This will be our first holiday as a married couple. While we'll probably spent one night with his mother's family (his parents are divorced), in the past we've spent the other with our rabbi's, but this year I'd prefer we do something on our own (I don't like to go to his dad's family's gathering because you wouldn't even know it's RH and they don't keep kosher).
I want to buy some stuff, nothing too expensive, to get us going for the holiday (we didn't get as much Judaica as I'd hope). I've seen a few things on Google and saw a few nice things on Jewish Bazaar; wondering if anyone could recommend a website or store (NYC area) they've bought or gotten gifts from for me to get some things.
TIA.