I'd asked for suggestions on where to find good vintage jewelry a bit ago, and a few of you suggested Main Street in Hopkins. I went to Hopkins Antique Mall today and found a great necklace, bracelet, and earrings set for $40! It's light but chunky looking, hammered silver. Most people wouldn't look at it and think "Hmm, wedding jewelry!" but dainty isn't my style, and I love it!
I should've taken a picture at the shop; FI's home and I don't want him to see!