I found a BBQ company that only charges $10.75 a person! I've been worried about doing our own food, but this would be about the same cost.

This buffet would include 2 meat choices and 3 sides, and I'm sure we could still supplement any other food we want (especially for the cocktail hour) ourselves. They also have a dual "All Occasions Catering" company that does more traditional wedding food...for about the same price! I'm like literally jumping up and down right now. I'm leaning towards BBQ (our wedding IS Memorial Day weekend, after all!), what do you think? It's an evening wedding (i.e. we're feeding people during dinner time), so would BBQ be weird?
Edit: Here's the website if you're curious -
http://www.bubbs.com/