FI and I went to Leo Hamel after getting a rec. from his coworker. I also checked out their reviews on Yelp so we made a trip. We found both our wedding bands at decent prices and they're not pushy or snooty at all. Usually I feel very uncomfortable trying jewelry on but that wasn't the case. I can also take my rings there anytime I want for a free cleaning and they have free beer - that's a plus! I found my band from that 'hearts on fire' collection and it's oh so perty and sparkly!
http://www.leohamel.com/