The best port in the Caribbean is...

MissOwl

and GO!

AllyG303

St Martin!

beersnob

St. Martin was my hubbys favorite. We just sat at the sunset beach bar and drank and ate all day watching the planes. Sounds lame but we had a blast.

Also loved St. Croix as we snorkled for like 6 hours. Very clean and lovely beach.

Antigua was ok just sat around on the beach being bums but it was nice, was not very impressed by the town and island itself.

Barbados was not what we expected. Very drab and boring to us.

St. Lucia was beautiful as you get to see alot of different things beach rain forest very lush and tropical

orianita3

Beach wise? Turk and Caicos

As a non-cruise visitor? Puerto Rico

For shopping? St Martin

It depends!!!!!!!!!!!

MissOwl

yay thanks ladies. keep 'em coming!

[Deleted User]

I loved St. Thomas. Picturesquely beautiful, and amazing snorkling. It helps that it was the first caribbean island I had ever been to, but it was still amazing. The hillsides at sunset were gorgeous.

SuMmErKuTiE

Curacao and St. John are my favorites. We also love the Riviera Maya region in Mexico.. Cancun, Playa del Carmen, Cozumel, etc..

I've only heard amazing things about Turks & Caicos and can't wait to see for myself :0)

girlinchicago

St. John and St. Lucia for the overall scenery and beautiful beaches

Wiscisbliss

A ton depends on what you do in the port.

We loved Roatan (private island with amazing snorkeling: Maya Key)

Grand Cayman (7 mile beach, Sting Ray City)

St. Thomas (Coki Beach)

St. Kitts (Historical tour)

Magdala9

We just got back from a cruise to the Western Carribbean.  Belize and Grand Cayman were absolutely gorgeous.

Laurie&Brandon

St. Lucia and St. Thomas!