this is the code for the render ad
Pennsylvania-Philadelphia

This is why you don't hire family..

FI's twin brother is a graphic designer and he is doing all of our stationery. I don't even remember discussing it with him to do it in the first place, it was just an automatic decision that we never really thought about again. He did our STDs, and I thought they were neat and unique but didn't really go with the style of our wedding. I let it go though, because we were short on time.

Now for our invitations, I tried to steer him more toward the romantic, vintage, classic look of our wedding, but maybe I wasn't clear enough. He showed us a mock up last night and the more I look at it the more I dislike it. To me, it is becoming very clear that he is a graphic designer and not an invitation designer. There are basic elements that I think look very wrong. And to be fair, he is a really good graphic designer. He works for a magazine and has done billboards and websites and commercials and they are all very cool. I tried my hardest to hide my disapointment, and he asked what things I'd want him to change so I told him some things that could make it better. Truthfully though, I just don't like it at all. FI says he likes it, but he also said has similar taste to his brother and is really not that picky anyway. The thing is, he worked really hard on it and he's doing all of this as a gift to us, for free, so I feel really bad about not liking it and wanting him to change it. I'm trying to look at it like I am getting exactly what I want for everything else in the wedding, so it's ok if this one aspect isn't what I want, as long as FI is happy. It's just hard to have that perspective when I think the actual style of the stationery clashes with the rest of the wedding.

Sigh. I just needed to vent. I talked to FI about it alone last night, and he listened to my concerns and wants me to be happy but it puts him in a difficult position too. I will try to post what he showed us when I get home from work to see if anyone has any ideas on easy ways to improve it.

Thanks for listening : /

image
Wedding Countdown Ticker

Re: This is why you don't hire family..

  • edited December 2011
    Sorry you didn't like it.  Did you give him any samples or ideas before he started?
  • FutureMrsTCTFutureMrsTCT member
    1000 Comments
    edited December 2011
    I had this exact same problem, only it was with my Uncle (aunt's DH). He's an artist, and graphic designer - so I figured - wow, I've always loved his artwork, so why not ask him to do it.

    Biggest mistake I've ever made. He either didn't want to do it, or didn't care to do it - b/c what he ended up doing was something I could have put together. I wrote an extensive email to him trying to describe exactly what we were going for as far as our style. What he gave me was a bad poster. I didn't get it either since he's an amazing artist and has a great eye for things.

    It was hard, but in the end, I told the truth - only highly sugar coated...I said, thanks for your time and effort, but the style of the invites created didn't really fit with our venue or the idea we were taking.

    Obviously with it being your FI's twin, things will be even harder. If you can find one thing you like about it, then focus on that and definitely see if FBIL can make the invites geared towards your theme. What may help is finding a style of invite you kind of like or that best exemplifies your style - it may help him to have a visual of what you're going for.

    Good luck!
    *~~*The Future Mrs. Coulter-Thurley*~~*
    Siggy Challenge Pic with BM
    Image and video hosting by TinyPic Wedding Countdown Ticker
  • edited December 2011
    I did show him some that I liked but his way of designing is to not look at others' work so that he isn't influenced. I'm thinking about referencing them again though in hopes that he will at least try to make it look more like an invitation.

    image
    Wedding Countdown Ticker
  • edited December 2011
    Thanks, TCT, that is really good advice. Not having him do it is definitely out. I do have a good relationship with him so I would rather have horrific invites than damage that. And there are aspects of it that I do like, so maybe I will approach it more that like this aspect so much that I would have wanted to see it played out more.

    image
    Wedding Countdown Ticker
  • ev4149ev4149 member
    500 Comments Third Anniversary
    edited December 2011
    Maybe pick a font you like, or something  that he HAS to use (a certain flower, swirls, etc.).  Then, he can work his design based on the font or design.  If you give him one piece that is a "must", maybe he will be able to work the rest of the invitation around it.
    Wedding Countdown Ticker
  • edited December 2011
    Great idea EV. Making me re-think taking that friend up on her offer to design my stationary....
    Wedding Countdown Ticker
    Planning Bio
    Philly Siggy Challenge: The Ring!
    image
  • edited December 2011
    Yes, that is good advice too. Luckily, I did know the fonts he was using way in advance and I love them. He used them, but the placements seem weird to me and the overal style is just not what it should be.

    image
    Wedding Countdown Ticker
  • angel33284angel33284 member
    100 Comments
    edited December 2011
    The thing you have to understand is that invitations are not a form of graphic design, at all. It's just a bunch of fancy fonts laid out on a piece of card stock, with no real artistry to it. It's just there to deliver information, whereas graphic design is there to engage the viewer. Just tell him you wanted a more traditional look and thanks for offering to help.
This discussion has been closed.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards