I sent my 1400 word article to the editor who had requested it, explaining that I knew it was short of 2000 words but it pretty much covered everything I knew on the topic, and I was open to suggestions. He just sent me a curt email telling me that it's too short (hello, I told him that already) and that I need to add 600 words before he can send it out for peer review.
Peer review? Seriously? It's the intro section to a buyer's guide, it's not exactly PNAS. I get that it's short of the target, but he used the word "unacceptable" and now I feel bad. It's not like I volunteered. They asked me to write it and now I regret agreeing to do it. I figured I could scrape together 2000 words. I guess I'd better go think of 600 more.
Maybe I'll add a concluding section on kittens. Who doesn't like kittens?
�