snyderlounge.com, part of snydereventrentals.com, had church pews and a bar that I loved. They also have rocking chairs. Some of theie items are not pictured on the website, so just ask them about what you are looking for. Hope this helps!
If you are looking for great vintage rentals in the Southeast area...I highly recommend Mao Thao. She has loads of items...white rustic church pews, farm tables, vintage chia, Victorian couches, etc. She is very reasonably priced and will travel to most places in the Southeast as she is based in the Atlanta area. Here is a link to her blog and contact information with a few pictures of just some of the items she has for rental: http://fourinchfold.blogspot.com/. If you need something closer to the Charleston area...Snyder rentals is a popular company to use as well as ohhevents.com. Both places have church pews but aren't as rustic looking as Mao's. I'd recommend Mao over using any of the other companies. Hope this helps! We are using farm tables, white church pews and a Victorian couch for our plantation wedding in May from Mao and I can't wait!