I am at a loss! I spoke with my FILs asking for a budget for the rehearsal dinner since they so graciously offered to cover it. The response was, "Something along the lines of Olive Garden." Luckily, my FI is an italian food snob and won't go with Olive Garden. Plus, there's no Olive Garden in downtown Seattle.
I'm wide open for suggestions! Somewhere that is inexpensive (along the lines of Olive Garden prices

), in or around downtown Seattle, and preferably has a separated room or section to fit 30-35 people.
I had originally told them that we were doing pizza (Tutta Bella), but they nixed that most likely assuming that I was suggesting Pizza Hut or something of that sort. I may have to go back to that and explain it better.