October 2012 Weddings

REALLY?!??!? Vent...

Bit of back story: Back when we were getting our guest list together, we asked FMIL for a list of family we should invite. She came back with a list of nearly 100 people (20 of which were family). Venue holds 160, but we are capping it off at 130 for monetary reasons. Plus, FI had never even met most of the people she had on her list. We wanted to keep this as small and intimate as possible. (Honestly, neither of us wanted anyone other than family at the wedding to begin with!) We told her that we couldn't accommodate all of the guests she had written down, and had her scale back the list. She wasn't very happy about it, but cut the list.

For months now, when I'm not around, FMIL has been badgering FI about the guest list. At one point she even told him that the more people he invited, the more presents we would get, so we should let her invite all of those people. Seriously, woman?!

So two of my uncles (and one of their wives) mentioned they will be unable to attend the wedding due to one reason or another. I was sad about this as I am fairly close to both of these uncles. I mentioned it to FI a couple weeks ago, and it hasn't been brought up since.

Until last night. I asked FMIL for her list of addresses last week. She called me last night to ask me some random question (FI is out of town), and while on the phone, she mentioned that she heard my uncles were unable to make it. Then she asked if that meant there was more room on the guest list for her friends.

Um, NO! We didn't want these people at our wedding to begin with. What makes you think that since my uncles aren't coming that we somehow magically want strangers participating in the most important day of our lives? This is something I feel very, very strongly about.

This caught me way off guard too! I just stuttered something about not being 100% sure they couldn't make it and got off the phone. I can't WAIT till FI gets back in town.
Wedding Countdown Ticker

Re: REALLY?!??!? Vent...

  • In Response to <a href="http://forums.theknot.com/Sites/theknot/Pages/Main.aspx/wedding-club-boards_october-2012-weddings_really-vent?plckFindPostKey=Cat:Wedding%20Club%20BoardsForum:56b9bcef-1e34-456e-81f5-cfaa107456b2Discussion:7f5ded35-44ed-45ee-b832-ff730c290b42Post:1631f907-1730-477e-817c-fd08c449d4ea">REALLY?!??!? Vent...</a>:
    [QUOTE]Bit of back story: Back when we were getting our guest list together, we asked FMIL for a list of family we should invite. She came back with a list of nearly 100 people (20 of which were family). Venue holds 160, but we are capping it off at 130 for monetary reasons. Plus, FI had never even met most of the people she had on her list. We wanted to keep this as small and intimate as possible. (Honestly, neither of us wanted anyone other than family at the wedding to begin with!) We told her that we couldn't accommodate all of the guests she had written down, and had her scale back the list. She wasn't very happy about it, but cut the list. For months now, when I'm not around, FMIL has been badgering FI about the guest list. At one point she even told him that the more people he invited, the more presents we would get, so we should let her invite all of those people. Seriously, woman?! So two of my uncles (and one of their wives) mentioned they will be unable to attend the wedding due to one reason or another. I was sad about this as I am fairly close to both of these uncles. I mentioned it to FI a couple weeks ago, and it hasn't been brought up since. Until last night. I asked FMIL for her list of addresses last week. She called me last night to ask me some random question (FI is out of town), and while on the phone, she mentioned that she heard my uncles were unable to make it. Then she asked if that meant there was more room on the guest list for her friends. Um, NO! We didn't want these people at our wedding to begin with. What makes you think that since my uncles aren't coming that we somehow magically want strangers participating in the most important day of our lives? This is something I feel very, very strongly about. This caught me way off guard too! I just stuttered<strong> something about not being 100% sure they couldn't make it and got off the phone</strong>. I can't WAIT till FI gets back in town.
    Posted by semay23[/QUOTE]<div>
    </div><div>I think you handled it well and you should stick with that line. Plans can change. I assume that even though you've gotten a verbal "regrets" from your uncles, you're still going to send them an invitation. It's quite possible that when they actually get the invitation they may be able to come. If she continues, repeat that you've got your guest list finalized and that you can't accomodate any more people then quickly change the subject. Hopefully she'll get the message. GL!

    </div>
    Daisypath Anniversary tickers Follow Me on Pinterest
  • CFM said exactly what i was going to say. You should still send your uncles invites because things could change.  That is pretty bold of her to basically ask you to do a B list.  If she keeps it up I woud be tempted to say to her 'if you really want to see these people so badly, why don't you throw a party and invite them!"
    Image and video hosting by TinyPic
  • Is she contributing financially at all?  If not, then she needs to understand that you have complete control over the guest list.  Sorry you are going through this.
    dscf4745-2
    Anniversary
  • In Response to <a href="http://forums.theknot.com/Sites/theknot/Pages/Main.aspx/wedding-club-boards_october-2012-weddings_really-vent?plckFindPostKey=Cat:Wedding Club BoardsForum:56b9bcef-1e34-456e-81f5-cfaa107456b2Discussion:7f5ded35-44ed-45ee-b832-ff730c290b42Post:6de7c4fa-887b-4642-bb93-0b2b10696f67">Re: REALLY?!??!? Vent...</a>:
    [QUOTE]Is she contributing financially at all?  If not, then she needs to understand that you have complete control over the guest list.  Sorry you are going through this.
    Posted by ystaalenburg[/QUOTE]

    No, FI and I are paying for 100% of the wedding ourselves.

    FMIL/FFIL paid for all of FSIL's wedding. They spent over $23,000 and there were nearly 300 people there. This is the exact opposite of what FI and I want. Since we are footing the bill, I really didn't think this type of thing would be an issue. *shrugs* I guess she just still imagines some giant event like her daughter had.
    Wedding Countdown Ticker
  • Oh my!! I'm sorry that you have to deal with this. My FMIL wanted a bunch more of her friends to be invited too but dropped it once the STDs went out.

    I would let FI deal with it and let them know that until RSVPs start coming in you're not making any decisions.
    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • Not cool FMIL.

    But, I would also be sure that you and your FI are on the EXACT same page about the issue. If your FI is torpedoing this whole guest list thing that could be really bad!
    Pregnancy Ticker
  •   so sorry ,but it happens often  
  • I am always confused when I read these posts and family members want to invite their friends as well. If it is a family friend that maybe you grew up with, that makes some sense, but just a friend that someone knows? I just don't get it.
    Wedding Countdown Ticker
This discussion has been closed.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards