I just booked at Le Jardin.I know of one other wedding there and two proms. Everyone loved the food and they were satisfied with the service as well. The wedding was several years back I believe but the proms were recent.They let me pay for a tasting dinner before I signed the contract which a lot of places won't allow. The food and service was amazing. (there were other couples who had signed their contracts and they were treated equlally well) The servers and bar staff were great. Their prices are really fair and they will negotiate to make a package to suit you. I ended up with everything I wanted and paying less than I would have if I went elswhere.I was about to book elswhere (had the appt already set) when I found them and I am so glad I did.I am planning an off-season wedding so maybe that also makes a difference.Even now that the contract is signed the people are still helpful and will respond to questions really quickly. (never longer than 24-48hours for the most part...even though this is their high season) Even a cab driver I had loved this place.
The only down side was I don't like gold too much and they do decorate with to much for me. The rest is perfect.I would say maybe you could also have a tasting so you can see for yourself. (they don't charge much and you still get another when you do sign)EDIT I haven't been to the other place mentioned so I don't have an opinion. Maybe make a list of everything you MUST have and how much you want to spend and after the halls present you with their costs see which matches best, or present what you want and what you want to pay and see if one will try to make it work. Also, maybe a tasting at both places, it would cost money but you could actually taste before you decide.