Wine Cellar at Cosimo's on Union in Newburgh...opinions??

gingern

We are thinking of using the wine cellar at Cosimo's for our rehearsal dinner...but just can't decide for sure...I'm not a huge fan of their food, but I think the wine cellar is so neat...do any of you have experiences, good or bad, to share??

Thanks!

BellaSposa223

If you don't really like the food why would you consider it?

gingern

The decision is not based on just the food...

In Response to <a href="http://forums.theknot.com/Sites/theknot/Pages/Main.aspx/local-wedding-boards_new-york-hudson-valley_wine-cellar-cosimos-union-newburghopinions?plckFindPostKey=Cat:Local Wedding BoardsForum:113Discussion:be8399a7-ffbc-4618-a388-d86951e01c3cPost:e537562e-8993-4fc7-824a-2e497ad4272f">Wine Cellar at Cosimo's on Union in Newburgh...opinions??</a>:
[QUOTE]...but I think the wine cellar is so neat...
Posted by gingern[/QUOTE]

Bat937

Personally I LOVE the food as Cosimo's.  I've never had a bad meal there.  My friend's husband used to use the wine cellar for his company Christmas Parties every year and I never heard a complaint. 

There is a a review of the wine cellar on Trip Advisor from someone who had their rehearsal dinner there and they gave it 5 out of 5.

TerriandJoe

I have to agree with Bella on this one!

Tue a lot of factors go into selecting the place for the night before your most special of days surrounded by family and friends. But the food SHOULD also be considered.

Selecting a place thats unique, or charming, or cool, or close is nice. But peopl will remember the food. Especialy if they don't like it.

I've never been, so I can't comment on the place, but do you want your guests to say that "Ginger and Fred picked a really cool place for their rehearsal, too bad the food sucked."

Granted yes, I'm going to extremes, but hopefully you get what I'm saying.

Find a place that you like. and a place where you (and FI) enjoiy the food. Let the other factors be used as a secondary guide. Or write out a list of the places where you like the food and rank each one with the practicality and uniquenesss to give your rehearsal dinner that special touch.

Ww had pizza in a lakeside restaurant. and know what? It was perfect!

Good luck!

(You can totally oignore what I'm saying, but remember this, go with a place where you, the bride, at least like the food. It doesn't have to be your favorite restaurant, but should at least be a place you enjoy being)

You can always mention the wine cellar in your out of town bags if you wanted to list a unique place for your guets to try.