We were married last weekend at the Hotel Utica, and had the reception catered by the Blue Flag Room.
The food was the best food I have ever had at a wedding, or other catered event. They served 120 people, and the food tasted like regualr plated dinners at a high end restaurant. It did not have the taste or texture that often comes with "banquet food."
If you are getting married, or having any catered event, anywhere near the Utica, NY area, you can NOT go wrong with them as your caterer. They also have a restaurant, so you can have your event at their establishment in Union Station - which has amazing architecture itself.
Dave Morgan, the owner, was easy to deal with and very accomodating. We had an extensive tasting dinner before we selected them (unlike some places that make you sign a contract first) so we knew the food was first-rate.