There is a seller on Etsy who makes beautiful garters at very reasonable prices. I didn't want to copy the recent weddings I've been to w/ Seahawks garters, so I came across this website and she sells both the toss and keepsake garter for $25! She also can customize them in your colors for the same price. Not bad if you have unique colors, in my opinion
http://www.etsy.com/shop/creativebridal