I did go with It's Icing on the Cake after all. They were easier to get a hold of, we liked their design better, they're closer and about $200 cheaper.
Here's my cake:

Yay! It's going to be mint chocolate flavored.

110 Invited

76 Are Ready to Party!

34 Are Missing Out

0 Need to Respond
RSVP Date: February 21
March 2012 Siggy Challenge: Rings

Mine

His
My Wedding Blog(Updated Daily)
