d839-48d4-bcf2-84963ec36d5fPost:cfc45c03-76c3-456b-bca5-4a0e1ee0315c">Re: Problems changing last name</a>:
    [QUOTE]This has nothing to do with my love for my FI.  Having my name does not mean that I love him less.  I had made this decision way before we even met. EXACTLY! Your FI should really be defending you to his family. What does he say about their comments?
    Posted by msmerymac[/QUOTE]

    To be honest, he doesn't say anything.  Actually, my FI is the one who brings it up in coversation, so I know he's not OK with it.  However, he never gave me the whole "I don't want to get married if you don't take my name" speech.  He's accepting it, with a massive attitude.

    His cousin has the same first name as me - so someone said "hey, you'll be the second one with that name" and he said "no, she won't, she refuses to take my name".  I am assuming he is agreeing with his family.
This discussion has been closed.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards